7 ms·
I don't understand how HFT can make me pay more than I want to for a stock. I set a limit order--the limit is how much I'm willing to pay. If some HFT firm push
by snowwrestler 13y ago
I don't understand how HFT can make me pay more than I want to for a stock. I set a limit order--the limit is how much I'm willing to pay. If some HFT firm pushes the price past my limit, then I don't buy.
- nemasu 13y agoThis is true, but I believe if you don't set a limit order, then the market value will go up. Then if the price keeps going up, you'll have missed your chance to buy the rest.
- wging 13y agoIt can make you pay more than you otherwise would, not more than your limit.
- jcdavis 13y agoJust because you have a limit order doesn't mean you aren't getting fleeced, as you could've bought it for less otherwise (assuming some level of fixing as is suggested)
- jhonovich 13y agoYou still lose. In your scenario, you are blocked out of buying the stock. And without a limit order, you get the stock but pay more. Imagine this happened when ordering food. Sure, you could put in a limit (no more than x french fries and y per fry) but your price would either be run up or you'd go hungry.
- snowwrestler 13y agoBut I'm not buying food, I'm buying a stock--which, unlike food is a totally optional purchase. My limit is the price at which I thought that stock was worth buying. If the price never falls that far, then I wouldn't want to buy it anyway.
- barkingcat 13y agoHFT is manipulating the pricing so that it is no longer worth it for you to buy it, therefore fleecing you of the profits you would have made if they weren't there. Of course, this is not illegal (it's like any other type of trading, pushing up the value so it goes beyond what you're willing to pay) - but it's achieved by using robots in such a way that normal humans can't hope to compete. Of course, you can build your own robots (ie your own HFT software) to take advantage of the weaknesses of existing HFT programs, but if you can do this, you would be working at an ibank as a quant of some kind.
- kasey_junk 13y agoCan you actually describe this market manipulation?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hueving 13y agoYes, but what the parent poster described is moronic for an HFT to do. If they see a limit order come in, there is no incentive to push the price beyond the limit order. Why would that help them in any way? There is no implication that the person issuing the limit order will suddenly decide to pay more. Additionally, to push the price up in the first place, it means the HFTs have to buy all of the stock being sold below the target price, which is taking on major risk. There is no guarantee that there isn't someone simultaneously dumping big chunks of shares at given price targets.
- snowwrestler 13y ago> HFT is manipulating the pricing so that it is no longer worth it for you to buy it, therefore fleecing you of the profits you would have made if they weren't there. This makes no sense to me. Are you claiming that HFT purposefully drives up the value of every single stock? How would they even do that? And why?
- rrhyne 13y agoHFT pushes incremental buy orders, which your sell order accepts (price discovery) but are canceled before they are filled. Knowing your limit, they then fill your order at your limit. It's illegal for anyone to issue an order they don't intend to complete, but the HFTs get a pass for some reason or other that must end with quite a few zeros.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoHFT pushes incremental buy orders, which your sell order accepts (price discovery) but are canceled before they are filled. This is incorrect. If you place a BUY@$100 and someone has a SELL@$100, the exchange instantaneously matches the orders and a trade is issued. You can't cancel an order which was matched. The "price discovery" happens before the trade is placed. The instant the exchange receives the BUY@$100 order it is published to the world via the exchange's multicast quote stream. "Issue an order they don't intend to complete" is an anachronism related to pit trading - in the pit, it's possible to throw the "I accept" hand signal at the other guy and then change your mind after trading hours during reconciliation. The FIX and OUCH protocols do not have a similar "oops I changed my mind now I'll be a jerk after hours" message.
- crdoconnor 13y agoIt's called quote stuffing: http://www.zerohedge.com/article/its-not-market-its-hft-crop-circle-crime-scene-further-evidence-quote-stuffing-manipulation- http://www.zerohedge.com/article/its-not-market-its-hft-crop...
- yummyfajitas 13y agoNanex has discovered some wiggles in a graph. So what?
- rrhyne 13y agoWhat they discovered (as have others) are innumerable canceled quotes, which are the mechanism for price discovery. A bit more than wiggles on a graph.
- mathattack 13y agoIn the simplest of cases, let's say a stock you are following is at 50.50. You want to buy it at anything under $50. It drops to $49.99, and someone cuts in front of you in line, and buys it. You miss the purchase, and the stock goes back up. Multiple this millions of times. This isn't to say they are all completely evil. They do provide liquidity as banks have walked away from equity. But there needs to be more transparency on what is going on. (For example - should it be legal to send false buy or sell signals which will be intentionally cancelled?)
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThe false buy/sell signsls are a legitimate issue. Given that you can't easily make it illegal to cancel a limit order (after all people give up after a while) you could require that the order has to be valid for 60 seconds before it can be cancelled and that would put a huge crimp in the 'faking it' market.
- AndrewBissell 13y agoA rule like this would cause every market marker to set their bid/ask spread wide enough to cover the risk of the typical adverse price move which could occur over 60 seconds.
- mathattack 13y agoYou've hit on the challenge. Any hard and fast room either has unintended consequences, or can be worked around.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThere is no "cut in front of you" message in FIX or OUCH. Most exchanges use price/time priority - if someone "cuts in front of you" it means they offered $50.01. Or maybe "cuts in front of you" means you wanted to buy the stock at $50, but you didn't actually place the order until the last minute because you wanted to play a speed game (and lost).
- ChuckMcM 13y agoIt doesn't. If you watched 60 minutes tonight, or read the book, the problem was that a large trader (the guy they profiled ran the trading desk for RBC) would make an order for a large block of stock, say 400 shares of X, and then send that out to all of the exchanges. What would happen is it would get to the first exchange and be partly filled and when it was the HFT guys would send trades on ahead to the other exchanges faster than RBC could and buy out the stock before the RBC order got there, leaving the order only partially filled. (or filled part at one price and filled the rest at a higher price). In the story they mention that by restructuring how they sent their trades out so that they arrived at every exchange simultaneously eliminated the possibility of the HFT guys front running them. In order to make it possible for everyone to do that they have created their own exchange (iEX) which locks out the HFT folks (well it has them going through an extra 60km of fiber to slow down their access).
- harmegido 13y agoHis issue is with market fragmentation then, not HFT. If all the liquidity providers were at the same market, his large order would hit all of the liquidity at the same time. This is a valid complaint to me, but blaming the HFTs for "front-running" (if you could even call this that) is a bit like UPS complaining that FedEx is using airplanes to quickly move packages around. Keep up with the technology or stop competing.
- curun1r 13y agoNo, his issue is with HFT companies using fragmentation to trade risk free and skim obscene profits off the top from institutions that make these large trades. From the 60 minutes piece, one hedge fund estimated that this kind of thing was costing them $300m/yr.
- kasey_junk 13y agoYet, I for the life of me cannot describe how they do this. Can you write out the basic trade that HFT companies use to get all this risk free profit?
- Edmond 13y agoActually limit orders are a perfect way for HF Traders to fleece regular investors...for instance if you set a stop loss at a certain level and a HFT causes the price of a stock to drop precipitously, you'll end up selling likely at a loss for an artificial reason. This scenario used to play out a lot during the 2008 financial crisis. I remember loosing money because of such tricks.
- patio11 13y agoIf you do not intend to sell a stock for $40 then it is, in general, not advisable to tell your broker "Sell this stock at $40."
- Edmond 13y agoNot sure what you mean, but you do a stop loss to make sure you don't lose your shirt when a stock moves against you. No one intends to sell at a loss but that is part of the game. The problem is when market manipulators artificially cause the price to move against you thus triggering your stop loss.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoIf you don't want to sell your stock at a price below $X (for any value of $X), you should not tell your broker to sell below $X. If you want a mechanism to retain upside while limiting downside, it exists. It's a call option, not a stop loss order. If you don't understand the difference you should not trade. If you could explain the specific mechanics of what you believe is "market manipulation", it would be very helpful.
- hueving 13y agoA stop loss is not a limit order, at least in finance terms.
- Edmond 13y agoI am using that to mean the various order rules for capping trading losses/gains...I know the finance jargon meaning is slightly different.
- tim333 13y agoHow it makes you pay more for a stock than your limit order works as follows. You see XYZ is trading for $49.99 and put in an order to buy 10,000 limit $50/share. Your trading platform replies you have bought 4000 at $50, the price has moved to $50.50 you have a 6000 share order waiting to be filled. You then say darn it I'll wait for it to go back to $50 and it goes up more and so on. As has happened to me many a time. Though as a trader you can play the game too and offer to sell shares at a high price if it looks like someone needs to buy. This stuff is one reason why paper trading gives a false sense of how easy trading is as historical prices don't actively try to figure what you're up to and screw you.
- james1071 13y agoI thought that what happened was that the HFT players were able to find your limit and so front run your order.
- otikik 13y agoMy understanding is that if the price was initially lower than your limit, they can buy it at that price before you can, and then sell it at your limit.