6 ms·
You appear to be advocating a new IDE. Here's why it will not succeed
- codeka 13y agoIs this in response to anything in particular?
- dredmorbius 13y agoYou appear to be asking a rhetorical question on HN. Here is why it will not succeed ....
- Kluny 13y agoWe have answers for everything.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoBut we generally choose them from a surprisingly small set, so YMMV.
- acchow 13y agohttp://colinm.org/language_checklist.html http://colinm.org/language_checklist.html
- danielweber 13y agoWas the "your new anti-spam system sucks" checklist based off of this, or the reverse?
- krzysz00 13y agoThe reverse, I think.
- wmf 13y agoProbably Atom, Nitrous, Light Table, and all the other Web IDEs being created in recent years.
- leoc 13y agoIt's a variation on the famous "Your post advocates a [...] approach to fighting spam" form from Slashdot during the days of the email spam crisis: https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt .
- captaincrowbar 13y agoAlso worthy of note: "You advocate a ________ approach to calendar reform..." http://qntm.org/calendar http://qntm.org/calendar
- cheepin 13y ago[ ] No one really believes that your IDE is faster than: [ ] Eclipse [ ] You have reinvented Eclipse but worse I doubt it
- romanovcode 13y agoI don't think there is an IDE slower than Eclipse. Even NetBeans is faster.
- PopsiclePete 13y agoYou haven't had the pleasure of using VS 2012/2013 with Resharper, I see. My cursor lag while I type. Occasionally the entire IDE sputters to a halt, becoming unresponsive for seconds at a time, because Resharper decided to perform some static analysis on a 200-line Javascript file. On an 8-core, 32-GB RAM machine with an SSD. Let that sink in for a second. Yeah.
- mehrdada 13y agoThat's exactly the experience I had with Resharper when I installed it (and subsequently removed it for good after a few days) years ago when I still wrote C# code. I never understood the "Resharper is essential" attitude. Plain Visual Studio was just fine.
- voltagex_ 13y agoVS2012 and 2013 have caught up to Resharper's features. I still use Resharper's refactoring and Alt-enter shortcuts though.
- stefan_kendall3 13y ago"SSD" doesn't mean a whole lot. Sata 2 vs PCI Express is an order of magnitude of difference.
- marcosdumay 13y ago
- _prometheus 13y agoVersions of this have always applied to creating editors -- or for that matter, any new {language, system, product}. And yet, new ones are created all the time, some even become widely successful. Your finality is drastically overstated, and fundamentally negative in value.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoYou know, I get the feeling that you are just not taking this seriously enough.
- ZenoArrow 13y agoI understand the frustration of the author of this list, but do still believe there's room for improvement in the field of IDEs. Light Table is the most promising new IDE that I know of, do think it has a decent chance of bringing benefits to coding, partly because it seems to focus on the one important area that I still feel lacks any real polish in many current IDEs, which is in debugging.
- gkoberger 13y agoI got the impression that the author wasn't frustrated, but rather mocking the common responses new IDEs like Light Table or Atom inevitably get. EDIT: To reiterate what leoc posted below, the format this is presented in is a well-used "meme" in the tech world.
- ZenoArrow 13y agoPerhaps, but there are plenty of barely original or language-specific IDEs out there, so it's fairly possible the author was being direct.
- leoc 13y agoI think the humour of the original spam-solution form https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt was always meant to be double-edged, and it was usually taken as such.
- munificent 13y agoCan't it be both?
- munificent 13y agoThe great thing about this list (and the original programming language one that I stole from, of course) is that it mocks itself. It is true that almost all IDEs are doomed to fail and the reasons why are easily listed. But it is also true that the critics of those are giving so little insight that all of their criticisms often boil down to a few things you could put on a checklist.
- jmhamel 13y agoHi! Perhaps the people of HN can offer some advice: I’ve happily been using Emacs for about a year now, with loads of customizations from where I worked. Now that I no longer work there, the customizations don’t really make sense for my own projects. I started from scratch today, and now I totally hate emacs! I want to just start coding, and not spend a whole day setting up my IDE. Do you have any suggestions for other IDEs/reasons for me stick it out with Emacs? (I’m on a mac, doing mostly rails and node development btw)
- gkoberger 13y agoYou're looking for Sublime 2: http://www.sublimetext.com/ http://www.sublimetext.com/ (Note: I personally use vim, so I'm not plugging Sublime based on any bias.)
- DjangoReinhardt 13y agoActually, Sublime Text 3 [0] (although in Beta) is quite stable and already has massive support within the community. I was lucky enough to get started with ST in my early days (not too long ago, tbh) and I haven't felt the need for a full-fledged IDE yet and I whole-heartedly recommend it for someone looking to move from (IMHO) bulky IDEs like Eclipse to a more minimalistic editor. ST3 + SublimeIntel + SublimeLinter and suddenly, I feel like a keyboard ninja. Believe me, for a newbie, that is a massive boost of confidence! :D [0]: http://www.sublimetext.com/3 http://www.sublimetext.com/3
- AsmMAn 13y agoDo this support C++11? there's already some days I'm looking a new IDE/text editor with real C++11 support to I switch to. Also, I can change the theme too, right? this black isn't very good to my eyes.
- plorkyeran 13y agoIt's just a text editor, so there isn't much to support.
- pearjuice 13y agoAtom could have been Github his expansion. Its final monopoly settlement. A web based IDE so modernly written it would only work on Chromium nightly (for few months). A business model in which your IDE is in the cloud backed by Github. One private repository for free, public unlimited and after that maybe $0.99 per private repository/IDE-project or something. Synced all across the cloud, responsive, adaptive, buzzwords alike. You log in to atom.io and boom there is your IDE. Partner with Google for Chrome OS. But no, instead we get some poorly optimized, hacky IDE with half of a Sublime Text look-and-feel. In Javascript. On the desktop. This could have been it. They had all the ingredients. Too bad. Maybe in the future.
- shadowmint 13y agonope. See, web ides have two fundamental fails that no one has figured out yet. 1) your browser context is not isolated; you have other tabs that kill performance, you have browsers you need to restart periodically (dns cache), or die because of dev javascripty things (eg webgl). Restarting your ide all day? yeah, no. 2) no access to local files without a stupid plugin. enough said. There are some not terrible run-your-own-local web ides, but how is that any better than a fat client? Its not a wasted chance; its that what you want currently cant exist in a form that isnt worse than the current solution.
- gbog 13y ago3) not using the terminal, which is the best way to have a shell nearby, and the shell with its extensible toolset is necessary for any serious coding task.
- malkia 13y agoAdd to this list - good window docking system, and by good I mean Visual Studio, because what's built-in Qt is not enough, and while QT Creator is great, and it's very well suited for laptop use, I can't use all my monitors at work as much as I want to.
- shadowmint 13y agoamusing. I particularly liked 'no one believes your new IDE is any faster than any of the other successful new IDEs other people have made'.
- gojomo 13y agoYou think you're being clever with your checklist dismissiveness. But your smug cynicism actually makes you one of history's greatest monsters, because... ...
- habosa 13y agoYeah! People should never try to build new things that fit their needs/philosophy. I'll stick with Eclipse 1.0 thankyouverymuch. Or not. Discouraging people who build or discuss interesting things without actually offering a better solution is petty and a waste of everyone's time. if someone thinks that building a new IDE where you type upside-down that only supports Arc, good for them. One of those people might come up with Visual Studio or intelliJ, and then save tons of people countless hours.
- aaron695 13y ago> Yeah! People should never try to build new things that fit their needs/philosophy. Correct. Certainly in the software world. Software for young white males is done to death. And although this article is pure humour it makes an important point. As if the IDE is going to be fixable on a whim. It's used and thought about by every person who writes software most days, as if there are any magic bullets left to implement. And if you get put off by a humours article which you don't get the points on, you're doomed to failure anyway. Go off and try something different. If people can't think of reasons why you shouldn't do it, then there's a chance it's a good idea that might have some lowing hanging fruit on it.
- chazu 13y agoTo quote ESR, "Every good work of software starts by scratching a developer's personal itch." For me that truism underlies the passion that gets all good hackers into designing and implementing software. It's the very linchpin of what makes a good software engineer. Someone who's driven to build something, even if its yet-another X. It's "the bug" that I expect to see in any half-decent job candidate for an entry-level position. Dismissing that seems, to me, tantamount to taking all the fun out of programming. That being said, I do find atom kind of silly.