6 ms·
My main issue with him is that he didn't spend 5 minutes researching this on the internet because it's come up many times previously and doesn't count as a nice
by zimpenfish 13y ago
My main issue with him is that he didn't spend 5 minutes researching this on the internet because it's come up many times previously and doesn't count as a nice hack worthy of any praise. Sorry kiddo.
As an example, these links are all 2010 or earlier.
http://www.cnet.com/uk/news/the-right-font-can-save-you-money/ http://www.cnet.com/uk/news/the-right-font-can-save-you-mone...
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=125639616 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1256396...
http://www.sitepoint.com/cut-costs-by-saving-ink-with-ecofont/ http://www.sitepoint.com/cut-costs-by-saving-ink-with-ecofon...
etc.etc.
- amirmc 13y agoAre you suggesting that every high-school science project should be original, ground-breaking research?
- zimpenfish 13y agoNo but I'm suggesting this isn't nearly as big a deal as people are hyping and that the kid - whilst diligent - ain't a genius.
- amirmc 13y agoNowhere does it suggest that the kid is some kind of genius. Not in the original article, nor in these threads. It's clear that this was a school science project and that he was encouraged by his teachers (and his reviewers) to pursue it.
- zimpenfish 13y agoFair point - it doesn't actually mention the word "genius".
- SilasX 13y agoThe fact that it's considered newsworthy enough ("man bites dog" & all that) to merit a CNN story is itself the claim that this is somehow novel or interesting. It's the same objection you'd have if CNN posted a story about "kid uses physical model to predict lava distribution from volcano using baking soda and vinegar".
- zimpenfish 13y agoAlso "of the nearly 200 submissions they have received since 2011, Suvir's project was a real standout"
- baddox 13y agoI'm suggesting that science projects which are not original ground-breaking research should not be portrayed in the media as original ground-breaking research.
- joezydeco 13y agoNot to mention an off-the-shelf tool to actually do the calculation, meaning others have been working on this problem too.
- zimpenfish 13y agoIt's not even that people have been thinking about it theoretically - actual places have actually implemented schemes to save money on toner and ink.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- unethical_ban 13y agoAs others have pointed out: It wasn't the first time the idea had come up, but he came up with it and looked into it independently. That, at the age of 14, is the kind of thinking science fairs should be encouraging. As a Ph.D project? Not so much.
- jwr 13y agoThis is why I think the Internet might actually be stifling innovation and creativity. I find that more and more often I think of something, then search on the internet, and if I see that someone somewhere has done anything similar, I abandon the project immediately. After all, it's been done, so what's the point? Net result if we push this to an extreme: instead of pursuing interesting ideas people end up wasting time in useless discussions on Hacker News, thus adding exactly zero value and failing to move humanity forward. At a first approximation, everything has been tried by someone. It is very, very rare to have a truly groundbreaking idea. But that's not a problem! Humanity advances mostly through incremental improvements, not just by giant leaps. So stop criticizing and start doing.
- freehunter 13y agoSometimes I feel the same: I'm not going to be able to do this better or even as good, so I'll stop working on it. Sometimes, though it's the other way around. This has been done, but it still sucks so I'm going to do it better. Or sometimes, it's been done and works great for these people but not for me, so I'm going to make it better for my use case. It goes both ways.
- zimpenfish 13y agoThe Internet is stifling innovation and creativity? Which Internet are you on? Mine is -full- of innovation and creativity. There's too much, in fact, to keep up with on a daily basis which is why I have to subscribe to aggregators like Hacker News!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- aryastark 13y agoyes, but some of us have higher standards of creativity than the 100th version of 2048 or the front page of reddit.
- saucetenuto 13y ago
- SilasX 13y agoWhat I'm more interested in is: why did this kid get all the press coverage from this suggestion, as opposed to the numerous other people who have suggested it (many if them probably kids too).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zimpenfish 13y agoThis would be an interesting research project in and of itself. Slow news day? Pushy parents pimping him out to the news media?