7 ms·
Print an 'illegal number' on the top in the form of a barcode and include a scanner in every machine, copywriting the number and taking legal action against any
by colechristensen 13y ago
Print an 'illegal number' on the top in the form of a barcode and include a scanner in every machine, copywriting the number and taking legal action against anyone who uses it without license. It's trivial to break on your own but very difficult for a proper business to break legally.
- colmmacc 13y agoAnother option would be to put a 5mm embossed "K" on the bottom of the container, and call it a trademark, or trade-dress. Then make the receptacle require that exact "K" as a physical lock.
- Pitarou 13y agoWe can combine the two ideas: Print a trademarked image on top, and then print a digitally signed digest of that image (as a barcode) on that same top. The coffee maker verifies the signature, and verifies that the digest matches the image. This also makes it easy to control who else can manufacture the coffee pods.
- joezydeco 13y agoIt's a great idea, but probably over complicated for the environment that this coffee maker operates in. You'd also have a tricky optical problem capturing an image of the cap at close range (such as inside a closed lid)
- duskwuff 13y agoThat would almost certainly not be upheld in court - Sega v. Accolade found that the use of a trademark as part of a security system cannot be prosecuted as trademark infringement. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade Capsule summary: Sega's Trademark Security System, which was present in some versions of the Sega Genesis game system, would check for the string "SEGA" at a particular location in the ROM. When it found this string, it would display the text "PRODUCED BY OR UNDER LICENSE FROM SEGA ENTERPRISES LTD." on screen; if it did not find this string, the game would not boot. Accolade reproduced this to make their unlicensed games work; Sega sued them for a variety of things, including trademark infringement, and lost.
- OWaz 13y agoThanks for sharing that. I was never aware of Sega v Accolade and the impact it had on reverse engineering under fair use.
- Danieru 13y agoNintendo also tried this with the Gameboy's DRM. The gameboy would copy a section of the ROM onto the screen then checksum it. The gameboy would only jump to the real start address if the displayed bitmap matched the nintendo seal of quality. This went a bit further than Sega's system by displaying it verbatim. Every ROM needed to includ the full trademark and it would be show in full to the user. I think they get this system for the Gameboy Color. I'm not sure of the timing between the lawsuits and the GBC. In general the GBC is a GB with double clocked CPU and palleted color so they might have kept the same scheme for developer ease.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- OWaz 13y agoYeah the one's I have seen were like that.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- MichaelGG 13y agoIt seems unlikely that copyright would be upheld for a non-creative part of a system like that. A number by itself is certainly not a creative work. Even if it was a creative work, like a poem, I've gotta imagine it'd fail in court given the intended usage. Maybe if there was an advanced image recognition system and it examined the entire pod. But then I'd still expect (or hope) a court would override any protections given the motivation.
- colechristensen 13y ago(very nearly) Every creative work can easily be encoded as a number. Anything that can be represented on a computer is a number. A jpg is a number, an mp3 is a number... you get the picture. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number
- DerpDerpDerp 13y agoThe numbers are not illegal to have for other purpose, but only if you're using them to construct (or act as) the actual work of art, or to break other rules. In all the cases that were presented, there was malice in the actions involved, by intending to circumvent rules by pretending it was something else, rather than honestly happening on the equivalent number.
- chrismcb 13y agoYou can copyright a number, and you can't copyright a short phrase.