5 ms·
>text links replaced by only graphical icons This is a terribly pernicious trend in all sorts of software, not just GMail. I really hope that the fad dies out
by epistasis 13y ago
>text links replaced by only graphical icons
This is a terribly pernicious trend in all sorts of software, not just GMail. I really hope that the fad dies out soon, because it's preventing me form effectively using software that otherwise may have been great.
- Kluny 13y agoIt's like they realize that reading English is kind of tough, so they give you a whole new language to learn, which doesn't help at all.
- debt 13y agoI think it's done to more easily deal with internationalization. Instead of making the design fit the translated text, just remove the text altogether and stick with just the icons.
- techtalsky 13y agoWell "mystery mean navigation" refers to something specifically where there's little chance of understanding what the icons refer to without rolling over them, much like "mystery meat" in your fridge that you can't remember what it is without opening the tupperware.
- MichaelGG 13y agoFor accessibility, they still need the text. So only hassle saved is the minor one of designing a bit larger to fit languages that need more pixels.
- duaneb 13y ago> fad You realize that iconography predates all civilization, right?
- blockross 13y agoTrue, but don't confuse iconography with brand marketing.
- Pacabel 13y agoI think he's talking within the context of software, you know. Even within this context, icons have been used for a long time in things like toolbars. But historically they've been quite descriptive of what they do, and often times have been accompanied by a textual description if there's any uncertainty as to their meaning. Like the earlier commenter wrote, however, we've seen the use of icons really taken to a stupid extreme as of late. This is especially true when it comes to websites and web apps. The icons are often rather abstract, to the point of causing confusion and harming usability. Even desktop apps have succumbed to this. Look at Chrome's menu icon. In the last version I used, it was a stack of three horizontal lines. At a glance, it's not clear at all what it represents. It's only after clicking it, and seeing the menu that opens, that the connection is made.
- sirkneeland 13y agoIE6 predates all of civilization too.
- duaneb 13y agoOf all the things that inhibit our use of programs, icons are surely the least because after you've pressed them a couple thousand times, I hope you still don't forget them. Text takes up a lot of space.
- Pacabel 13y agoWhat you're saying about icons is true, but only if we're talking about desktop software that has major releases only every few years, or software that otherwise uses a very standardized and common set of icons. That isn't what we see with most web apps these days, including the major ones. There's continual change, including the icons that are used, where they're positioned, and what happens when they're clicked on. If you discover what an icon means and does today, there's a very good chance it'll have changed by tomorrow, if it's even still around. We're much better off losing a small amount of space, but getting an obvious and unambiguous description when text is used instead of icons.
- wyclif 13y agoOne of the first things I did when Gmail updated the design was to revert back to text links in the settings.
- joshfraser 13y agoWhere is the setting for that? I can't seem to find it.
- isbadawi 13y agoSettings -> General -> Button labels. You can choose between "Icons" and "Text".
- ekianjo 13y agoThanks for this! I was not even aware the option existed. Done!
- xentronium 13y agoYou might also like other advice from this article: http://jasoncrawford.org/2012/04/how-to-cope-with-the-gmail-redesign/ http://jasoncrawford.org/2012/04/how-to-cope-with-the-gmail-... At least for me it made gmail bearable again.
- andrewljohnson 13y agoBut it's a trend that is extremely helpful to non-English speakers.
- BHSPitMonkey 13y agoOnly if the iconography is more obvious than the equivalent English text (or icon + text). If it's not, then you might as well be using Egyptian hieroglyphs.
- redorb 13y agoVincent Flanders called this mystery meat navigation [1] and has a whole site about webpages that suck.. (a bit dated) [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mystery_meat_navigation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mystery_meat_navigation http://www.webpagesthatsuck.com/mysterymeatnavigation.html http://www.webpagesthatsuck.com/mysterymeatnavigation.html
- jey 13y agoSome people have asked, "Where are the sites?" Well, the menu above should aim you in the right direction. Too bad that Web Pages That Suck sucks.
- Jack000 13y agowow that site's still going. I remember reading his book when I first started learning web design. Always thought the bad design on that site was done ironically though..
- JimmyM 13y agoYou should read the FAQ, http://www.webpagesthatsuck.com/faq.html http://www.webpagesthatsuck.com/faq.html, the design is deliberate.
- benihana 13y ago>I really hope that the fad dies out soon I wouldn't hold my breath. I think a lot of the reasons we're moving to icons instead of text is because sometime in the next ten years, the majority of all internet traffic will originate on phones, and phones don't have nearly as much real estate to devote to labels as desktop screens do.
- scep12 13y agoUsing icons over text gets you some nice wins when it comes to i18n as well. I.e. you're fitting an icon, not variable width text.
- marcosdumay 13y agoJust decide which decade you are talking about. I hear this since the 90's.
- benstein 13y agoShow me a "Save" icon that doesn't _still_ look like a floppy disk. Until then I'll take my text labels.
- baudehlo 13y agoModern apps don't have a save function. There's no need for it.
- acheron 13y agoReminds me of Neal Stephenson's The Diamond Age, where most people can't actually read and just follow animated icons. "Mediaglyphs" I think it was called.
- jellicle 13y agoThe best kind are the ones that change the icons with every iteration (Ubuntu, I'm looking at you), so you can't even memorize the icons.