4 ms·
The field of computer security is still too young to handle cash. The biggest barrier for cryptocurrency.
by kalleboo 13y ago
The field of computer security is still too young to handle cash. The biggest barrier for cryptocurrency.
- msgilligan 13y agoI agree with your basic point. However the field of defensive computer security is the same age as the field of offensive computer security. The problem is that defensive security still is not a big enough priority for customers or vendors. When customers walk in to a computer or mobile device store and ask "is this thing safe enough to store my Bitcoins?" and go elsewhere if the answer isn't good enough, we may see vendors up their game. The same flaws that let a government see you naked let crackers steal your cryptocoins. When I'm in an optimistic mood, I think that cryptocurrency could be the thing we need to motivate more people to care about security.
- maxerickson 13y agoCredit cards work fairly well with pretend security. That cuts way down on the purposes where an irreversible digital currency is interesting.
- kalleboo 13y ago> The problem is that defensive security still is not a big enough priority for customers or vendors This is absolutely true. Most people care about price over any other variable. Yet even areas where there are people who prioritize security consistently fail (Apple vs Jailbreakers, Open Source SSL/TLS developers vs CA validation failure). There is literally no code on this planet you can trust 100%. Even the code that sent people into space had bugs. edit: I do like the idea of cryptocurrencies, but I don't trust software enough yet. I'm more bullish on the idea of P2P shared blockchains in the form of namecoin as a replacement for DNS etc.
- chii 13y ago> Most people care about price over any other variable. most people (at least, in western countries) don't pour over the ingredients, or sus out the manufacturing process to see if their food products have poisons in them, or whether they are fit for eating. It's mandated by law. I would like to see security have such measures mandated by law, so that it frees the average joe from having to worry about it. Because face it, the average person can't worry about it - it's an expert field.
- pjc50 13y agoMandating something like FIPS for everything would impair startups quite badly. For the moment I'm quite happy to not have regulations on the development process or content of software.
- drawkbox 13y agoIt is a good thing all of our IRAs, 401ks, issued currencies and markets are behind it and pretty much digital as well now. The flipside is that computer security is much better than the old human security with phones and faxes of back in the day. The newer systems are at least more verifiable and higher security. Crypto currency or not, all of our money is now digital really, it has to be to move fast enough and keep up.
- kalleboo 13y agoNone of those are cash. All of those are reversible in the case of errors. Even the NASDAQ has reversed trades.
- drawkbox 13y agoYes transactions between financial entities should have some reversibility but bitcoin is more like real physical cash that also can be tracked. Stolen physical cash ends up in the same non reversible predicament. The fact that crypto currencies leave a digital trail and verification actually makes it a tad safer than cash if it was a true stable currency which it isn't yet, but one that could offer that between larger crypto currency 'banks' which is what the market does now with real money, the networks and institutions aren't there for crypto currency yet. Eventually entities will do the exchanging for you in return for the transaction reversibility, just using another currency or crypto credit. Already happening with stored wallets, exchanges and more. Eventually they will be banks. But currently bitcoin is as safe as having actual cold hard cash in your hands.
- _delirium 13y agoEven cash is slightly more "marked", since bills have serial numbers, and it's more difficult to launder large amounts of cash than to send BTC through a mixer. Doesn't help much in small-time cases like having $100 stolen from your wallet. But it makes it harder to make off with a large amount of cash and then actually spend it. A common way of tracking bank thieves is to blacklist the serial numbers and wait for alerts from cash-counting machines that check the blacklist (mostly at banks and back offices of large businesses). Then investigate the areas where blacklisted serial numbers pop up. It's not foolproof, but it makes it much harder to successfully do anything with $10m in stolen cash.