7 ms·
Mozilla's 4.5” Dual-Core Reference Phone
- pcx 13y agoAndroid (AOSP) these days is not a functionally complete mobile OS with Google pushing lots of functionality into their closed apps. Mobile really needs a complete OS which devs can use as an off-the-shelf product, and mod according to their needs. FirefoxOS and Ubuntu Mobile are probably the only real contenders now. Both have their pros and cons, but I sincerely hope that either of them (if not both) would succeed. One very important thing Google added to the ecosystem was drivers. Android using Linux essentially made nearly all mobile hardware work on Linux, even though some drivers are closed. I remember the days when getting a projector to work with Linux was a pain, and I am not even 25! EDIT: My comment on AOSP is in this context: http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/02/neither-microsoft-nokia-nor-anyone-else-should-fork-android-its-unforkable/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/02/neithe... http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/10/googles-iron-grip-on-android-controlling-open-source-by-any-means-necessary/ http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/10/googles-iron-grip-on-... I do accept that Google has added great value to the ecosystem with AOSP. It's just that AOSP is pretty much unusable for people without the resources of Amazon, Nokia, Mozilla, etc. I want something like Debian/Ubuntu. It's pretty much possible for a single person to build a customized OS for computers. We need that for mobile.
- swetland 13y agoDianne's response to the recent "AOSP is unusable" silliness is pretty solid: http://www.hnwatcher.com/r/734444/Google-s-Dianne-Hackborn-comments-on-Ars-s-Android-open-sourceness-FUD-piece http://www.hnwatcher.com/r/734444/Google-s-Dianne-Hackborn-c... Regarding drivers, we expended a lot of effort to push things as open as we could. We never shipped any binary kernel drivers for any lead devices, something which most OEMs and silicon vendors seem to have stuck with. We insisted on linux-on-the-metal instead of solutions where it would be virtualized under a closed hypervisor that had the "real" drivers and other such insanity. GPU drivers have been the biggest uphill battle -- getting all the vendors to agree to GPLv2 kernel components to handle resource management and ensure that userspace is not directly poking the hardware, alongside their "secret sauce" in userspace was better than nothing and better than closed binary kernel components, but not ideal. It seems like we're finally seeing some motion in this area. Watching Nokia, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and others take AOSP from its git repositories and build full products on top of it is, I think, among the best evidence that there's an awfully useful base platform there. If people were to augment that with open source alternatives to various Google (or other) cloud services, that would be cool. And of course folks can take AOSP as a base and extend or modify it however they like in a fully open way -- follow the model of cyanogenmod that's been tracking AOSP and adding their own enhancements, goodies, or platform support on top of it, for example...
- pjmlp 13y agoExcept other than a minority, no users will care if they don't get access to Google services.
- Spearchucker 13y agoYour points are noted, and I agree with you. But I'm not convinced by Dianne's post. Big red flag is what on earth you need cloud for to provide a location service? And mail? An MTU is a client app by definition. Open implies supporting popular protocols - that hardly creates a dependency on Gmail. The biggest issue of all though is how most apps are virtually unusable without an internet connection. That, in the real world, happens a hell of a lot more often than people like Dianne care to realise. I call bullshit. Her post is as biased as the posts she's responding to.
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoThe reason you need tho cloud for location service is because you can save user time and battery by doing a lookup based on nearby wifi points, a database of which is stored in the cloud. Relevantly, Mozilla are trying to build an open one of these. https://blog.mozilla.org/services/2013/10/28/introducing-the-mozilla-location-service/ https://blog.mozilla.org/services/2013/10/28/introducing-the... Though privacy issues make it complicated for people to just download the data, rather than make a call to the cloud. Those who object to the whole idea of this will probably just have to accept slower lookups. I'm not sure what you're saying with your other points, I would have thought a GMail app would be expected to have a dependency on GMail. The Email app (which Ars claimed was abandoned, yet just got a overhaul) is there for communicating over popular protocols to non-Google services.
- Spearchucker 13y agoI use a normal (non-Gmail dependent) MTU for my Gmail. What user need does the Gmail-dependent MTU from Google fulfill that warrants that dependency? As far as I can tell, my non-Google MTU adds more functionality to GMail than GMail has. As for AGPS - great. But we already know that location services function quite well without it. Did you know that you can do AGPS and drastically reduce time to fix just by initializing a GPS receiver using your last known location? AGPS with a location obtained from a WiFi SSID (via a call to the cloud) is only faster when your last known location is drastically different to your current location (another state, or country). I won't believe that Google is incapable of designing a location API that's extensible. There's a non-technical reason, and that reason is in conflict with the openness Google likes to play up.
- tombrossman 13y agoI have to disagree with the statement that AOSP is not functionally complete. I'm using it on a Nexus handset with F-Droid and I'm really pleased at how easy it was to switch over. I was rooting my phone anyway and this started as an experiment. I had the ROM and the separately packaged Google Apps package (Google Play Services, etc...) and thought I'd try skipping the extra Google stuff to see how it worked. Haven't looked back since. Some of the replacement apps are functionally superior to the Google versions, though I concede these are not as user-friendly for non-technical users. Nothing against Google really, I have a GMail account as a secondary email and I like the default Google search on the Firefox browser. I just don't need any more than that and so reject the added complexity of flashing all the Google stuff on top of AOSP.
- bad_user 13y agoI did the same thing with an older Galaxy S that I have lying around. I installed CyanogenMod on it without Google's services. Have been installing apps from F-Droid. I use Apollo, VLC, K-9 Mail, OsmAnd and Firefox. At some point I also installed some apps from Amazon's App Store, but I then realized that I don't really need any of that crap. People saying that AOSP is not usable don't know what they are talking about. That said, I'm also planning to get a phone with Firefox OS and I think it has a bright future, just because it is based on web standards. I really like the approach taken by Firefox OS and Chrome OS.
- pcx 13y ago> People saying that AOSP is not usable don't know what they are talking about. The Linux kernel is usable. Why don't you just start from scratch with the kernel? When I say AOSP is not usable for normal folks, I mean it's not comparable to the existing solutions we have for computers.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- noinsight 13y agoThat mobile OS is Mer (-> and Jolla with Sailfish OS). It's probably the only real contender at the moment.
- lern_too_spel 13y agoNonsense. If AOSP isn't functionally complete now, it was never functionally complete. Nothing has been removed from AOSP.
- girvo 13y agoI know you meant that at 'pcx but while AOSP is functionally complete in terms of it giving you a base to work from, most would consider the lacking services, etc that it's missing to mean that it's not what most consider "Android". Of course, I love hacking on AOSP and it doesn't bother me, for a ROM that replaces the "missing" Google services, Replicant is the way to go.
- nakedrobot2 13y agoDEAR PHONE MANUFACTURERS: WE DON'T GIVE A SHIT ABOUT THIN PHONES. WE WANT BIG BATTERIES THAT LAST MANY DAYS. Sorry for an all-caps comment that is only tangentially relevant to this particular article/phone, but I am goddam sick and tired of NO mainstream phone manufacturers getting out of this "We'll compete on fractions of millimeters that you'll never notice, we'll tell you what you want, we'll condition you to plug in your phone every chance you get like some kind of direct-current junkie" Ugh.
- arrrg 13y agoWho is “we”? Please speak four yourself.
- samastur 13y agoHim and me. I think that is already enough for we ;)
- hrktb 13y agoThere's that feeling of loneliness when you want something, but the market moves away and leaves you with only out of date devices fully matching your needs. I sympathize. And if there is a market for 5mm case+battery packs (and really, aren't these almost only available for iPhones?) there should be a market for a phone with twice or more battery life from the start, built-in. I don't think nakedrobot2 is the only one wanting that.
- leoc 13y ago> And if there is a market for 5mm case+battery packs (and really, aren't these almost only available for iPhones?) For phones with replaceable batteries such battery cases are somewhat unnecessary as you can just make/use an extended battery with a replacement back cover. Check out this beauty, for instance: ;) http://www.amazon.co.uk/5200mAh-Extended-GT-I9505-18-Month-Warranty/dp/B00CPLEKTO/ http://www.amazon.co.uk/5200mAh-Extended-GT-I9505-18-Month-W...
- 13y ago
- yeukhon 13y agoAh. I recently bought a used iPhone 3GS for $40 on eBay because my old Motorola Atrix's screen is sort of broken. I didn't want to get a new phone until I have a budget. I thought about getting ZTE Open but two things pushes me away from FxOS. 1. ZTE Open's spec is many times weaker than my Atrix's. I already find Atrix slow. Spending $70 on a phone in that spec is still not affordable for me. 2. The FxOS ecosystem is still a lot smaller than iOS and Android. I know it is new but that a number of popular apps (Instagram, Gmail, GMap) are not yet available on Mozilla Marketplace. I understand that the initial launch is targeting at countries where smartphone usage is low. But what people need is a phone not buggy and laggy. I want to see a phone with powerful spec so #1 goes away. I can then still rely on the web interface to do #2, provided that the phone is powerful enough so I won't lag while opening multiple web pages! I like FireFox OS and I really want to own one, but right now I am going with iOS (I will avoid Android) given how rock solid iOS is in my experience. Keep up the good work, FxOS team.
- darklajid 13y agoI know this came up before in Firefox OS threads, but .. I failed to dig it up. Any phone recommendations? Reference devices sounds fine, but a) where do I get one (and for how much)? b) what other options do I have to get into Firefox OS?
- kevining 13y agoThe ZTE Open is probably the easiest route to go, and you can order it on ebay: http://www.ebay.com/itm/ZTE-Open-powered-by-Firefox-OS-3G-unlocked-smartphone-orange-eBay-exclusive-/281165818989 http://www.ebay.com/itm/ZTE-Open-powered-by-Firefox-OS-3G-un... But the ZTE Open C is should be just around the corner: http://www.engadget.com/2014/02/23/hands-on-zte-open-c/ http://www.engadget.com/2014/02/23/hands-on-zte-open-c/ Alternatively if you have a nexus 4 or 5 you can flash FirefoxOS on top of it.
- darklajid 13y agoI looked at that (Open, didn't know about the Open C, thanks!) before and while that looks like a reasonable (price) entry, I wonder multiple things: - how well these devices are supported? Are these FF OS devices really future proof for a while (think 'supported' upstream, kinda like Nexus devices or fully supported CyanogenMod builds)? Can I follow FF OS without waiting for e.g. ZTE? - Those are low spec devices. I understand that FF OS wants to target the lower end of the market and is supposed to work well in that environment. But is that the case? Will I be able to give these a spin as my primary device for a time? The second issue is lower in priority. Even if these things don't allow me to replace my main Android phone, I'd still love to peek at FF OS and play with the development environment, but a 'daily driver' would be quite interesting as well.. Only thing I found so far is the Geeksphone Revolution, but without testing it first/getting a decent idea of what that can do I don't like to spend 250-300 EUR (and that doesn't seem to be a high-end device either).
- frik 13y agoGreat news that Firefox OS will be on tablets (VIA Vixen, Foxconn InFocus) too. I wonder if there are already plans for Firefox OS release for desktop/notebook (like ChromeOS). This could be a huge thing.