4 ms·
What Capitalism? America is the largest welfare state in history. Total government expenditures are nearly the size of China's GDP. What we have is corporatism,
by adventured 13y ago
What Capitalism? America is the largest welfare state in history. Total government expenditures are nearly the size of China's GDP. What we have is corporatism, plunder by a combination of bureaucrats + government protected corporations (see: Verizon, AT&T, Comcast, Exxon, Pfizer, etc).
I wish we had Capitalism. All we have is an extraordinarily misdirected, poorly run welfare state.
- chongli 13y agoYou can't separate the state out like that and pretend it's not a player. Capitalism is what gives rise to corporatism. Oh, and welfare state is not a bad word. Some of the most prosperous and equitable countries in the world are welfare states[0]. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model
- adventured 13y agoA poorly run welfare state is a bad word, to so speak, and that's exactly what America has. Some of the worst functioning countries on earth are also very poorly run welfare states. Feel free to point out several poorly functioning, free market Capitalism countries though. Socialism is what gives rise to Corporatism. The intrusion of government into the economy - rather than the proper separation of the two - through regulation and bribes, opening up a flood gate of protectionism, lobbying and special favors. I'm well aware of the arguments on the nordic model. Most of them had to reform their poorly functioning welfare models over the last few decades (see: Sweden). http://www.forbes.com/forbes/2009/0803/international-invest-guide-obama-sweden-public-downsizing.html http://www.forbes.com/forbes/2009/0803/international-invest-...
- amalrik_maia 13y agoNordic countries only implanted welfare after they developed economy. Welfare State means the goverment can take your money and spent it in what they they think is best for you.
- wwwtyro 13y ago> Capitalism is what gives rise to corporatism. Corporatism is a legal construction of the state: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporation#Formation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporation#Formation
- galactus 13y agoin that case, it can be argued that the soviet union was not real Communism either.
- Houshalter 13y agoIt wasn't and many people do argue that whenever the subject comes up.
- galactus 13y agoI know, my point is that both "real" capitalism (the libertarian kind) and "real" communism are fantasies.
- Double_Cast 13y agoWhenever I hear the word "capitalism", I interpret it as "private ownership" by default. I have to remind myself they probably mean the "Laissez Faire" flavor of capitalism. It screws with me sometimes.
- adventured 13y agoThe difference being, to achieve full Communism you have to kill everyone or enslave them completely such that they have no rights. Stalin, Mao, Lenin, Pol Pot, Fidel, Kim il-Sung - they all gave it their best try. And your comparison isn't accurate at all. There are obvious and often massive differences between America's economic models of 1825, 1910, 1960, and 2014. 2014 isn't in any respect similar to the 1825 or 1910 versions. To argue that America in 2014 is highly Capitalistic, is to argue that Capitalism is compatible with a government system taking 40% of the economy through taxation, massive wealth redistribution, government interference in essentially every sector, nationalization (quasi or total) of core economic segments, welfare programs sprawling to hundreds of billions in cost, tens of thousands of regulations covering every field, and on and on - basically it's like saying that Capitalism can be anything. It can't, it's a specific type of model.
- chongli 13y ago
- akfanta 13y ago- Total government expenditures are nearly the size of China's GDP Total government expenditure of USA 2013: 3.45 trillion (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_United_States_federal_budget http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_United_States_federal_budg...) GDP of China in 2013: 8.3 trillion (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomin...) If I am not mistaken, the federal spending budget includes military spending as well.
- scottjad 13y agoYou forgot to include state and local government expenditures, which perhaps almost double the number. And maybe he was thinking of a China GDP number from a year or two ago. When I google "China GDP" it gives me $7.3 billion from 2011. And "nearly" is subjective. And most military spending is welfare, either to defense contractors or otherwise.
- Florin_Andrei 13y ago> America is the largest welfare state in history. Welfare for the rich. Naked social darwinism for the poor.
- refurb 13y agoMore than 50% of the federal budget is for social programs. You're saying those only go to the rich?
- stefantalpalaru 13y agoThat's not the amount that trickles down to those needing the social programs. Most of it is lost in the skimming off the top done at each of the many layers along the way.
- refurb 13y agoThat's a ridiculous statement. You can easily look up what payouts are made to individuals. "Most" is lost. Give me a break.