6 ms·
Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- sammcd 17y agoI really think there is some room here for blogs and news sites to provide their own short urls that people can use to link to them. They might be able to reap the benefits of a higher page rank. Another good side affect is that urls might get cleaned up a bit in hopes that they will get copied straight into a tweet. I would love a web with short copy and pastable urls.
- trezor 17y agoIt pretty much says it all when this company's* only hope of turning a profit was getting someone to buy them. If your business plan is getting bought and leaving someone else with the bill, you have no business plan. (*) Not entirely sure I would consider a 20 line PHP script a company.
- treitnauer 17y agoWhat about running an URL shortener on your own domain? Here are 10 tools to do it: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=752144 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=752144
- jasonkester 17y agoBusiness Opportunity: - Buy these guys out for whatever they ask - Repurpose the site as a Jenny Craig style weight-loss business (or pretty much any other business that you like) on the site - Redirect all those useless tr.im links to your new tr.im homepage Suddenly you have a business with 10M unique visitors every day. It's like buying ALL the advertising, all at once. You now have 40 zillion inbound links to your thing. If you can't make money from that somehow, there's something seriously wrong. So yeah, just do the big bait & switch. When the complaints roll in, 301 them over to the old tr.im team. After all, it's them who sold you the domain, so they should take the blame.
- pj 17y agoAnd the house of cards begins its collapse. Let's hope it crumbles fast and we can rid the web of these shorteners before they cause more damage to the future of the internet.
- endtwist 17y agoOne failure does not a trend make. If another service flops in the next few months, then yes I agree, the house of cards is collapsing, but right now that statement is a little premature.
- tlrobinson 17y agoIt's inevitable, whether it's in the next few months or in 5 years, we're going to end up with millions of broken links.
- palish 17y agoOh no! ... I'm sure we'll survive.
- iheartmemcache 17y agoBroken links have been happening since the web began. Any time you've made any web request, there's been a SPOF(1). In fact, think back to 2002-- remember when a good number of links you'd click were dead? When was the last time in recent memory you've had that happen? In fact, I argue that the web has a lower percentage of broken links today than back in the day. In 5 years, we'll likely have even less. (1) Yeah yeah, I know, a drastic over simplification. There's Foundry LB hardware, round-robin DNS at different sites, BGP failover, etc.
- ams1 17y agohopefully bit.ly's api will expand to cover stuff you could do with tr.im, like aggregate user statistics-- seen in dave winer's 40 twits app (http://dave.40twits.com/ http://dave.40twits.com/)
- TweedHeads 17y agoTwo things: First, I don't like URL shorteners for this same reason. Every web server should be in charge of managing long and short urls easily with just one line of code. Second, how expensive it is to keep the site running? $10 a month for a cheap hosting service and they can make more than that with just google ads. Now, if they want to live largely just by shortening urls then no, it won't pay the bills.
- ams1 17y agomore details on why it went down: http://blog.tr.im/post/159369789/tr-im-r-i-p http://blog.tr.im/post/159369789/tr-im-r-i-p
- larrywright 17y agoA couple of points: 1) Url shorteners aren't going away. Like it or not, there's a need, particularly for things like Twitter. 2) I think it's more than that. They did more than just shorten urls, they also tracked analytics on those links, clickthrough rates and the like. You can view charts and graphs about how often links are clicked on, etc. Multiply that by millions of links, and it's not an inconsequential amount of storage and bandwidth. I think you way overestimate the capabilities of a $10 hosting package.
- jerf 17y agoAll the $10 package would have to do is forward the user, though. It wouldn't have to do all that stuff. That said, it probably isn't quite a $10 package. On the other hand, it probably wouldn't take much, especially if you cared to take the time to write a custom-purpose HTTP-redirection server. Actually, that would sort of be an interesting programming challenge: How small and efficient can you get such a server?
- bmelton 17y agoBut if that's all it's doing, where is its differentiation between it and the hundreds of other URL shortening services. You CAN run a social network cheaply, but good luck competing with Facebook / MySpace / Orkut / Friendfeed / Livejournal / et al. Offering the service with the least amount of features can sometimes be a winning idea, but in this space, I'm not entirely sure that it's doable, considering the major feature works pretty similarly across all tr.im's competition.
- matt1 17y agoAny guesses on how much it costs to keep one of these running in terms of money or effort?
- soult 17y agoIf you only want to do redirection, no statistics stuff, then pretty cheap. If they don't want submission of new links, even cheaper, they could even run it on shared hosting.
- scorpion032 17y agoIt should be fairly straight forward to dump these "lookup table" databases to Appengine, in which case, it wouldn't really cost anything. With many of these url shortners going out of business pretty soon now, anybody willing to try and make this a business opportunity?
- dannyr 17y agoThese Url shorteners became popular because of Twitter. Twitter should handle links differently (e.g. not count Urls against the 140 char limit).
- jorgeortiz85 17y agoSMS doesn't care what kind of characters you're sending.
- TweedHeads 17y agoSMS can't click on links either, so just send the word LINK and get done with it.
- slig 17y agotwitter should have their own url shortener.
- wmeredith 17y agoI believe they do and it's called bit.ly...
- tlrobinson 17y agoIronically bit.ly thinks tr.im is spam: http://bit.ly/2JXXZ http://bit.ly/2JXXZ
- drawkbox 17y agoI think there is good behind short urls but they should all be same domain. Relying on a third party for links embedded everywhere will now be worthless for users of tr.im. Short urls are good but also readable urls are better. The whole short url thing stems from twitter and is being originally based on SMS. But it is breaking the web when this happens and not knowing what you are clicking on is a security problem. I could see a case for a corporate service for short urls like mycompany.tr.im/YHu8 or just mycompany.com/YHu8 etc. Then it redirects to a longer url within the same company. But it needs to be guaranteed to be there as long as the linked to endpoint exists.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoI wonder how easy it would be to create an archive.org equivalent for URL shorteners. Any shortener could pay a fee (based on the number of links they had) in order to join, in exchange for which they'd get some form of certification that they were members. The archiving service would be a nonprofit with publicly viewable finances, and would make copies of partial or full link databases available for further download and backup. If it caught on at all, it would do two things well: 1. it would mean that there were few good reasons to use an un-certified link shortener, and 2. it would make the transition to a post-shortener world much simpler and more graceful: twitter could just download the full data set and repeal the character limit for URLs.
- tlrobinson 17y agohttp://permanize.org/ http://permanize.org/
- codyrobbins 17y agoYeah, but how is Permanize any different than a URL shortener itself — what happens when Permanize goes out of business?
- pronoiac 17y agoThey're not hard to crawl & save locally, at least: http://archiveteam.org/index.php?title=TinyURL http://archiveteam.org/index.php?title=TinyURL
- superjared 17y agoA large reason of why URL shorteners are hard to maintain is the incredible amount of spam they receive. At Slicehost we seem to get spamcop emails every day about yet another URL shortener someone has created because the spammers will use their link instead of the real URL.
- pg 17y agoMost url shorteners are banned on HN (in the sense that stories using them are autokilled) for that reason.
- ivankirigin 17y agoYou could auto-lengthen the URLs. Twitter has a useful tool for this, e.g. http://search.twitter.com/hugeurl?url=http%3A%2F%2Ftinyurl.com%2F5rw4zb http://search.twitter.com/hugeurl?url=http%3A%2F%2Ftinyurl.c...
- trezor 17y agoOr you could simply not use stupid URL shorteners which have absolutely no purpose anywhere on the internet. That one website (twitter) has a post limit of 140 characters doesn't mean we should spread the stupidity to everywhere else.
- ivankirigin 17y agoI get a lot of value from bitly's analytics. Also, with their pushing clients like AIR apps, iphone apps, and email readers to include referrers, your site's analytics are going to get a lot better. URL shortening done wrong sucks. Don't use anything besides those that are really serious. Right now, bitly is the best option.
- trezor 17y agoIf you want analysis. why not use one of the numerous proven tools out there already, designed for this specificly? Not trolling. This is a serious question.
- YuriNiyazov 17y agoWhat is "a minor amount"? I'd buy it for $1000
- Mystalic 17y agoSame. Maybe they'll get bought with this.
- telegraph 17y agoMay I ask why? How does one monetize URL shortening, anyway?
- YuriNiyazov 17y agoFrankly, I don't know right now, but $1000 seems to be obscenely low for a site that gets what seems to be a decent amount of traffic on the web.
- mryall 17y agoI'd buy the domain name, but I suspect it will go for a lot more than $1000.
- YuriNiyazov 17y agoIf they were trying to sell the whole package, including the domain name, which is required for the service to continue supporting all the existing links, and no one would buy it even "for a token amount", then why would the domain name alone go for more than that?
- mryall 17y agoBecause I think "a token amount" is (much) more than $1000 for a business. As it is for a short and readable domain name.
- sachinag 17y agoBecause the domain doesn't cost anything to maintain. The service has hosting and bandwidth costs, which must be relatively substantial for a service of their scale.
- joshu 17y agoNot surprised in the slightest...
- jorgeortiz85 17y agoStartups die for many reasons, but I can't help but feel the ones tr.im gives are a little dishonest. There is no way for us to monetize URL shortening -- users won't pay for it Users won't pay for web search either, and that has monetized very well. We just can't justify further devleopment since Twitter has all but annointed [sic] bit.ly the market winner. Umm, when tr.im got into this business, Twitter had "anointed" tinyurl the "market winner". If it was worth it to compete against tinyurl regardless, why isn't it worth it to compete against bit.ly?
- nir 17y agoWhen they got into the business, Twitter wasn't such a big deal, though. (Personally I believe Twitter will go back to not being a big deal in a few years, but so would URL shortening in general)
- minsight 17y ago"Users won't pay for web search either, and that has monetized very well." Tell that to excite, altavista, yahoo, etc...
- jmonegro 17y agoHeck, Microsoft used tr.im
- radley 17y agoThis is a reference to "tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service, effective immediately." Please don't make up your own titles, especially when they don't match the content.
- callahad 17y agoIn know that in the past TinyURL has adopted the domain and databases for failed shorteners in the interest of preventing link rot. Maybe Tr.im should toss an email to Gilby?
- jdr5 17y agothere must be enough content/news websites they could partner with. twitter is not the only business out there
- acangiano 17y agoApparently they can't afford a spellchecker either.
- ajg1977 17y agoRather than say that no one was interested for "token amounts" of money, I wish they would put the service up on eBay or accept closed envelope bids. I'm sure they would get something for it, I myself would be extremely if the price was right. That said there seems to be the same air of fatalism in both their attempts to sell the service and the reasons for giving it up.
- rythie 17y agoThis could be damaging to Twitter since it will raise a lot questions about the viability of short urls. It may force them to either buy bit.ly or start their own service.
- jbellis 17y agohttp://blog.tr.im/post/159369789/tr-im-r-i-p http://blog.tr.im/post/159369789/tr-im-r-i-p > this required significant development investment and server expansion to accommodate. tr.im has thousands and thousands of users, creating tens of thousands of URLs per day 10K urls per day x 1000 hits for statistics = 10M hits per day, each of which is a read (duh) but also a write to keep a hit count. That's 120 reads + 120 writes per second. Most of the distributed nosql options can easily handle that on a single node, and the non-distributed ones generally have even higher one-node throughput. Not to be an armchair architect, but url mapping is pretty simple. Sounds like they were using a bad tool for the job if they were having to throw hardware at it.
- iheartmemcache 17y agoAn avg of 240 dbIO/s is entirely different from peak time IO/s. When someone like Jeff Atwood posts a link using their service, they could easily see 10x the volume. Volume might be really stagnant for 45 minutes, then bam, 10 percent of their req's for the hour come in within a 2-3 minute span. Judging by their blog-post, I'm assuming they needed to have the infrastructure to handle that kinda load. Either way, I modded you up for a pretty thorough analysis (and because I largely agree with you (it basically is a mapped 301 Location: http://newsite/) http://newsite/)). From my armchair standpoint(1), a 256 mb slice + Redis + nginx should be able to handle 10x the volume easy. (1) Well not quite armchair, a good 30 percent of my firm's business is directly related to scaling.
- mahmud 17y agoWell not quite armchair, a good 30 percent of my firm's business is directly related to scaling. Your user name didn't hint at that at all.
- SwellJoe 17y agoInteresting that one of the commenters is Dave Winer, and he seems to think tr.im represents viable business opportunities.
- rishi 17y agoHow much to purchase your service?
- codyrobbins 17y agoGiven that they're shutting down, why isn't Tr.im simply releasing a complete copy of their URL mappings? There's no need for some industry-wide URL shortener consortium to archive links. Just give out your mappings if you happen to go out of business, so someone could decode your URLs manually if they really needed to.
- mbrubeck 17y agoThere are sure to be some private (unpublished) URIs in there, some of which may contain sensitive information. (Users shouldn't submit such URIs to third-party shorteners, but of course they do anyway.) Edited to add: Of course, those would also be picked up by groups like archiveteam.org that are brute-force crawling the shortener URI space.
- tnaleid 17y agoHere's a more appropriate link to the story: http://tr.im/w7Ba http://tr.im/w7Ba
- pkrumins 17y agothat's what you get when you use url shorteners - broken links to your website.
- known 17y agoDoesn't URL shorteners break PageRank?