3 ms·
It doesn't. If you watched 60 minutes tonight, or read the book, the problem was that a large trader (the guy they profiled ran the trading desk for RBC) would
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
It doesn't.
If you watched 60 minutes tonight, or read the book, the problem was that a large trader (the guy they profiled ran the trading desk for RBC) would make an order for a large block of stock, say 400 shares of X, and then send that out to all of the exchanges.
What would happen is it would get to the first exchange and be partly filled and when it was the HFT guys would send trades on ahead to the other exchanges faster than RBC could and buy out the stock before the RBC order got there, leaving the order only partially filled. (or filled part at one price and filled the rest at a higher price).
In the story they mention that by restructuring how they sent their trades out so that they arrived at every exchange simultaneously eliminated the possibility of the HFT guys front running them.
In order to make it possible for everyone to do that they have created their own exchange (iEX) which locks out the HFT folks (well it has them going through an extra 60km of fiber to slow down their access).
- harmegido 13y agoHis issue is with market fragmentation then, not HFT. If all the liquidity providers were at the same market, his large order would hit all of the liquidity at the same time. This is a valid complaint to me, but blaming the HFTs for "front-running" (if you could even call this that) is a bit like UPS complaining that FedEx is using airplanes to quickly move packages around. Keep up with the technology or stop competing.
- curun1r 13y agoNo, his issue is with HFT companies using fragmentation to trade risk free and skim obscene profits off the top from institutions that make these large trades. From the 60 minutes piece, one hedge fund estimated that this kind of thing was costing them $300m/yr.
- kasey_junk 13y agoYet, I for the life of me cannot describe how they do this. Can you write out the basic trade that HFT companies use to get all this risk free profit?
- cma 13y agoexchange A has a bid at 99, offer at 100 exchange B has a bid at 99, offer at 100 mutual fund X places two market orders to buy and take out the current offers, one on A and one on B. Its order on A executes at $100, taking out the liquidity and making the new best offer there $100.01 HFT firm Y sees this execution and cancels their offer of $100 on exchange B and replaces it with one at $100.01 all before the order that was placed on B arrives. This is a market fragmentation issue, Reg NMS tries to address this but doesn't really work at these timescales, because you only have to comply based on the current quotes you are getting from the exchanges, which could be many milliseconds behind (and if your system is slow to process the quotes and makes more money as a result, you won't be getting a task from your boss to speed it up). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_NMS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_NMS There are many other types of useless latency arbitrage that don't depend on market fragmentation, like trading on the difference in price between ETFs (basically a basket of stocks usually trying to match something like the makeup of the entire S&P) and the underlying individual stocks. Each time the underlyings change, the ETF price changes (within reason, risk hedging activity etc. could make the ETF temporarily get out of sync, but that is just another latency arbitrage oppurtunity). Whoever is faster wins. It's pointless, there are datacenters full of servers running wait loops on incoming data via DMA so that they don't have to pay the latency price of a system call and context switch to the kernel. Basically burning up part of that mutual fund's money into waste heat.
- kasey_junk 13y agoWhat you describe as "useless" latency arbitrage sounds like the mechanisms for a very efficient market to me. As a buyer of an ETF or as a market participant looking for trading venues I needn't spend lots of resources ensuring that the prices are in sync. Those costs have been born by the specialists in those arbitrage opportunities and it is a very cut throat efficient system.
- cma 13y agoTake out the arbitragers and all the other participants as a whole keep more money. Spreads may increase, but one party to the transactions always earns the spread and the other loses it, netting out to zero, rather than compensating latency arbitragers (and paying to generate waste heat in their datacenters) which nets out to less than zero. There is some value to keeping things liquid, but that value isn't tied at all to the amount of money that arbitragers get compensated. Consider that whether the latency is 1ms or 5ms, the fastest arbitrager wins. But to bring things down to 1ms from 5ms may require 10X more expense and waste, lowering the compensation to the arbitrager. In a competitive enough environment they simply burn up all of the spreads into waste heat and redundant fiber infrastructure.
- AndrewBissell 13y ago> skim obscene profits off the top from institutions that make these large trades It's not like in the pre-HFT days market makers would just obligingly fill institutions for whatever volume trades they wanted to execute, regardless of how ham-handedly they broadcast their intent into the market. Any estimate of "costs" to institutions from HFT needs to be measured not against some Platonic ideal scenario where market makers earn no profits, but rather against the old specialist system that it replaced. In which case I suspect the costs would come out quite a bit on the negative side of $0. There are some practices in HFT like paying for privileged newswire access that could use some reform, but the best solution to this fragmentation issue is for large institutions to stop sending out their orders like it's the year 1995.
- zaroth 13y agoIt certainly sounds like there's a large dollar value that these 'large institutions' could capture by getting better order routing for their orders.
- patio11 13y agoBasically, certain big buyers/sellers of stock want to be the ones to benefit from the information "Someone really wants into or out of this stock", and they really, really dislike when the HFTs democratize that information advantage faster than the larger players can gain extra returns from using it. Trading communicates information to the market. Proprietary access to information is valuable. HFTs make certain information non-proprietary faster than the state of the art prior to HFTs. That changes the allocation of profits associated with that information. This is the entire ballgame. Retail traders swim placidly on the sea above totally ignorant of the krakens vs. mutant-sharks-with-lasers bloodbath happening 20000 leagues below.