2 ms·
The situation is not as clear cut as your link claims. A broken window might or might stimulate more economic activity. It depend on, among other things, wheth
by joe_the_user 17y ago
The situation is not as clear cut as your link claims.
A broken window might or might stimulate more economic activity. It depend on, among other things, whether the money spent on fixing the window would have otherwise been horded.
The problem with broken window economics isn't that breaking and fixing them doesn't create jobs but that it doesn't stimulate rational decisions. If a glazier can count on business from hoods he pays to throw bricks in the night, he won't create a business that gives much to society as a whole. Remember, the Soviet Union didn't fall for lack of jobs but for lack of sane economic activity...
And that's what's wrong with cash for clunkers. If a company can just sit and repeat clunker money, they are probably going to just ... create more clunkers.