4 ms·
"You can’t just free market part of the time. Good on Facebook for not being party to the shenanigans." I'm always fascinated by what people don't understand a
by adventured 13y ago
"You can’t just free market part of the time. Good on Facebook for not being party to the shenanigans."
I'm always fascinated by what people don't understand about free markets. The author appears to think "free market" means lots of government enforced market controls (which would be an obvious contradiction in terms).
In an actual free market, it's not illegal to collude to suppress wages, just like it's not illegal for employees to form unions, leave for other better jobs, or start their own companies to compete and pay superior wages to steal talent.
In intentionally overly simplified terms, "free market" means a lack of, or severe limitation of, government controls. How is it possible the author doesn't know that?
- tedks 13y agoGood luck starting a union if all the union organizers are fired as soon as management finds out they're unionizing. Good luck starting new companies without any access to capital. Good luck finding a new job in a labor market like today's. (If you want to see how easy it is to "start a union," there are plenty of active campaigns by unions to unionize various companies: Starbucks and Jimmy Johns are the ones that come most quickly to mind. The people running those campaigns would appreciate your help, and you'd learn a valuable lesson about labor politics.)
- adventured 13y agoGood luck starting new companies? Why yes indeed in fact. I'm very well versed on the history of the free market in America for example, circa 19th and early 20th century. There was no problem in starting companies - in fact it was a boom time for entrepreneurialism - despite the extremely low level of regulation. If there was a market opportunity to make money, capital was available. For every juggernaut there were numerous others that wanted to chop that juggernaut down to size. JP Morgan, Rockefeller, Carnegie, they all had countless large enemies willing to finance competitors. Why should it be easy in a free market to start a union inside of a company? Free markets don't guarantee you have a right to a job or a right to start a union at a company. In a case where the employees don't own the company, assuming they're strictly labor, they agree to work there and get paid for it, or they can quit. That's a free market for labor. You also don't have to work at a company to attempt to organize its labor in a free market. (also I should note, my intentions aren't to have a debate on the pros and cons of free market economics, but rather to describe what a free market for labor actually is)
- matthewmacleod 13y agoHow is it possible the author doesn't know that? Because you are (your words) using 'intentionally over-simplified terms.' A free market is not simply one without government controls, it's one without government controls or other de facto authority, such as price-setting monopolies. Excessive government regulation means a less free market. Similarly, excessive monopoly control or cartel-like behaviour means a less free market. These are similar forces; the market loses freedom because one group has excessive control of it. So, paradoxically, government regulation can result in a freer market - it's more complex than you are claiming.
- adventured 13y agoI disagree. Monopolies can only exist in free markets when force is applied, eg by a corporation hiring thugs or militia to restrain the free market, and the government fails to stop that use of force. The only way a corporation can acquire de facto authority in a free market is with violence (in which case they become a competitor with the government as it regards rule of law). There is no other way they can literally hold back competitors.