9 ms·
The point, for me at least, is to increase the total volume of freedom in the world. Here is a radical thought: Western Civilization hasn't reached "freedom pea
by bjourne 13y ago
The point, for me at least, is to increase the total volume of freedom in the world. Here is a radical thought: Western Civilization hasn't reached "freedom peak". The freedom level can continue to rise or it can decrease. Peasants in the Middle Ages probably thought they were free. We think we are free. How silly do we think those peasants were? How silly will future generations think we are?
It depends. If everyone just shrugs their shoulders, then we can easily slide back to the Middle Ages. Freedom is not monotonically rising all the time. What I, who likes computers much more than people, can do to generate freedom is write free software. It's not much but it provides value and proves that valuable stuff can be produced without a profit motive and that salary slavery isn't necessary to ensure that good software is programmed.
That's why I like the GPL. In a way that is saying "This is highly valuable software, but you can have it for free, provided..." vs BSD "Do whatever you want with this shit I just wrote for fun." Free software is great fun and I contribute to it only because I like writing code, but as a side effect of that I'm also, well, improving the world one tiny step at a time.
- aaron-lebo 13y agoYou can have an end goal of increasing freedom and just disagree that coercing people in any way shape or form to spread that freedom is either wrong or counterproductive. Especially if you have a belief that simply sharing knowledge is a way of increasing freedom and human advancement, "do whatever you want with this shit I just wrong for fun" can be just as powerful. Really when you get down to it, the battle is still open source (however you want to define it) vs non open source, and squabbles between copyleft vs permissive can miss the larger picture.
- phillmv 13y agoThey really don't. I have almost zero control over my phone (a situation that only slightly improves with Android) and even then limited control over my workstation. You're not even allowed to use GPL'd code on Apple app stores. It'd be great if the distinction were merely academic.
- zanny 13y agoThe GPL operates under a spectrum: Proprietary software takes away your rights <----> permissive <----> free software guarantees your rights It is about the user, not the developer. The free software movement for the most part sees the power of the developer to take away a users rights as unethical, and does what they can (via copyright) to correct that.
- cobrausn 13y agoProprietary software does nothing as drastic as 'take away your rights'. There is no inherent right to browse source code. At best, you entered into an agreement when you started using it that doesn't grant you as many benefits.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zanny 13y agoWe are talking about copyright here, and in court that extends to decompiling binaries as well. Copyright is a forceful transfer of natural rights (do what you want with what you have) to the creator of information, with that entire hayday of logistics and reasoning, which is depriving you of your ability to modify and redistribute said information. Source code is an oddity, sure, because you can distribute binaries that aren't modifiable and keep the source private yet still have no copyright on anything, but you aren't practicing software freedom. The source code availability is absolutely an extension, but it is no more so one than saying it is unethical to give you a car and never let you see the instruction manual if you wanted to try modding it.
- dwc 13y agoSo GPL'd software is highly valuable where BSD'd software is just hobbyist stuff...because of the license? Less loaded (and more accurate) one-liners might be... GPL: you may use this code, provided you follow rules representing my views on software freedom. BSD: you may use this code however you see fit. Which approach fits with your personal philosophy depends on you. But certainly BSD does nothing to lessen the highly valuable software licensed with it. OpenSSH, sudo, and many others, for instance.
- caniszczyk 13y agoWord, thanks for cleanly explaining this to people.
- zanny 13y agoYou can spin these lines any way you want: GPL: You can use this software however you see fit as long as you provide the same courtesy for everyone else. BSD: You can have my labor for free, and then profit off it all you want. Call it free money, you're welcome.
- clarry 13y agoGPL: You can have my labor for free, and then profit off it all you want. Call it free money, you're welcome. But there are some strings attached and certain things you may not do.
- johnbellone 13y ago> BSD: You can have my labor for free, and then profit off it all you want. Call it free money, you're welcome. There's a lot of software that is licensed under BSD which, for the most part, is sponsored by corporations. If you decided to license the software under BSD (e.g. you and the authority to do so) the likelihood that you're not making a living is relatively small. Because why else would you have released the software under such a liberal license?
- dwc 13y agoThose are fair enough comparisons. In fact, I think you've hit upon something there. If the idea of someone benefitting from your work in terms of money bothers you then BSD/MIT/ISC licenses seem bad. Personally, I'm fine with it. Apple takes FreeBSD userland and makes money? Ok! We still have FreeBSD. Someone incorporates OpenSSH code into a non-free for-profit Windows program? Ok! We still have OpenSSH.
- maratd 13y ago> What I, who likes computers much more than people, can do to generate freedom is write free software. Life is not that simplistic. So you wrote a new CRM suite and made it free. This put a bunch of shops out of business, because their clients bolted to your free alternative. The owners of those businesses have less "freedom" now. So do the employees. But the users of your free software have more "freedom", because they now have more money to spend on other things and make their life better. Is there some aggregate increase in freedom? I have no idea and neither do you. Do what you want to do. If you want to write software and make it available for others for free, go for it. If you want to sell it, that's fine too. But whatever you do, no preaching, please.
- tjr 13y agoSo you wrote a new CRM suite and made it free. This put a bunch of shops out of business, because their clients bolted to your free alternative. If this is actually a problem it all, it's a matter of software with zero monetary cost, which could be true of open source software, proprietary software, and "free software".
- ekianjo 13y ago> The owners of those businesses have less "freedom" now. So do the employees. But the users of your free software have more "freedom", because they now have more money to spend on other things and make their life better. NO, they had a rent, and they lost their rent because it became irrelevant. They haven't lost their skills, so they are still free to go and look for other rents to make. Note that this rarely happens in the actual world. There are tons of products where proprietary offers are better than FOSS tools. That's how can continue being relevant while doing proprietary software. Or, even if you are not "better" than the free software offer, you can offer paid support for your application, etc... and function as a service company and not a product company anymore.
- icebraining 13y agoDo what you want to do. If you want to write software and make it available for others for free, go for it. If you want to sell it, that's fine too. You're confusing free and Free. My job is writing Free Software, but you can't get all of it for zero monetary cost, since it's not online except for clients of ours (and nobody has ever asked us for the source).
- torrent-of-ions 13y ago> The point, for me at least, is to increase the total volume of freedom in the world. Yes, absolutely. This is something I rarely hear mentioned. Many people consider freedom only as a local optimisation problem. This is why some people argue that the BSD licence, or the public domain, is "freer" than the GPL. It's true that if you receive a program which is in the public domain that your personal freedom is maximised with respect to that current program. It's also true that if you receive a program licensed under the GPL that you have less personal freedom (you now lack the freedom to deprive others of the same freedom you received). But we can do better than this. Freedom is a global optimisation problem. Locally optimised freedom is called divide and conquer. Copyleft is the best solution that I'm aware of for the global optimisation problem. It should also be noted that copyleft itself only needs to exist in order to "undo" the effects of copyright. Public domain would be a trivial solution to the global problem if copyright didn't exist, or at least didn't exists in its current form whereby it automatically attaches itself to anything and everything. Having a world where both copyright and trivial copying by each member of society exists makes this a non-trivial problem.
- dTal 13y agoVery astute on local vs global optimisation. >copyleft itself only needs to exist in order to "undo" the effects of copyright. Public domain would be a trivial solution to the global problem if copyright didn't exist This I must disagree with. In this world of no copyright, how do I prevent people from taking my code, making interesting changes to it, and distributing the binary without sharing what they did? Copyleft uses copyright to make it against the rules to violate the user's "four freedoms". I don't know whether we'd be better off overall in a world without copyright or copyleft, but there would be no way to guarantee the freedom of your software's future users. Note that it's perfectly possible to explicitly cede copyright protection by putting your work in the public domain even today. Note that copyleft is nevertheless much more popular for software than "raw" public domain.
- einhverfr 13y agoInterestingly, the late Middle Ages are the time I would point to for the greatest economic freedom at any point I know of in history.