3 ms·
On the flip side, the cost of caution also decreases. Scenario: a person is approaching a checkpoint and does not obey verbal commands. No civilians are presen
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
On the flip side, the cost of caution also decreases.
Scenario: a person is approaching a checkpoint and does not obey verbal commands. No civilians are present near the checkpoint.
Human soldier: "Oh shit, shoot him, I don't want to get blown up!"
Robot soldier: "Direct extra scrutiny towards target. Do not allow him to approach civilians. Allow him to approach the checkpoint. I only cost $100,000, no reason to kill a human to save my metallic skin."
- citation_needed 17y agoThe tragedy is, to the people calling the shots (ie. the invading military or government), a foreign civilian's life would probably be worth far less than $100,000. As a previous comment notes, civilians killed are thought of as 'collateral'. That's just not acceptable. The burden lies with the occupying/invading forces to do everything possible to make sure civilians aren't killed or harmed in any way. Even actions that would lead to rations being withheld or basic needs not being met could be considered a breach of international humanitarian law and the fourth Geneva Convention.
- anigbrowl 17y agoWrong. The manufacturing cost of the robot may be a mere $100,000. But besides the argument that human lives are often valued at less than that, there's also the security argument: 'we can't allow our technology to be stolen and exploited by the enemy'. I can pretty much guarantee you that one will get trotted out. It's not very logical, but that has never mattered in war. I mean, let's not be naive here. When the fighting in Iraq was intense a few years ago, the biggest threat to coalition (and especially US) soldiers was 'IEDs' - improvised explosive devices, which in turn was a fancy name for 'homemade mines'. Generally these were triggered by cellphone and there were many comments about how cowardly and evil this was (because it was happening to us). Imagine the reaction if these had been mobile devices - or more accurately, when they are. Because while there are many engineering challenges involved, there's nothing fundamentally difficult about it.