3 ms·
I'm not saying Kerberos isn't good, and obviously it's going to be better than any "new" system -- after all any new system hasn't seen any real-world testing.
by e12e 13y ago
I'm not saying Kerberos isn't good, and obviously it's going to be better than any "new" system -- after all any new system hasn't seen any real-world testing. All the fluff around the various (http-centric) SSO-solutions is partly from wrapping them around SSL/X.509 -- just as IMNHO one of the problems with setting up (a secure and easily maintained) kerberos deployment isn't kerberos but LDAP.
As mentioned up-thread MS AD does a great job of enabling in-house CA and management -- and it's mostly that I want. I want to use certs for auth most places, and I want it easy! Openssh have shown that public key auth doesn't have to be hard -- but also doesn't have a very compelling story around managing access. The new cert-system might be an improvement -- but it absolutely needs some infrastructure around it to be easy to deploy (and verify).
- zobzu 13y agoin fact openssh has support for full-blown certificates but its also a little more painful. what makes ssh easy to use is that it doesn't have any central trust authority by default. you get a fingerprint and you trust it. if it changes, it warns you.. but in most cases you're going to know why it changed or just accept the change anyway (which is a problem when you admin 10000 servers of course as the warning might be a real issue) central trust/revocation is still an issue everywhere to this day, i think. both technically ("my client trusts this, but do i?") and from the useability pov.
- e12e 13y ago> openssh has support for full-blown certificates Well, yes and no. Do you mean the new cert stuff that's in standard openssh? Which has stuff like: The marker is optional, but if it is present then it must be one of “@cert-authority”, to indicate that the line contains a certification authority (CA) key, or “@revoked”, to indicate that the key contained on the line is revoked and must not ever be accepted. Only one marker should be used on a key line. While certainly simple, it doesn't strike me as very manageable. Or did you mean the x509 patch? http://roumenpetrov.info/openssh/ http://roumenpetrov.info/openssh/