3 ms·
I understand this type of argument, but it is somewhat faulty. I think we can all agree that the intelligence community can't operate with 100% transparency.
by slg 13y ago
I understand this type of argument, but it is somewhat faulty. I think we can all agree that the intelligence community can't operate with 100% transparency. They can't exactly do their job if they have to specifically tell their targets that they are being targeted. The opposite is also true. None of us want these organizations to operate in complete secrecy without having any idea what they are legally allowed to do.
The problem is that Snowden's actions land somewhere in that huge gap between those two options. We can once again all probably agree that the ideal solution also lies between those two extremes. So trying to frame the debate as if either extreme is a possible outcome or one that is preferred by anyone seems disingenuous.
- higherpurpose 13y agoThat's the problem, while you say we shouldn't use the argument that "spies need 100 percent transparency", they do pretty much use the opposite argument, that we can never know anything about what they're doing, often even their overseers, because it would "endanger national security". Plus, even though the 4th amendment clearly states that you can't even seize stuff from a person, without probable cause. Yet, they keep saying that they can, and it's ok to do it as long as they don't search it. They intentionally omit the seizure part of the 4th amendment. Look at it this way. Would it be ok for the police to come into your home, no proper warrant other than a "general warrant", like the writ of assistance for which Americans rebelled against UK, and take your stuff, as long as they promise to not look through it? I think that would be completely unacceptable and immediately be declared unconstitutional. Yet, NSA keeps pretending it's completely fine to take your "digital" stuff as long as they don't look at it.
- slg 13y agoThat isn't a far comparison to make because the British government taking my stuff deprives me of that very stuff. The US government making a copy of my digital stuff doesn't deprive me of my digital stuff. While I agree that you can't take either government at their word, the fact that one can happen without your knowledge makes it the preferable option from both an intelligence standpoint and maybe philosophically a rights infringing standpoint. I.E. it is the intelligence version of the tree falling in the woods. Are my rights infringed if the infringement has no impact on any of my other rights or my life in general (I didn't say it can't effect your life, but for the majority of people surveyed, I would guess it doesn't)?
- Zigurd 13y ago> That isn't a far comparison to make because the British government taking my stuff deprives me of that very stuff. The US government making a copy of my digital stuff doesn't deprive me of my digital stuff. So, "Information wants to be secretly collected?" That has a certain symmetry to it.
- res0nat0r 13y agoThis sounds like the "information want's to be free" argument people use here to justify copying movies and music, shouldn't it also then apply to your phonecall data? It's all just bits right?
- arg01 13y agoSure, but those making that argument would be right to point out the NSA should be releasing all their data under the same logic.
- darkarmani 13y ago> the fact that one can happen without your knowledge makes it the preferable option from both an intelligence standpoint and maybe philosophically a rights infringing standpoint. I.E. it is the intelligence version of the tree falling in the woods. Are my rights infringed if the infringement has no impact on any of my other rights or my life in general Seizure is the wrong tack. The 4th Amendment also covers searches. SCOTUS has ruled in Katz that a reasonable expectation of privacy triggers 4th Amendment protections (clarified in additional rulings).
- Houshalter 13y ago>That isn't a far comparison to make because the British government taking my stuff deprives me of that very stuff. That is not the reason the restrictions exist at all. It's to prevent abuse of power, not just the police stealing your stuff. Searching your house is, in general, far less abusive than stealing your digital information. You may not keep records of your private activities, you might not have any incriminating physical items. It also takes far more effort for the police to do. Your digital information includes everywhere you've ever been, much of your conversations, the crazy things you Googled because you were curious, the porn you've looked at, everything you've ever bought, etc. Eventually it may even include recordings from microphone and cameras as they become ubiquitous. And all this becomes a permanent record of your life. It will be stored on some computer forever, never going away. Oh ya, and it happens without your knowledge.
- saraid216 13y ago> Would it be ok for the police to come into your home, no proper warrant other than a "general warrant", like the writ of assistance for which Americans rebelled against UK, and take your stuff, as long as they promise to not look through it? Wrong question. Would it be okay for the police to come into your home, not touch anything, but just write down a list of everything they see? What if they did this without the bodily intrusion? It is arguable whether or not the Fourth covers this. There are legitimate legal arguments that can be made for its legality. You might not agree with those arguments, and you might not find them convincing, but you can't dismiss them just because you don't like it. You have to argue that property is, in fact, being seized (which I'd disagree with you on). You have to argue that "search" is sufficient to meet the standard of the Fourth. And so on. If anything, this is one of the most striking examples of how we have to bend over backwards in order to fit 21st century morals and ethics to codes written 200 years ago.
- Zigurd 13y ago> somewhere in that _huge gap_ between those two options The people I have seen on this board defend the NSA's actions don't see two things: 1. How much the US is an outlier. 2. How huge the gap between current practice and reasonableness is. The US spends more than the rest of the world combined on weapons and soldiers. It is likely that intelligence follows this ratio. US military spending is near a historic high in constant dollars. But there is no Soviet Union. There is no military threat that can touch US territory. And yet we spent $TRILLIONS on overseas wars and incurred similarly staggering future liabilities for injured people and worn out materiel. We did 90% of that spending after our adversaries - the "bad guys" as they are referred to - had no weapons larger than a rifle. Not one aircraft. Not one armored vehicle. The answer is not to "split the difference." There are not "two equal sides" to the story. Yes, there must be some state secrets. But none of what Snowden revealed needed to be a state secret. We are no less secure now than before Snowden. What that tells us is that every bit of secrecy around those documents was gratuitous and so were the secret programs themselves. All that secrecy did was to make us less free. So let me challenge you about "either extreme." Let's say someone walked out of Ft. Meade tomorrow with a copy of everything. Including what the NSA knows about every state secret in every department of the government - let's assume that's everything. And then posted it openly on the Internet. Obviously extreme. Obviously irresponsible. Obviously some spies and informants would die. But would that create an existential threat to the US, or not? Would it materially reduce the security of the American people? If not, why not work backward from that "extreme," of having no state secrets at all in small steps, until we have a reasonable and manageable number of state secrets. Everything else is unnecessary and corrosive to freedom.
- pdonis 13y agoThere is no military threat that can touch US territory. The threat our intelligence community is trying to guard against is not military. It's the threat of a terrorist attack. Our elected representatives have repeatedly authorized the intelligence community to do various things to try to prevent such an attack. (Not to mention our military.) That includes authorizing various forms of secrecy. You may not agree with all that, but the remedy is to elect different representatives, who have been clearly informed by the voters that preventing a terrorist attack is now lower priority, so it's OK to spend a lot less money on it. And of course, those same voters would have to agree not to complain to the government if the drastic reduction in spending resulted in an attack happening that could have been prevented if spending on intel had been higher. The fundamental problem is that we want two things: freedom, and safety. But you can't have unlimited amounts of both; there's always a tradeoff. would that create an existential threat to the US, or not? The problem is that nobody knows unless they've seen the information that would be released, and once you've released it, you can't take it back. So nobody is going to run this experiment.