3 ms·
Schneier: The War on the Unexpected
- ivankirigin 19y agoIt is at the same time astounding and unsurprising how wrong our security policy setting bureaucrats are. I work with bomb disposal robots. I'm no security expert, but I understand a bit about the field. Not only is the edifice of security extremely inconvenient and abuse-numbing, but it doesn't actually accomplish much of anything. Take a CD. Break it in half. Now you have a plastic knife. The idea that we need to suffer through half measures ignores the most import premise in security: you're only as strong as greatest vulnerability.
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoThis privacy/security issue to me is the most important issue of our generation -- especially with the huge datastores everybody is building. As a libertarian, I want to be completely left alone by government. If I act odd then that's my own business. In fact, eccentricity in thought and action are things we should praise, not report. I do, however, understand that there is going to have to be some uncomfortable trades to make the modern world function. A retired politician once asked, "Nobody wants to record and mine behavior, but lets assume that right now there are five guys in this country with a lethal, contagious disease that they have been trying to spread to as many people as possible. We would really need instant access to everything they've done over the past week or two, and it would be too late to try to pass some kind of law to create a database to get it. Do you collect and mine that information beforehand, preparing yourself to save millions of lives, or do you make the decision that individual privacy is more important than all those lives?" To me it's a tough and complicated issue. At the end of the day, I'm willing to put up with some degree of false positives, even if it involves my detention or arrest if it supports the greater good. False positives are always an issue with any system. The question is whether the current security system is appropriately tuned to the security threat. Does it do more harm than good? Beats me.
- corentin 19y ago> The question is whether the current security system is appropriately tuned to the security threat. Does it do more harm than good? Let's see... The current "security system" of the US seems to consist in attacking other countries, turning its citizens into paranoids and implementing counter-productive policies. It kills thousands of people and destroys wealth. Kind of like a second 9/11, with less intensity. So I guess it does way more harm than good. And please, don't mod this as a troll; that's basically the thesis of Schneier's book "Beyond fear".
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoPlease. Tell us what you really feel. Stop holding back so much. :) I know it's fun to lob rhetorical hand grenades around. The nice thing about the US is that we have a system where failure is accepted. If you don't like the policies or leaders, there will always be someone along later that's more to your liking. We've done all kinds of screwed up stuff -- and all kinds of good stuff. I think it's absolutely important to point out where we're wrong, but a little perspective can be useful too. In my perfect world there would be a lot less government involvement in all of our lives. We would be armed and take care of things like terrorism ourselves right when it happened, instead of farming the responsibility for our security out to big government. But both the left and the right want to take away all of our freedoms and do all the worrying and thinking for us. So that means we turn what should be personal things like health care, personal security, property ownership, and privacy into a huge multi-generational political argument without resolution. And then people complain that the government gets it wrong! I think people are all too happy to take away somebody else's freedom for their pet cause. It's just when somebody else does it to them that they squeal the most. That's why I can only answer what freedoms I am personally willing to trade in the war on terror. I can't and won't make those decisions for other people. I can make one observation, though. As democracies are attacked by terrorism they have a tendency to get more and more restrictive. I would expect the US to follow that pattern -- it has in the past. The thing I am watching is whether those restrictions are temporary or permanent. I don't countenance too much the argument that politicians use fear to keep the war on terror machine humming along. To me that sounds a lot more paranoid than just simply acknowledging that there are people right now who are actively plotting to kill lots of Americans. It's nothing to go beserko about, just something to consider when you make decisions to vote for representatives. If attacks continue over the next few decades, voters will punish politicians who downplay the threat of terrorism. That's just political reality.
- brlewis 19y agoFalse alarms abound. A general sense of alarm is maintained. The government sets itself up as a protector. People do whatever the government wants. The system is working perfectly. What problem is Bruce Schneier trying to solve here?
- savrajsingh 19y agoTo better educate yourself against a common "false alarm" check out this movie--all TSA screeners are req'd to watch it before Thanksgiving. It's produced by the Department of Justice. http://sikhswim.com/2007/10/16/video-on-common-ground/ http://sikhswim.com/2007/10/16/video-on-common-ground/ -Savraj
- corentin 19y agoMy only explanation is that a country is globally as intelligent as the mode of the 51% less intelligent of its citizens (it may even be much less than that due to bipolar politics). I can't explain the braindead politics we have to deal with in western countries otherwise.
- edw519 19y agoSorry, Schneier, but I have to report this to the authorities.
- jimbokun 19y ago"In criminal matters, law enforcement is experienced in separating legitimate tips from unsubstantiated fears, and allocating resources accordingly; we should expect no less from them when it comes to terrorism." I don't think you can expect untrained citizens to distinguish between false alarms and something genuinely concerning. However, it is asinine for a trained police officer to then investigate, find nothing, and arrest someone anyway. There needs to be consequences for anyone in a position of authority for arresting an innocent person simply to cover their own posteriors.
- juanpablo 19y agoUSA is becoming a scary place to live.
- cellis 19y agoAlas, this may be the beginning of the end for startup news as I once knew it: a forum free from the messiness of politics.
- rms 19y agoThe sky is falling!