8 ms·
A New—and Reversible—Cause of Aging
- edj 13y agoLink to the abstract on PubMed: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24582957 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24582957 Original is behind a paywall. --- I'd take all this with a grain of salt, though. The biology of aging is incredibly complex. Seemingly certain answers to the question of what causes or mediates aging (e.g. free radicals) have turned out to be less conclusive and all-explaining than researchers originally thought.
- stcredzero 13y agoThere are seven distinct mechanisms for cellular and intracellular damage resulting from aging. Improving the regulation of mitochondria could completely fix one and slow down the rate of accumulation of a few other types of damage, but that's it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategies_for_Engineered_Negligible_Senescence#Types_of_aging_damage_and_treatment_schemes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategies_for_Engineered_Negli...
- pyduan 13y agoPlease note that Aubrey de Grey's theories are highly controversial and while some of these mechanisms are indeed big topics in the field, many biogerontologists have been publicly skeptical of his claims. In fact, some of these are even mentioned in your link. The way you worded it, it seems you're implying SENS is a widely accepted theory, while in fact it's anything but (although I'd say it certainly is interesting and worthy of investigation).
- stcredzero 13y agoSENS is controversial, but the cited 7 damage mechanisms are not. The way you worded it, it seems you're implying the 7 mechanisms are not widely accepted, while in fact, they are. (I only used the citation for the list of the 7 damage mechanisms. I can't easily find other lists that are as concise. I too am skeptical of his proposed fixes.)
- exratione 13y agoIf by "highly controversial" you mean "supported by many leading names in the research community" then sure. See this, and note the presence of George Church, Judith Campisi, Maria Blasco, etc: http://sens.org/about/leadership/research-advisory-board http://sens.org/about/leadership/research-advisory-board The SENS Research Foundation has a yearly budget about a tenth of that of one of the largest aging research labs, the Buck Institute. The Foundation funds work in a range of laboratories around in the US and Europe, and has collaborations with Oxford, Wake Forest, and so forth. Insofar as controversy exists, you might look on it as a facet of the present dispute over modern theories of aging: camps for aging as accumulated damage versus aging as evolved programming. The accumulated damage side is much bigger but split into several factions, one of which is centered around SENS.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoIts a promising result, but a lot of mice experiments don't have the same effects on people. It would be ironic if this technique failed on humans subjected to a lot of exposure to botox :-) The fear is that suddenly not only would the rich get richer, but they would never die. That leads to some fairly depressing scenarios.
- JabavuAdams 13y agoStep 1. Get rich. Same as it ever was.
- ashray 13y agoThe rich would not get richer. They would stay alive and stick around until they got poorer and eventually died.
- tormeh 13y agoThat's not how capitalism works. Your earning potential increases with your capital, eventually making talent and effort negligible factors.
- WalterBright 13y agoThe first generation makes the fortune, the second generation spends it, the third starts over.
- Lockyy 13y agoWhat happens if that second generation never replaces the first?
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago"A witty saying proves nothing."
- stcredzero 13y agoIn Larry Niven's Known Space books, some of the rich stuck around so long that they became hyper bored and so decided to become super criminals. He has one such minor character who is a woman over two centuries old, with all of the experience and knowledge that entails, with the body of an 18 year old.
- chunky1994 13y agoHere's a link to the newscientist article on the same discovery: http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn24784-turning-back-time-ageing-reversed-in-mice.html#.UzcLd63qe0Y http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn24784-turning-back-tim... And the actual paper (the full paper is behind a paywall): http://www.cell.com/cell/abstract/S0092-8674(13)01521-3 http://www.cell.com/cell/abstract/S0092-8674(13)01521-3
- naterator 13y agoWorking link to actual article: http://www.cell.com/retrieve/pii/S0092867413015213 http://www.cell.com/retrieve/pii/S0092867413015213
- jarradhope 13y agoFound paper: http://www.cnd.mcgill.ca/~ivan/age-reversing-compound.pdf http://www.cnd.mcgill.ca/~ivan/age-reversing-compound.pdf
- ackydoodles 13y agoThank-you for that. Reading now. So far it looks like good science.
- lutusp 13y agoHere's a better article that describes the same work: http://hms.harvard.edu/news/genetics/new-reversible-cause-aging-12-19-13 http://hms.harvard.edu/news/genetics/new-reversible-cause-ag... Less hype, more technical detail.
- etiam 13y agoThere was also this interview with Australian ABC around the publication of the article. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-12-20/researchers-reverse-symptoms-of-aging-with-1-week/5168582 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-12-20/researchers-reverse-sy... Apparently the video has "expired" so please refer to e.g. http://www.filedropper.com/researchersreversesymptomsofageingwith1weekoftreatmentnewsaustralianbroadcastingcorporationnolbageingx20125 http://www.filedropper.com/researchersreversesymptomsofagein... for that (as an aside, I'd appreciate advice about less obtrusive file upload services)
- lawl 13y agoThis is REALLY scary if you have recently read the following article: Could we condemn criminals to suffer for hundreds of years? Biotechnology could let us extend convicts' lives 'indefinitely' http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2580828/Could-soon-create-hell-EARTH-Biotechnology-let-extend-criminals-lives-makes-suffering-HUNDREDS-years.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2580828/Could... Edit: Since people have some issues with the dailymail, feel free to pick any other article on this topic: https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=prison+life+prolonging https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=prison+life+prolonging I just googled and dailymail appeared at the top. Not sure if that was the article i read a few weeks ago. Also please note that I don't want to stiffle innovation in this area in any way. I think it's awesome research. But I also find it interesting to explore other "applications" of this technology.
- tormeh 13y agoQuoting the Daily Fail? Seems unwise. Not even going to read it and neither should anyone else.
- lawl 13y agoI'm not sure why that would be? The idea is out there... Speculating if it will happen is pointless anyways, as it will probably take a long time before reversing aging could be done on scale. So I really don't understand the downvote(s).
- bmadden 13y agoYour original post is a huge tangent from the topic of discussion. That article is pure fearmongering and is exactly the type of propagandized information that stifles innovation. Obviously it makes sense to talk about the ramifications of new technology, but the article you linked is doing this in a heavy-handed way to get people to read the article. The result is disproportionate value being placed on that idea for the average reader of dailymail, which necessarily detracts from the discussion of balance surrounding this research.
- jusben1369 13y ago“The aging process we discovered is like a married couple—when they are young, they communicate well, but over time, living in close quarters for many years, communication breaks down,” said Harvard Medical School Professor of Genetics David Sinclair" - Totally off topic though but I think he's describing a couple heading to divorce. Nearly all successful marriages move in the exact opposite direction.
- tommoor 13y agoYep, this struck me as an odd analogy!
- rquantz 13y agoWithout intervention, the human body usually headed for divorce, in this analogy, anyway.
- grok2 13y agoI think, it's not really that communication breaks down, it is more that you don't need to communicate at all because you know the other person so well by now. Then divorce happens because you don't like what you know or you realize your spouse isn't what you wanted, or the marriage becomes stronger because you anticipate your partners needs/actions without having to communicate. So yeah, the analogy is not really right.
- DigitalJack 13y agoWhile it is true that you learn your spouse that well, it will be long before that when you realize if don't like them. However when you don't communicate, your lives get out of sync. At some point this has gone on long enough, the changes we go through (called life) cause people to become strangers again. It's like two inertial systems. They drift, differently, over time and this difference accumulates. Communication between the two inertial units can synchronize them. Or a trusted third party (GPS) can give them both a course correction.
- agumonkey 13y ago
- diminoten 13y agoLink to the submitted article (before it was changed by an admin), for posterity's sake: http://guardianlv.com/2014/01/ageing-successfully-reversed-in-mice-human-trials-to-begin-next/ http://guardianlv.com/2014/01/ageing-successfully-reversed-i... Dunno why the submission was changed, I suspect the admin didn't actually read the article, which contains original journalism work (article writer got in touch with David Sinclair again for an additional quote).
- WasimBhai 13y agoFor those working in Genetics, how much is the field upbeat about regenerative medicine in general, and Google's Calico [0] venture in particular? [0] https://plus.google.com/+LarryPage/posts/Lh8SKC6sED1 https://plus.google.com/+LarryPage/posts/Lh8SKC6sED1
- mcarter 13y agoThe font size on that page is a reversible cause of ageing.
- exratione 13y agoMany of the problems surrounding funding of meaningful efforts to treat aging, eliminate age-related disease, and extend healthy life come about because the people with the biggest megaphones are also doing the least useful work. This is true outside the scientific community, in the "anti-aging" marketplace that tries to convince people they should take supplements rather than support research. This is true inside the scientific community, where the Sinclair labs and their work on sirtuins - which is about as useless as supplements based on the last ten years of work - get far more attention than anything that is actually likely to produce meaningful results. This article is an example of high-road hype and nonsense. More than a decade of work on sirtuins have failed to reliably produce even a tiny fraction of the gains to health and life provided by calorie restriction or exercise. This is just one tiny slice of the broader mainstream scientific approach of attempting to alter the operation of metabolism in order to provide benefits. This is vastly complex, and will take a very, very long time to get anywhere. When scientists speak of not seeing any real progress towards human longevity in the near future, this is the approach they are talking about: take this thing, the interaction space of metabolism with aging, which is vast, and about which nowhere near enough is understood, and then try to make a better version of it. Sure, it's possible in the long term. But we'll all be old before anyone even makes a good first pass through this enormous complexity. Yet there is a much better path forward towards treatment of aging. This is to identify the differences between old and young tissues, something that has already been done and agreed upon by the scientific community, more or less settled for the past 20 years, and then fix them all. You don't need to delve into the interaction space to understand why or how or process or progress. You just fix it. It is the difference between repainting a wall versus understanding the deep molecular interactions of wall, paint, and weather so that you can build a better lasting paint. One of those choices is evidently much more efficient than the other. When it's a wall, who cares? Let the paint scientists get on with it. But in the case of aging, tens of millions of lives are lost every year that passes while the mainstream screws around with metabolism to slow aging rather than building the means to repair the identified causes of aging. Even better, while the metabolic engineers have no clear plan to produce a good end state, just a bunch of plans that have not yet panned out as expected despite great expense, the "just fix it" approach to aging has clear paths to the development of repair therapies for each identified difference between young and old tissues. So they are only limited in progress by funding. Why does this situation exist? I blame regulation. If your work doesn't result in something that looks like a drug, sounds like a drug, and walks like a drug it isn't going to be approved. Further, treating aging is not a result recognized by the FDA - so whatever you do has to be sidelined to treat some disease of aging. In other words only applied after it's too late to prevent things from going awry. So we see marginal unambitious work on marginal unambitious treatments, the continuing random walk through the natural world's pharmacology in search of chemicals that can be crudely administered to do slightly more good than harm, because that's the only way to have even a slight chance of getting to market. Highly regulated systems perpetuate their current state at all expense, and treat change as a threat. The treatments for aging that might actually do some good in the future are radically different from today's pharmacology. These are the repair strategies: mitochondrial gene therapy, adapted bacterial enzymes let loose in the body, targeted destruction of stem cells and immune cells run wild, that sort of thing. You can find them described if you look up SENS, the strategies for engineered negligible senescence, but there are other similar lists put forward by different research groups. The repair approach is the disruptive newcomer to the field, barely ten years old, but gathering support. We should hope that it soon wins over the mainstream, and relegates the era of paying billions for sirtuin research and other dead-ends to the dustbin of history.
- FD3SA 13y agoFor the biologically inclined, I sincerely recommend reading this paper in full. It has a number of extremely groundbreaking hypothesis, which bring together the common elements of cancer, caloric restriction, and aging. I find it interesting that this finding suggests that free radical/reactive-oxygen-species theories of aging were close, but just off the mark. It appears that the cell can cope quite well with chemical damage of this type, but has a harder time regulating mtDNA expression, which leads to the same result: reduced mitochondria function with age.
- lettergram 13y agoThe article did not say if the mice lived significantly longer...
- salimmadjd 13y agoAnti-aging divide? I'm all for anti-aging, I was obsessed by it since my teens and got a degree in molecular biology thinking I want to dedicate my life to it, I even own dontage.com. However, I'm concerned about implications of potentially high-price anti-aging treatments. Till now, death has been the great equalizer. Life is inherently unfair. If you are born in poverty there is high chances you'll stay there, but at least you always count on everyone dying at the end. With high-price anti-aging treatments people who have wealth can live longer (maybe one day indefinitely) and accumulate more wealth and those without money will just dye twice or three times as fast with no way out of the cycle. You can argue historically we always had this type of divides, for example in early stages of invention of antibiotics or vaccines or ability to buy them in black market in areas where they were scarce. However, we're moving from preventing premature deaths to extending life beyond its natural extension and that brings a whole new set of issues. Will there be enough retirement funds? If we do democratize anti-aging treatments, lets say increasing the average life span to 100 or 120. Will there be enough funding? As is, the social security is feeling the pressures of increased average life-span. So if we are able to make a 60 year olds be 20 (in some aspects of aging) or 90 year old to 30 and as the article alluded to, decrease the risk of cancers (perhaps). Then, who will pay to cover the retirement funding gap? We're heading toward a world were you can choose to live longer and have the wealth to support your life for extended time, and those who will only live 1/2 or 1/3 as much just because they were born in a different household. Among all the technological breakthroughs, anti-aging will probably have the biggest social impact and as a society we're not even thinking about it or are even preparing for it yet. But then again, if you have the money, why should you care.
- Houshalter 13y agoEveryone says this when the subject comes up and it's ridiculous. Many countries have government subsidized healthcare. Additionally patents only last for 20 years or so. And there is no reason to think it would inherently cost a lot. Do only rich people have iphones? And anyways, who cares? Better that some people live longer than none do.
- garg 13y agoWere scientists from the past worried about this when they worked to improve medicines and public health that has increased the global average lifespan from 31 years to 70 years in the past century? No one knows the answers to your questions, but I think there will be solutions to those problems. Birth rates are averaging out and hopefully starting to go down. Automation of work is going up. The reach of education has increased. Also even if everyone was immune to death by aging, some actuaries showed that humans will still be limited to 400 years due to accidental death. I think that people in different parts of the world today have life spans that are 1/2 to 1/3rd of other countries. Maybe if we're not losing all our most experienced and knowledgeable people to senility, old age, and death, we may come up with solutions more quickly.
- simonsquiff 13y agoOne thing I'd really like to understand re: ageing is why a newborn is essentially 'reset' from an ageing perspective. I appreciate that egg cells aren't constantly dividing during a mothers life but they are still a product of division and contain DNA that can suffer from time based mutations. So if aging is due to mistakes accumulated during either divisions or time then why are children born young? I don't think this is as simple as non-viable embryos are miscarried, there must be something different in the formation of embryos that means they don't carry the aging of their parents...and what clue does that give to cure aging?
- X4 13y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, I'm not a geneticist, but the logical reason for this sounds as simple as enriching the baby's DNA with that from the mother and father. Also only cells, which are our main building blocks, suffer from death. The death as we know it, is only affecting "bodily" species incl. single-celled life forms. DNA doesn't die, ever (given good conditions). That's why scientists can still extract DNA from animals which have been died thousands or millions of years ago.
- hughlomas 13y agoThe organism is a vessel to propagate the genes. Germ cells such as embryos usually have additional defenses and repair mechanisms, such as for DNA damage, that the somatic cells lack. Since the soma are merely there to help the replication of the germ line, they receive less investment. No creature we know of has successfully evolved the capability to permanently stave off aging. Besides the inevitable issues with fighting entropy in a complex system, how would an ageless organism compete in the shifting landscape of an ecosystem as other creatures evolve around it? How would a non-aging organism adapt? It seems likely that continually creating new generations is the best strategy for genetic replication. Now we are at the amusing point that genes may have unwittingly experienced their own skynet event. Modern science has given us the ability to not only gaze upon our creators, but manipulate them to do the bidding of ideas.
- simonsquiff 13y agoThanks - germ cells was the key term I was missing, this section on the germline on Wikipedia answers my original question: Germline cells are immortal, in the sense that they have reproduced indefinitely since the beginning of life. This is largely due to the activity of the enzyme known as telomerase. This enzyme extends the telomeres of the chromosome, preventing chromosome fusions and other negative effects of shortened telomeres. Most somatic cells, by comparison, can only divide around 30-50 times according to the Hayflick limit. Certain somatic cells, known as stem cells, also express telomerase and are potentially immortal.
- X4 13y agoWithout being an expert in the area, but having some detailed knowledge in the field, it honestly sounds like hype. The statement that it wasn't mentioned anywhere, before is bogus. Take a look at the source [1] that describes how NAD actually has an effect on telomeres. They really suggest using regular supplements on that url, which I'd call bullshit! I can't tell, if it's the editors fault, a missunderstandin, or if they really mean that. That's because I've no access to the real paper. -- [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicotinamide_adenine_dinucleotide#Non-redox_roles http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicotinamide_adenine_dinucleoti...
- BetterLateThan 13y agoMr Stoyte broke the silence. 'How long do you figure it would take before a person went like that?' he said in a slow, hesitating voice. 'I mean, it wouldn't happen at once ... there'd be a long time while a person ... well, you know; while he wouldn't change any. And once you get over the first shock - well, they look like they were having a pretty good time. I mean in their own way, of course. Don't you think so, Obispo?' he insisted. - Aldous Huxley, After Many a Summer Dies the Swan. ...But I am sure this news makes banks, bureaucracies and big pharma mega-ecstatic.
- cmollis 13y agothe great irony of cancer cells is that they themselves are immortal.. bit of poetry and sarcasm on the Creator's part.