48 ms·
NHTSA to require backup cameras on all vehicles
- russell 13y agoGood idea. While they're at it get rid of those passenger side convex mirrors, "objects are closer than they appear." One of the functions of a rear view mirror is to tell you where objects are behind you when you are changing lanes in heavy traffic. You can cover your blind spot by proper adjustment of your side mirror.
- bencpeters 13y agoDon't forget that in some areas of the country, we get snow pretty regularly - in my experience back-up camera lenses get completely covered by road grit in snowy zones pretty quickly - makes it hard to rely on for something critical like highway visibility for a few months a year.
- RealGeek 13y agoIt is not an issue at all. It happened 3 times with me during the whole winter, and I quickly wiped and cleaned the lens. The windows and mirrors get dirty too, we often clean them.
- dfc 13y agoWhen you say "it happened three times" this whole winter do you mean "it snowed three times"? I live in Syracuse, NY. We get 100+ inches every year, so I have some experience with the slushy salt+sand mixture that covers everything near a road in the winter. You can clean your car all you want but as soon as you spend 2 minutes driving a lot of the salt+sand+slush is back. How do you clean the lens while driving?
- crygin 13y agoSeriously. My entire rear window is unusable after five minutes on the road this winter, no idea how any rear-facing camera could function.
- RealGeek 13y agoI live in NY as well, and it snowed every week most of the winter. My camera lens got dirty or blocked by ice on only three occasions. Mostly, the camera is clear even when windows are dirty. Is cleaning camera lens for a total of 3 times in a year a big deal? We clean our cars a lot more than that.
- dfc 13y agoYou are correct 3 times in one winter is not a lot. I am saying that 3 times in one winter is not an accurate estimate of how often I would have to clean the camera. How much snow did you receive in your area of NY? Did you get half the snow Syracuse did? City 2013-14 Avg. ---------------------------- Syracuse 131.6 123.8 Buffalo 128.7 94.7 Rochester 112.3 99.5 Binghamton 84.4 83.4 Albany 71.1 59.1 from: http://goldensnowball.com/ http://goldensnowball.com/
- teamonkey 13y agoI prefer blind spot mirrors or segmented mirrors. I can't work out why they're not popular in North America, but the last two British cars I owned had them as standard. Two mirrors = no blind spots. The biggest reason why I don't like angling the mirrors outwards is because it reduces visibility close to the rear on both sides - just large enough for a cyclist to sneak while waiting at a junction.
- cpr 13y agoSadly, it won't help in the most tragic cases where a toddler is already under the car. (We had friends who had to suffer through such an incident some years back.)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zwily 13y agoI actually get really nervous driving a car without a backup camera now. This is good news.
- JshWright 13y agoYour average passenger car has darn near 360 degrees of visibility, with very good mirror coverage. I can see how a camera would be useful (though I find them difficult to use, as I'm never sure if the image is reversed or not), but it should never be necessary (at least until the point where the driver is no longer necessary).
- mikeash 13y ago360 degrees around what axis? Backup cameras allow you to see low objects directly behind you, which no mirror system does on any passenger car I've ever seen.
- bonkabonka 13y agoI really wish that, in addition to the camera, they'd include a sort of proximity cone (radar, sonic, something) too. Case in point: Coworker of mine gets himself a Leaf - loves it to death. So, to partake of his joy, we all take a ride with him to Chipotle to grab lunch. Right next door to the restaurant in the strip mall is one of those UPS Pack-n-Ship places. We didn't pay it a lot of attention when we pulled in but right behind us, backed up to the front of the UPS store, is one of their short-length semi-trailers. Not an issue until we're backing out - dude came withing centimeters of smashing out his back window because he was relying on the camera which only showed the legs of the trailer and not the deck. This isn't to say that the cameras aren't good, but they do have limitations and can lend a sense of false security.
- a3n 13y agoI think I would use the camera to check clear for what it covers, but look over my shoulder for actual backing up. The camera isn't going to show cars and pedestrians coming from either side. I'd probably have trouble steering backward through a camera anyway. Actually it'd be cool if you could see the display while you were twisted around looking backward.
- hyperion2010 13y agoBack over 'accidents' don't happen because you can't see what is behind you. They happen because you are oblivious to your surroundings. People can't handle their own guilt so they try to pawn it off on society. Well guess what, 99+ percent of all vehicles never back over a child. It has nothing to do with the "visibility systems."
- mikeash 13y agoWhy should we believe you over the NHTSA on this question?
- Perdition 13y agoBecause his statement was not loaded with emotion like the one from the NHTSA. >""We are committed to protecting the most vulnerable victims of back-over accidents — our children and seniors," Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx said in a statement." This rule doesn't pass the "sniff" test. There is absolutely nothing backing this except an estimate that several dozen lives might be saved. No cost effectiveness analysis, no comparison to other changes.
- mikeash 13y agoActually, his statement was just as loaded with emotion. It was just a different emotion. Instead of "think of the children", it was the typical nerd emotional appeal of "the problem is that people are idiots and if they would just stop being idiots then we wouldn't have to deal with people being idiots." Regarding your "absolutely nothing backing this" statement, did you read through their documentation before saying this, or did you just assume? It's pretty extensive. http://www.nhtsa.gov/staticfiles/rulemaking/pdf/FMVSS-111_Rear_Visibility_Final_Rule.pdf http://www.nhtsa.gov/staticfiles/rulemaking/pdf/FMVSS-111_Re...
- Perdition 13y agoI was talking about their statements, not information buried in a report the public won't read. You think people would approve of this rule if the NHTSA had of worked, "Based on the aforementioned revised estimates for costs and benefits, the net cost per equivalent life saved for rear visibility systems meeting the requirements of today’s final rule ranges from $15.9 to $26.3 million.", into their public statement? If you actually read the report it is clear this has nothing to do with rear-vision camera systems being cost effective and is just about the NHTSA doing what they are told by congress. >"Throughout this rulemaking process, the agency has been sensitive to the costs of today’s rule and has sought to ensure that the requirements adopted impose the least amount of regulatory burden on the economy while still achieving Congress’ goal of reducing fatalities and injuries resulting from backover crashes." And hyperion2010 was right, having a rear-vision system doesn't mean you will use it (where I live it is illegal to use them when actually reversing). The solution to these accidents is education. Technology is often the answer to human stupidity, but not at $15.9 to $26.3 million per life saved.
- prbuckley 13y agoAccording to Wikipedia there are approximately 254 million passenger vehicles in the USA. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passenger_vehicles_in_the_United_Stats http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passenger_vehicles_in_the_Uni... Also there are approximately 15 million new cars sold per year. http://m.nydailynews.com/1.1567645#bmb=1 http://m.nydailynews.com/1.1567645#bmb=1 At a cost of ~$100 per vehicle for these cameras that means to get the entire passenger fleet compliment with this law will cost 25.4 billion dollars and 1.5 billion per year in additional costs. The article states that they estimate 58-69 lives per year to be saved, round that up to 70. 70/1.5 billion and we are spending over $21.4 million per life saved. That seems absolute crazy to me. How many lives could be saved with that amount of money spent in a more efficent way?
- GauntletWizard 13y agoThe actual cost is lower; Some percentage, probably even a significant one, of existing car sales already have these cameras equipped. If the price drops and the feature is compelling anyway, I can see it being a tenth that in actual cost, which brings it into line with real life-saving programs. Preventing deaths is expensive. My instinct was along your lines, though, and I'm not entirely certain that the whole idea isn't just a gift to automakers for yet another reason to jack up prices. What used to be a costly extra is now 'required'.
- prbuckley 13y agoI think you are likely correct on the cost. I would honestly like to know what the most cost effective way is to save a life. My guess would be vaccines in 3rd world. There is something that still bothers me about laws like these. A very vocal minority drives the cost up for everyone, while the effectiveness of the law is questionable. It is of course a tragedy when a young person is killed in an accident but is this really a good use of the government and law? People need to be careful when they are operating a car. Also who is going to argue against saving a toddlers life? That is probably a poor political move. This just seems like another sign of how weak willed our political system is at standing up for what is in the interest of the general public and not a vocal minority.
- 13y ago
- lutorm 13y agoIf auto makers didn't design huge vehicles from which the drivers can't see the ground behind them for hundreds of feet, this wouldn't be much of an issue.
- whyenot 13y agoKind of difficult to design a truck that does not have this problem. The Ford F-series truck is the #1 selling automobile in the US (Chevy Silverado and Dodge Ram, also trucks, are #2 and #3).
- peeters 13y agoOr a trunk, for that matter. It's not at 100 feet behind you that the trouble lies; mirrors are sufficient for that. It's the 1-5 feet behind you that you're completely blind to with mirrors (assuming you don't have transparent rear seats and hatch).
- TheLoneWolfling 13y agoCynical side of me says "hey look! More cameras for TLAs to use!" Also, unsure about cost/benefit here.
- nradov 13y agolink to the final rule: http://www.nhtsa.gov/staticfiles/rulemaking/pdf/FMVSS-111_Rear_Visibility_Final_Rule.pdf http://www.nhtsa.gov/staticfiles/rulemaking/pdf/FMVSS-111_Re...
- alayne 13y agoSounds like a huge cost for little gain. Why doesn't the NHTSA require daytime running lights?
- salimmadjd 13y agoCan anyone comment on value of patent and potential licensing revenues. I found one patent holder [1] but I assume they are several others that can claim and request licensing fees. [1] http://www.google.com/patents/US20060103727 http://www.google.com/patents/US20060103727
- mcovey 13y agoI've driven several cars with a backup camera and never used it, instead I used my eyes. Maybe I'm just not used to them since my main vehicle doesn't have one, but I feel like the one time I need it to work it will have some sort of lag/delay or a blind spot and cause me an accident if I trust it.
- stretchwithme 13y agoI guess the assumption is that people will be more aware if they can see what's behind them on TV. But is this true? Has this been studied? Or do people back up more safely when rely on their vision and who aren't glued to the TV?