7 ms·
I am not enthusiastic about jumping into speculation land, but I would be interested in knowing if the possibility of this being a accident followed by auto pil
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
I am not enthusiastic about jumping into speculation land, but I would be interested in knowing if the possibility of this being a accident followed by auto pilot is possible or totally disproven
My default assumption was they took off, an accident occurred that damaged cockpit and forced a turnaround, the damage was so great that the crew were unable to survive and turned on autopilot to stop an immediate crash, which then flew for seven hours till fuel ended, presumably with passengers pounding on the locked and hardened cockpit door.
So whilst I am in wild speculation territory I would like to know if there are some experts who might be able to say "bird strikes cannot disable radios" or "oxygen canisters do not leak" or "stewardesses can open the cockpit door" or some such.
I tend towards cockup not conspiracy myself.
(I recognise I may have missed discussions covering this and apologise if it is obvious)
- gassit 13y agoApparently the door can be opened. They enter a code and if the cockpit doesn't reject it within a certain time frame the door opens. See Helios flight 522.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoPlanes have flown for hours without any human intervention. That part of it is entirely feasible.
- pedalpete 13y agoI'm not familiar with the inner workings of planes, but from what I've gathered, the timing of disabling the two tracking systems, which are on either end of the plane, is just about the same time it takes to get from one end of the plane to the other, and disable the 2nd tracking system (blackbox). Therefore, it would be a great coincidence that both of these tracking systems would be disabled at the same time. It seems therefore that the most logical explanation is foul play. I thought/hoped the same as you, that some sort of failure resulted in the tracking systems failing as well, and then the plane crashed, but it sadly doesn't seem as likely given the timing of events.
- emeidi 13y agoSo you say the pilot does not have switches in the cockpit to turn equipment on or off? They have to WALK through the whole plane to turn devices on or off?! Bollocks.
- Implicated 13y agoThings that aren't meant to be turned on/off routinely by the pilot? why not? There's enough stuff going on in the cockpit...
- pedalpete 13y agoThe black box is in the tail of the plane, it doesn't make any sense to wire it through the whole plane so the pilot can switch it off from the cockpit. I have no problem with your questioning my logic and my response, as I'm not expert, but keep your bollocks to yourself.
- snom380 13y agoIt makes perfect sense when the top priority is being able to isolate electrical systems in case of an electrical fault or an in-flight fire: http://www.askthepilot.com/malaysia-airlines-flight-370/ http://www.askthepilot.com/malaysia-airlines-flight-370/
- emeidi 13y agoWhy are you referring to the black box at all? ACARS and the Transponder signal the plane's position to the ground, not the black box.
- danford 13y agoI don't think it's supposed to be easy to turn off the tracking mechanisms of planes.
- davepage 13y agoWishful thinking. Aircraft are designed to be operated by professional crews -- not ex-convicts on work release. So, there are accessible circuit breakers to turn various things off.
- jcfrei 13y agothe pilots were shortly on the radio after the deactivation of ACARS (a signalling system). while this doesn't completely disprove your theory about the autopilot it still hints towards malicious intent.
- appreneur 13y agoWe are almost on the same page: here's my theory purely based on what I read! 1.Something happened like explosive decompression, Explosive decompression occurs at a rate swifter than that at which air can escape from the lungs, typically in less than 0.1 to 0.5 seconds.Everybody onboard(including pilots) would have died in less than a second due to castrophic mechanical failure which caused explosive decompression. 2.Plane was on autopilot there after ,nobody complained since nobody was alive.Fell silent into the ocean and rests there. 3.Plane blewup and disintegrated just like an endevaour....leaving only ash...nothing was left. 4.I dont know why boeing company is not talking about this much, they just are silent ....the biggest benefactor if pilot theory is right is boeing.Boeing benefits alot if its pilot error which caused the incident. 5.Boeing looses a lot if its mechanical or structural or some design failure...."The longer-range 777-300ER and 777-200LR variants entered service in 2004 and 2006 respectively"...they are relatively new...however malaysian airlines is boeing 777-200ER 1997 release...is it possible to have some structural or design or mechanical failure which caused explosive decompression...even pilots die in less than a second...if it occurs. 6.Boeing 787 Dreamliner: Cracks Found in the Wings of 40 New...this clearly shows even the latest 787 is not safe leave alone an old plane like boeing 777-200ER. 7.If its done deliberately by some pilot why nobody is claiming credit for it...ofcourse he wouldnt have done it for himself. The whole media is trying to protect the company "boeing" by showing pilot has conspirators...I cannot see even 1% of people questioning boeing the company... Latest Boeing 787 Dreamliner: Cracks Found in the Wings of 40 New.... All the more we should question boeing...
- Jtsummers 13y agoWRT 787, the cracks were a consequence of two things. The new(ish) production methods involved in the aircraft, and the absurdly aggressive outsourcing of the production. The 787 is (was?) in many ways at the bleeding edge of carbon fiber manufacture. Combine that with the stupid notion their management had of sending out 99% of manufacturing outside of final assembly to dozens of different companies (as a consequence of contractors sub-contracting work) meant that they didn't find the design flaws until late in the game. This particular 787 issue doesn't provide any evidence of potential issues with other aircraft.
- rajbala 13y agoThere would have been calls/texts/tweets/facebook posts from the passengers if they were aware that something terrible was happening whether accidental or intentional.
- Buge 13y agoDo they have satellite phones? Over the ocean there is no cell reception.
- rajbala 13y agoIf there was indication that something was awry the passengers would have had plenty of time before reaching the open ocean to use various forms of communication.
- blakeja 13y agoThis is a good question. What are the odds that someone on the flight had a sat cell? If so, would it have worked in those conditions?