4 ms·
"[O]therwise you can kiss anything but the most trite (read: cheap to produce) pop music and plotless explosion-fest movies goodbye." I'm not sure pop music is
by dllthomas 13y ago
"[O]therwise you can kiss anything but the most trite (read: cheap to produce) pop music and plotless explosion-fest movies goodbye."
I'm not sure pop music is cheap to produce (compare the tech work and marketing and all involved in a band playing at your local venue with that at a ... um... Taylor Swift? is she still a pop star? concert), and "plotless explosion-fest movies" tend to be the most expensive movies - "2012" and "Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen" each cost 13 times as much as "The King's Speech".
"If people can't get paid to pursue their dreams, they have to shelve their dreams in order to get paid. Then you have one less author, one less musician, one less movie being made."
Most authors and musicians already do something else in order to get paid.
'Nuclear power plants "want" to melt down, dams "want" to break, influenza "wants" to spread, etc.'
When those things happen, hundreds or thousands or millions of people are harmed. When information spreads, hundreds or thousands or millions of people are enriched. We should find another way of rewarding artists than fighting an uphill battle to constrain value.
- api 13y ago"We should find another way of rewarding artists than fighting an uphill battle to constrain value." Trust me: if such a thing were found, every single artist would be all ears. Solve this problem and you're the next Zuckerberg. Non-solutions include artists having to rely on charity, "they'll just make money touring," tip jars, DRM, and micro payments (unless they can be made incredibly seamless and low-friction). But making an app specifically designed and targeted so as to impoverish artists is a dick move.
- dllthomas 13y ago'I'm working on it.Trust me: if such a thing were found, every single artist would be all ears. Solve this problem and you're the next Zuckerberg. 'Non-solutions include artists having to rely on charity, "they'll just make money touring," tip jars, DRM, and micro payments (unless they can be made incredibly seamless and low-friction)." I'm working on it. "But making an app specifically designed and targeted so as to impoverish artists is a dick move." We have a commons for a reason. If I read "A Tale Of Two Cities" instead of "Twilight", I'm impoverishing artists - and artists can fucking suck it up.
- api 13y ago"We have a commons for a reason." Changing the subject.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dllthomas 13y agoNot at all. The subject is trade-offs we're willing to make which sometimes mean less money goes to artists. If I read Dickens instead of something modern, I'm entertained (... maybe) and my money didn't go to any artist. Permitting something like Popcorn Time, which makes parts of the commons imminently more accessible (as well as making some things that aren't part of the commons accessible) clearly shares similarities.
- killerpopiller 13y agowell, there are ways,there even is a infrastructure already in place. The german GEMA manages artists rights and is huge. They have the means to compensate artists whos works got fileshared. RIAA and others are already tracking the p2p-networks, companies like BigChampagne earn money with what is downloaded where exactly to optimize marketing. If we would install a monthly culture flatrate, we have a win win.