8 ms·
Households without any cash savings are twice as likely to be wealthy as poor
- crazy1van 13y agoThe title for this article is "Are the Suburbs Making People Live Paycheck to Paycheck?". However, the article isn't about suburbs at all. It is about the financial implications of home ownership. Home ownership maybe relegated to suburbs in NYC, but in a large number of cities that is not the case.
- Malarkey73 13y agoThis article is ass backwards. It implies that the upper middle classes are poor because they don't keep cash savings. But what it actually suggests is that the middle classes are putting their money into property and investments - which is indeed a rational choice that will make their excess wealth work for them. Not that I'm saying the middle classes aren't being squeezed - by the 1% stretching off into the distance. But this is just not that.
- dgabriel 13y agoSure, but in the case of job loss + foreclosure or short sale, all of that goes up in smoke. It's a big risk.
- nawitus 13y agoI wonder why one can't sell a house for about 95% of the market value in a month. I mean it sounds like a good deal: the property owner can sell the property quickly to pay off the mortgage, while keeping some of the savings for himself. The real estate investor will make 5% of the value of the house in a few months (minus expenses).
- refurb 13y agoWhat makes you think you can't do that? Unless the housing market is frozen, pricing a home under the fair market value usually results in a pretty quick sale. However, closing in 30 days might be tough. 60 days is probably the norm.
- nawitus 13y agoI didn't say that you can't sell houses sometimes under 30 days, my case was about certainly selling your house in 30 days for significantly (~5%) under the market value. If that's actually possible, then the parents claim "in the case of job loss + foreclosure or short sale, all of that goes up in smoke" is incorrect. If it's not possible, then I wonder why, because the economics seem to make sense.
- gohrt 13y ago5% of market value, 4-6% brokerage fees, ~3% transaction fees, ~1% in switching costs (double-rent), adds up to most of the home equity most people have.
- ghaff 13y agoPlus, as is probably still the case in a few parts of the US, a given mortgage may well be underwater (i.e. the house, even at market value, may be worth less than you owe). As others have pointed out there are also a lot of transaction costs, especially for a house (don't forget moving/storage/etc. too). If you've largely paid off your mortgage, sure, but then you have a great source of collateral if you need some short-term money.
- tsotha 13y agoIn the US you can sell a house quickly if you can list it at an attractive price. I did it once - I had to start a new job far away in a relatively short period of time, so I sold my house in 15 days, including escrow. It probably cost me somewhere in the neighborhood of 6% of the total value. But to do that you need equity. In a short sale or a foreclosure you're leaving the house without any money, which "up in smoke" seems to describe.
- drinkzima 13y agoTransaction costs on housing hover around 5-6% generally, and that ignores holding costs. Housing isn't an 'economically perfect' marketplace.
- nawitus 13y agoFair point. Transaction costs for the seller where I live apparently only include the estate agent commission, which can be 3% or even a fixed amount (e.g. 3k€).
- IanDrake 13y agoThis article refers to two classes of people, the "middle class" and the "poor". It then goes on to categorize the middle class group as "wealthy". It's as if words no longer have meaning. Wealthy means you can live off your wealth.
- ilamont 13y agoMisleading choice of words in the headline and text. A teacher making $60k a year is "wealthy" by The Atlantic's definition.
- walshemj 13y agoWell it depends if that teacher had inherited a property and some income producing assets from a parent or grand parent and have a pension from a former job (say 20 years in the army). They could be very well be wealthy.
- a3voices 13y agoThe world "wealthy" in my opinion means you can live the rest of your life in comfort without working, if you choose. These people are not wealthy.
- this_user 13y agoThere is more than one definition of "wealth" and "poverty". You could be a senior Silicon Valley engineer making 200k a year and that would make you wealthy compared to some homeless person in Detroit, but you'd still be poor compared to a hedge fund manager in NYC making 500 million.
- a3voices 13y agoWell on a logarithmic scale, 200k is much closer to 500m than it is to 0.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoOn a logarithmic scale you don't get close to 0 no matter how hard you try. It's infinitely far away isn't it?
- pizza 13y ago0.001 dollars is essentially 0, isn't it?
- gohrt 13y agoYou are describing "rich", not "wealthy". Income is not nearly the same thing as wealth. Wealth converts to income at ~5-15%/yr. Yet income doesn't quite convert conversely, because living costs money every yeat.
- Crake 13y agoIn my experience, wealthy people will usually define wealth in such a way as to exclude themselves from being categorized as wealthy.
- wmt 13y agoHome ownership and kids were the thing for me. While studying I was netting 800€ a month in a 400€ rental apartment and never had worry about money, and had a decent buffer in the bank. Now working and having a 2 + 2 sized family, we net 5000€ month, and pay 1500€ a month for the house (loan + other costs), and and still we have to very carefully budget our every month, often running on fumes when a payday arrives. (I have no regrets, this was more of an observation.)
- patio11 13y agoPartly this is due to households who are financially well-situated having options for smoothing out transient cashflow issues which are superior to keeping large amounts of cash in non-productive accounts. Depending on your risk tolerance, if you're a millionaire, having $1k in checking might not be quite as insane as people writing personal finance advice for Americans with $30k annual incomes would make it out to be. (Most folks with $30k annual incomes don't have $100k available on plastic or the ability to have $30k wired from their brokerage to checking within an hour of asking for it.)
- muzz 13y agothis may be a nit, but unless the $30k is in a cash-equivalent like money market wouldn't you have to wait 3 days for settlement of whatever was sold for that $30k?
- patio11 13y agoIt depends on a bunch of factors. For the type of folks I'm imagining, that won't be a problem for them. Think "margin." Not only do they not need to wait 3 days to receive the $30k they might never have to sell anything for it at all.
- adventured 13y agoA lot of brokerages will hook banking features up to your trading account, such that "checking" and "trading" essentially become just two parts of that account like "savings" and "checking" are for most standard bank accounts. You do typically still have to wait X time for settlement, but if you have margin or cash in your main account (which can also be put into action trading immediately), you can tap into that via a checkcard or similar.
- maxerickson 13y agoThe Brookings paper is extremely wonkish, but their medians (among the 'wealthy hand to mouth') are wealth less than $100,000 and more than 50% of it as housing.
- 13y ago
- brownbat 13y agoArticle calls out an interesting point by Elizabeth Warren.[1] In this country, it's extremely difficult to access the best schools without expensive housing. That encourages families to overextend and puts them at risk of bankruptcy. There was a recent This American Life episode that demonstrated the human impact of our absurd system, where hyperlocal property taxes set school quality. I thought it was a particularly strong episode.[2] [1] The Two Income Trap, http://www.amazon.com/The-Two-Income-Trap-Middle-Class-Parents/dp/0465090907 http://www.amazon.com/The-Two-Income-Trap-Middle-Class-Paren... [2] This American Life #512, "House Rules" http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/512/house-rules http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/512/h...
- HarryHirsch 13y agoThere was a recent This American Life episode that demonstrated the human impact of our absurd system, where hyperlocal property taxes set school quality. I thought it was a particularly strong episode. Oh yes. I remember my favorite bartender who after a divorce kept herself afloat working part-time retail and tending bar. There aren't many alternatives in nowhere rustbelt America. She rented an apartment that was in the only decent school district in town, all other schools were quite like juvie hall. About 75 % of her income must have gone to rent. When her youngest son had finished school she moved. I cannot fault this decision, education is important, and when you are near minimum wage a support system is important. Moving to where the jobs are isn't the panacea it's made out to be on this website.
- gohrt 13y agoProperty taxes aren't the big factor they are made out to be. School quality varies greatly even within a taxing district, yet still highly correlated to location of high-income people. This is because wealthier neighborhoods have less street crime, more parental involvement in children's education at home, more parental involvement in schools, children who in aggregate are better fit for school success (general health and safety, other factors), teachers prefer to work with (and burn out more slowly with) better-behaved students. The way around these issues would be to randomize school assignment (with residential schools (rare), or bussing (common, with its won set of complications)
- jdietrich 13y agoThe analysis misses the crucial factor - access to credit. A middle-class homeowner can easily borrow tens of thousands of dollars cheaply and easily via credit cards and overdrafts. With a good credit history, you don't need liquid savings to deal with a temporary cashflow problem; Low interest rates mean that it is economically rational to rely on credit in this way, rather than having capital under-utilised in instant access savings accounts. Credit is vastly more expensive for the poor, especially the unbanked poor (who represent around 8% of the American population). Borrowing $1000 for a couple of months costs just a few dollars if you have a low-rate credit card, but hundreds if your only access to credit is through payday lending. Without the cushion of cheap credit, it is imperative to have a rainy-day fund. The availability of peer support is also highly relevant; If you have affluent family and friends, then the consequences of cashflow problems are greatly diminished. The author draws the conclusion that the middle-classes are financially insecure, but I think that the converse is true - they choose to spend to the limit of their income because they are highly financially secure and do not fear short-term cashflow problems.
- jobu 13y agoThat's a great point. They only looked at the last 25 years, but I bet the story is different in the late 70s and early 80s when interest rates were significantly higher.
- ghaff 13y agoCredit cards aren't necessarily the best example as they carry horrendous interest rates relative to just about everything else in today's market. That said, they can paper over a very short-term cash flow crunch easily without costing too much. And, as you say, there are often many other sources of credit such as family, HELOCs, etc. That said: >they choose to spend to the limit of their income I'd argue that this is generally not a good idea unless "spend to the limit" includes a budget for savings.
- cbhl 13y ago> Most poor hand-to-mouth people (the red line) are younger, peaking around 22 years old Gee, I would be tempted to attribute this to many people graduating from college/university around the age of 22...
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI was sad that they didn't consider the fact that people save or don't save often as a function of their experience growing up. I remember finding vegetables that my wife's grandparents has canned in jars "for later" from the 60's in their basement. They were savers, they had lived through the Great Depression. Then there were people for whom their whole life the folks that gave them money, their parents or their employers, were always there for them to give them more when they needed it, they haven't saved anything. A lot of them got caught out when the Great Recession hit. Are their children and people who lived through that more inclined to save again? Hard to say, but it seems like it isn't really relevant to compare the savings behavior of a 40 year old to that of a 20 year old. They had completely different life experiences. And when the 40 year old was 20 it was a different experience than the 20 year old is currently experiencing. As so much of our behavior is driven by our past experience, this sort of cross generational behavior comparison analysis totally falls flat for me.
- supercanuck 13y agoI have access to 12 months of 0% interest up to about $10-15K with a fee of about 3%, $300-500 total due to my credit score. I think the access to Credit allows people to live paycheck to paycheck.
- kens 13y agoI read over the referenced Brookings paper and I can't make any sense of it. The paper doesn't really define what they mean by "wealthy" and "poor" (which is a red flag). It seems like they define "wealthy" as having a nonzero amount of illiquid assets, and "poor" as having a zero amount of illiquid assets. This is crazy - if you have one dollar in home equity, you are wealthy by this definition. The paper's main conclusion is that 1/3 of people living hand-to-mouth [hand-to-mouth is the paper's term for having no liquid assets] are poor, and 2/3 of them are wealthy. But I couldn't find any data on what fraction of the population is "poor" and what fraction is "wealthy", which makes it impossible to interpret this result. Are "wealthy" people more or less likely to live hand-to-mouth than "poor" people? I couldn't figure that out from the paper. The Atlantic article also seems to be totally wrong in interpreting the paper, saying the "wealthy" have at least $50,000 in illiquid assets. The paper, however, says "the [wealthy hand-to-mouth households] typically hold sizable amounts of illiquid wealth: for example, the median at age 40 is around $50,000." Confusing the minimum amount of wealth with the median amount of wealth is a huge, huge error that totally changes the meaning. If anyone could figure out what this paper is really saying, I'd like to know (not sarcasm). Link to paper: http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/projects/bpea/spring%202014/2014a_kaplan.pdf http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/projects/bpea/spring%202014...
- jpmattia 13y agoWarning: Cynical poster alert. Modern economics is inextricably entwined with politics. Look at the last line of the conclusion: > Second, we showed that the model that allows for W-HtM behavior implies that to maximize the aggregate consumption response to scal stimulus payments, the payments should feature more moderate phasing out with household income. During the economic shock of 2008, there was a fiscal response applied that was pretty much formulated in the wake of the depression: Give money to folks who are very poor (unemployment, welfare, foodstamps), who will then boost the economy a bit because they will not save/hoard the money or go tie up wealth in long-term assets. The current paper is pointing out: "Hey, there are wealthy people living hand-to-mouth. If you give money (= "fiscal stimulus") to them, you will achieve a boost in the economy as well." Who knows, maybe the conclusion is right. But god knows how you'd achieve any confidence that the conclusion wasn't a function of the authors' funding.
- mikeash 13y agoNo discussion of the proportion between poor and non-poor overall? If you pick a household at random, you're 3x as likely to get a household with over $50,000 in net worth (their cutoff) as you are to get a household with less. According to this article, if you pick a household with no cash savings at random, that drops to 2x. Thus, households with over $50,000 in net worth are much more likely to have cash savings. In other words, no shit.
- fulafel 13y agoRich counties are also more indebted as percentage of GDP than poor countries. If you're well off people will lend to you and it makes sense for you to leverage. Classic correlation vs causation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_public_debt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_public_de...
- nwenzel 13y agoFriendly reminder... Label your axis people! Especially if you're using them as evidence to prove your point. Though, due to the image quality, I'm wondering if these images were actually taken from the original study rather than produced by The Atlantic.
- nwenzel 13y agoPossibly the "wealthy" appear to be living hand to mouth intentionally. Inflation is a highly regressive tax on cash and savings that rewards hard/real assets. Buying the most expensive house you can (barely) afford is a wealth building strategy. It's not without risk, but you have inflation on your side. Sitting on cash to save up for that down payment is an uphill fight against inflation. As a parent of a 3.5 and 1 year old, I'm definitely a believer that our public schools are de facto private institutions. You pay your tuition one way or another for a premium product.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoI'm not so sure there is such a thing as a premium product. Home schooling outcomes can beat public schools by a large margin (don't always, but can). There's so much room for improvement, I'm not sure I want to spend ANY extra money on a particular public school.