5 ms·
Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling?
- Mz 13y agoI promised some follow up writing on the last thing of mine someone posted to HN, so here is a first installment on that promise.
- facepalm 13y agoI must admit I don't understand why that guy couldn't be seen to be your friend in front of an audience. If that is not possible (for whatever reason), how does it help women? Presumably men can be friends without problems, even in front of an audience. So there would still be an unsolved issue and disadvantage for women.
- Mz 13y agoI plan to write more about this. Part of the problem was that two days earlier, another man in the department was fired over something having to do with an inappropriate relationship to a woman. The entire department was walking on eggshells. I felt it was just extremely bad timing. Another part of the problem is that I had an entry level job and he was very high in the department. So we had very little opportunity to work together, thus it would read as "social relationship" -- again, two days after another man was fired for his behavior towards women. There were other factors. I plan to go into more details in future articles. In this case, I just wanted to talk about the fact that the glass walls of the stairwell fostered a sense of conversational privacy with zero fear of sexual or romantic intimacy occurring. You need conversational privacy to establish trust and do business. But you need a lot more than conversational privacy to pursue romance or sex. The lack of visual privacy mattered to our comfort levels. This man became someone who trusted me and likely would have done a lot for my career had I stayed with the company. That opportunity to talk freely (in the stairwell) without fear that one of us might misinterpret or misbehave was a key moment in the establishment of that trust.
- facepalm 13y agoI can see how it would make feel women slightly safer as it would reduce the risk of touching. But it seems to me romantic feelings could still develop easily. On the stairwell, you could ask the other person if they want to go for a coffee or meet after work. Actually the glass walls these days seem to be more necessary for the men who have to insure against accusations of sexual harassment. I've heard for example that professors at universities always leave their door open or try to have other people present when they meet students, to avoid any such accusations. Of course that might help a little, if men need not be afraid of sexual harassment claims there is less need to avoid women in a professional context.
- jrells 13y agoThe one thing most emphasized to me by my university regarding teaching was to always keep my door open during office hours, for precisely these reasons. An open door (or glass wall) avoids any he-said she-said situations.
- ph0rque 13y agoThanks Michele! As I was reading the Gray Zone post in order to see what the pretext for this post was, I kept thinking that something like google glass would prevent some of the problems. A less techy solution is the glass walls, as you discuss in this post.
- rayiner 13y agoOne of the reasons I advocate that achieving an even mix of men and women in a workplace at all levels of the hierarchy is valuable for its own sake is because it diffuses the Gray Zone to a great degree. My hunch is that if there wasn't a pink collar ghetto and a systematic power dynamic favoring men, the awkwardness of having an unmonitored interaction would be diminished.
- incision 13y ago">It fostered a sense of being able to talk without worrying that it might be misinterpreted as romantic intimacy." I'd never considered this in detail before, but I'm nearly certain that this is why I prefer those stylish glass-walled conference rooms wherever possible. Though, I'm not particularly concerned about romance, rather the kind of paranoid / narcissistic managers who can't bear not to impose themselves on any (opaque) closed-door meeting.
- bsder 13y agoGlad to see this, but I always assumed it was fairly standard knowledge for anybody in mixed situations to avoid closed doors. I know that when I taught college classes most of my fellow professors (male and female) were religious about this.
- Spooky23 13y agoI guess I work in a different universe where people behave themselves better. If anyone talking to anybody in private front of a group of people is a potentially salacious event, the level of paranoia and tension in that place is out of control. At one point, all of my direct reports were women -- if they felt anxious to have a private conversation with me in my office or stairwell, that's a huge problem, and I couldn't have been effective at my job.
- Mz 13y agoAn extremely popular man was fired two days earlier (for either sexual harassment or an affair or both). Tensions in the department were crazy high that week. It was not a normal situation. That was a factor in my decision to not speak with him at that time.
- facepalm 13y agoI hope it was sexual harassment, or can you really be fired for having an affair?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- SwellJoe 13y agoIn many companies the policy is that people in positions of power can't have relationships with their underlings. i.e. a VP having sex with their executive assistant would probably cross the line into unethical behavior on a number of fronts. Even if both parties entered it willingly and with no coercion or implied retaliation for saying "no", there may be questions of favoritism among other employees. The assistant would never be able to rise within the company without that doubt creeping in about their competence. So, if it's not the official policy in an office, it is probably still grounds for action, since most offices expect a certain level of ethical behavior toward coworkers.
- facepalm 13y ago
- PeterisP 13y agoI hadn't wondered about the reasons, but in most recently built office buildings I've seen that almost all the small intra-office "meetingrooms" have glass walls. They insulate sound, so the meeting contents are private but it's very public about who is meeting whom and if anything other than talk is happening - say, escalated conflicts would also be visible.
- cushychicken 13y agoI find the notion of different kinds of workplace privacy an incredibly perceptive observation on Michele's part; I think the glass walls theory would solve a lot of problems by removing environments where bad behavior is enabled due to lack of observation.
- Crito 13y agoI think that opaque glass walls are the best. My office has opaque glass walls on two sides which, in addition to making good writing surfaces for dry-erase markers, allow me to see the fuzzy outline of people as they walk by my office and allow me to see when other people are in their offices (as the glass walls will light up.) The opaque glass walls provide a sort of literal privacy that cubicles or open office spaces don't (such that I don't have to guard my screen when working on some projects, I don't need to excuse myself to the bathroom if I need to adjust my belt, and I can stretch out after sitting for too long without feeling self-conscious), but retain much of the general air or atmosphere of a more open work environment.
- crazygringo 13y ago> The nice man from the stairwell appeared and was clearly making a beeline towards me to talk to me. Not good. Not good at all. This fool, who is still feeling all warm fuzzy over talking to me in the stairwell, is going to talk to me like I'm his best friend. I'm completely confused. I rather enjoying making friends with people at work, male or female (and regardless of "rank"). If you've met someone before, and people are "milling about in an open space", why on earth wouldn't you give each other a warm friendly hi? Why is he suddenly "a fool" in a situation that is "not good at all"? And assuming he's still feeling "all warm fuzzy" (what does that even mean?) As a man, I almost feel insulted by all the assumptions being made here, and the idea that my own natural socialness might one day be so misinterpreted. Maybe something's missing from the story, but I can't even begin to comprehend a place where a friendly hi between two people who met and chatted in a stairwell, or elevator, or lunch line, or any of the other 100's of places you run into coworkers at all levels, is somehow a bad thing. I mean, if the dude's some kind of a creep, then I get it, but the author says he's a nice guy. Total confusion.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- delluminatus 13y agoNot the OP, but I relate to the quoted comment. Maybe my experience will give you some insight. Essentially, engaging in idle chit-chat is very stressful to me. It is far more stressful than anything else I do on a daily basis. In the past, I would feel physical fear when I saw someone I knew in a public place. Oh no, they're going to talk to me. The reason for this is simple: I'm not good at enjoying conversation with people. I have trouble relating to people, so I have to struggle to be conversant. It becomes a game of "what should I say here", or "what do they mean by that", or whatever. I know that if I just said what I wanted I would seem antisocial, so instead I have to carefully mediate my responses. It's very tiring! Having said that, this is really an issue with myself, not with the other person. I would never think to call someone a "fool" because they like to chat. The fool is the person who can't relax and enjoy a conversation.
- 13y ago
- Tycho 13y agoI thought glass walks was going to be another metaphor... Ie about transparency of wages across employees (perhaps in an anonymous fashion).
- trhway 13y ago> At some point, I felt kind of stupid standing in the hall talking for so long and asked if he wanted to come sit at the table in my room. He wisely declined. WTF? worked at Sun where we had offices and never had any issues coming into women's office or with women coming into my office. Would close the door on many occasions, especially if were talking in general (read - critical about Sun) instead of specific work topic. Never heard other people, managers as well, being afraid of doing it. Some people of different sexes shared offices. Following the logic of the article it was Sodom and Gomorrah. I mean, some hear man and woman laughing from behind closed door and think "they are at it again", and somebody, like article suggests, would think "they are doing _IT_"... Why would we allow the later people to rule our lives?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ericb 13y agoI can't help but think of the law of unintended consequences. I imagine entrepreneurs reading this and wondering "can I postpone hiring our first woman so I can avoid this source of awkward situations and liability for as long as possible?" I have no idea how to fix this...
- MattGrommes 13y agoThis kind of story freaks me out because I know that not in a million years would I be able to navigate these kinds of inter-personal situations. Knowing from eye contact and a shrug that somebody didn't want me talking to them but that we were cool and it wasn't personal. Wow. I've had many jobs and I've always just talked to whoever of whatever gender or place on the org chart. I've had to make an intentional study of how to deal with people and still in 35 years I learn there's so much more to figure out.