6 ms·
Interesting hypothesis that would square with this: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2014/03/a-hypothesis.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-
by nostrademons 13y ago
Interesting hypothesis that would square with this:
http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2014/03/a-hypothesis.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2014/03/a-hypoth...
- fosk 13y agoThis is an interesting article. One of the comments also gives another plausible solution. Pasting it here for convenience: "There are a number of troubles with that theory Charles, one of which is that the plane should have followed its intended course and stayed on radar by passive reflection, but it is certainly also one of my favourite theories right now. The lack of debris near where it disappeared from the radar opens the door to more "interesting" theories, such as kidnapping or theft. First of all, identifying planes by transponder code is not hard ID. It would be perfectly possible for co-conspirator plane to fly transponder-less up to the target plane, take over the transponder code, and fly decoy on the official route, while the MH370 goes elsewhere. That means that the point of "last contact" doesn't tell us anything but the existence of an electronic device acting like a transponder at that time and place. Turning the transponder off and tailing another transpondered plane very closely is another way to disappear from ATC without plastering the surface with debris and then you are also more or less free to go wherever you want, until somebody visually spots two planes very close. The decoy plane does not need to be the same size, so the probability of such visual detection would be low. Therefore, suspecting foul play, we don't have any trustworthy information about the planes whereabouts after the last visual sighting of the plane. It would be interesting to know if there were any high-value targets on that plane, amongst the passengers or in the cargo. If the cargo was the interesting bit, killing off all the passengers by dropping pressure and oxygen is trivial. One interesting nugget is the rumour that "passengers phones are still ringing". That's sufficiently implausible that nobody would take it seriously and actually follow the SS7 data. But if true, it would be explained by the plane sitting somewhere at the edge of a jungle, for instance on the remains of an old WW2 strip, passengers dead, and cargo gone."
- mootothemax 13y agoIf the cargo was the interesting bit, killing off all the passengers by dropping pressure and oxygen is trivial. When was the last time a criminal killed ~240 people in order to steal some loot? The solution proposed would, at best, be extraordinary; flippantly adding mass murder makes it absurd.
- noobermin 13y agoI mean, it would seem easier to steal the cargo at the airport before it got on the plane, just bribe a few ground workers, I guess. Steal some passports, hijack, then divert the plane just for cargo? It wasn't the cargo; the only reason to hijack the plane would be either the people or the plane or both. Or, it was an accident.
- mootothemax 13y agoI mean, it would seem easier to steal the cargo at the airport before it got on the plane, just bribe a few ground workers, I guess. Steal some passports, hijack, then divert the plane just for cargo Exactly. Even if we want to be horrible about it and suggest beating up and possibly killing ground worker(s), that's a waaaaaaay off killing 240+ people on an airplane.
- mseebach 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_Airport_diamond_heist http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_Airport_diamond_heist
- ekianjo 13y ago> * On February 22nd, aircraft 9M-MRO underwent maintenance. During this, or during a previous maintenance cycle, an empty oxygen bottle was installed by mistake for a full one, or a valve was jammed, or some other undetected fault rendered the flight deck crew's emergency oxygen supply inoperable. That sounds extremely unlikely. Standard procedures for equipment checks in plane are usually done at 9 sigma standards, i.e. they involved numerous checks by different people. We're not talking about an amateur doing maintenance at home during the weekend. And I doubt there would be a single oxygen source in the cockpit since airplanes are usually built with multiple redundancies. I don't really buy that one. Plus the plane did not make it to any military radar either - so where did it fly for 5 hours?
- Blahah 13y agoHe does reference the case of Helios Airways Flight 522[0], where a similar situation happened as a result of human error (leaving the pressurisation system set to manual). 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522
- ekianjo 13y agoThis was not the same place (737 is damn old in design, from the 70s, 777 was designed in the 90s), this was not an international flight (security standards for international flights are stricter), so I'm not sure he even tries to compare both of them. Why not reference a Cessna incident as well ?
- mootothemax 13y agoEdit: deleted hostile, snarky content.
- wilg 13y agoI think you're being unfairly hostile and snarky here. This isn't a good way to get your point across.
- banachtarski 13y agoDamn that is an interesting theory. I think there should be a way of getting into the cockpit if it can be determined that the pilot and copilot are incapacitated. That would be a miserable way to go. :P
- mbreese 13y agoBasically, a dead mans switch for the cockpit door lock? Where the pilot/co-pilot has to hit a button every N minutes? That might not be a bad idea...
- Blahah 13y agoThere is an emergency access code to get through the security door, at least on a 737: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2014/03/a-hypothesis.html#comment-1926816 http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2014/03/a-hypoth....
- mbreese 13y agoHere's one potential problem with that theory... that plan was equipped with an onboard GSM microcell, right? So people could still use their phones? These should run over a different set of antenna, so if the other set was ripped away, this satellite link should have still worked. So, if something like this theory happened, why didn't someone in the main cabin use their phone to call home? Unless everyone suddenly lost oxygen at the same time...
- ekianjo 13y ago> So, if something like this theory happened, why didn't someone in the main cabin use their phone to call home? If rapid decompression occurred, there could have been panic in the plane, making it difficult to establish any kind of communication. Who knows...
- mikeash 13y agoTime of useful consciousness after loss of pressurization at a typical airliner's cruising altitude is about 15 seconds. Your lungs basically operates in reverse and pump the oxygen out of your body as fast as your heart can beat. Once that deoxygenated blood hits your brain, it's lights out. I'd be rather impressed if anyone was able to make a phone call within 15 seconds of an explosive decompression. Presuming it was explosive, of course.
- retrogradeorbit 13y agoThe best part of this theory (which I think is good) is: "Losing Helios 552 might be a freak accident, but if decompression and a locked door led to the loss of MA370 as well, then this would be a new threat that will now have killed 360 air travellers—many times more than have died as a result of hijackings since 9/11. Is it appropriate to employ anti-hijacking measures to prevent violent hijackings a couple of times per decade, if they run the risk, as a side-effect, of crashing in-service airliners a couple of times per decade?" That's funny! When has there ever been a proportionate response to the threat of terror? The response to 9/11 was so over the top and all out of proportion to such an mind-boggling degree that the idea that they would address this is a bit ridiculous. Even if hundreds of thousands die to prevent one plane being hijacked, it would all be justified as just what needs to be done to fight TWOT. National Security!!
- omegant 13y agoThere is a code that can be used by the cabin crew to access the cockpit in this cases. It's cancelable from the inside, so if a hijacker tries to use it you can put it of once it starts ringing(it rings for 30 seconds and then opens the door). So this case of pilots unconscious is covered. Any way I agree that the spending after the 9/11 is insane and unecessary.
- TomAnthony 13y agoThat seems like a good solution. Why did the crew of the Helios flight not do that?
- zimpenfish 13y agoSomeone mentions further down in the comments that they did - just after an "unexplainable" two hours. Presumably it was far too late for any remedial action by that time.
- mikeash 13y agoAlmost immediately after the fellow finally gained entrance to the cockpit, the plane ran out of fuel. So your "presumably" is completely correct.
- anigbrowl 13y agoBoeing already said that the plane in question doesn't have the device fitted, so the question of fuselage cracking around it is moot.
- plantain 13y agoThat AD was not applicable to this aircraft as it didn't have the antenna he's speculating tore off installed at all. http://www.thestar.com.my/News/Nation/2014/03/13/Missing-MH370-Boeing-says-Malaysia-jet-not-subject-to-FAA-inspection-order/ http://www.thestar.com.my/News/Nation/2014/03/13/Missing-MH3...
- malandrew 13y agoI'm curious why there isn't redundancy in oxygen supplies? Under such conditions would the crew at least be aware enough to know the oxygen tank they are drawing from is faulty and that they need to switch to the backup tank.