4 ms·
Haiku poems have been held to be copyrightable; at 17 syllables, they may be 11 words, or less.
by gojomo 17y ago
Haiku poems have been held to be copyrightable; at 17 syllables, they may be 11 words, or less.
- jacquesm 17y agoSomeone should do a search of all haiku poems then and check to see which ones coincidentially match up with 11 words that were written before the poems release. Personally I think if you want to copyright something you should keep it to yourself. Don't poison the pool with the content that you own in order to extract royalties from the rest of us. It's bound to leak through sooner or later. Let the criterium be that if you perform something in public or spread it it becomes public domain instantly. This will upset lots of apple carts but I really think it is the only thing that in the long term will make sense.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoGah, the internet ate my thoughtful response: PD doesn't protect your right to be named as author, IMO that moral right should be protected as it is in the Berne Convention. Copyright [supposedly] ensures that works move into the public domain. The problem with copyright is that the terms should be of the order of 15 years, not life + 70. Without copyright books would simply not be edited - editorial staff couldn't be paid as on release an opposing publisher (lulu?) would simply grab the book and publish an identical but lower cost copy. The first copy sold would have to assume the costs of the entire production, authors, publishing staff, printers, machinery. Bands would probably still fill venues. But songwriters would be working for free as they could never demo a piece without "spread[ing] it". DRM and contract law would fill the void and IMO less pieces would ever eventually enter the public domain and the arts would no longer provide most of the careers it does now. A painter may still sell pictures, but a photographer could only sell each one once. Any advertiser could use your personal picture if you published it online. Anybody could claim your programming library, not only for free, but as their own if they could access the code in any way. Copyright is not _all_ bad.
- jacquesm 17y agoPrecious few of your examples would seem to me to be a 'loss' of something, most of them would simply change the theater we're operating in. Copyright is not all bad, but that is not the issue here. The issue is whether the sum total of the effect of the existence of copyright is a good thing or a bad thing. My suspicion is that it is a net negative.
- mahmud 17y agoGiven how finite phonemes are, couldn't one make a massive table of english syllables and then generate all their possible permutations? then copyright remove-if #'already-patented-p generated-sequence.
- req2 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haiku_in_English http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haiku_in_English gives as an example the one word haiku 'tundra'.