10 ms·
Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox
- sukuriant 13y agoWas that video running in Chrome? Honest question, if that's the new Firefox, it really, really looks like Chrome...
- epmatsw 13y agoFirefox's new theme does look a lot like Chrome. The tabs are more rounded and the color scheme is a bit different, but without going into the menus it's hard to tell them apart at first glance sometimes.
- dorkrawk 13y agohttps://blog.mozilla.org/ux/2013/11/australis-is-landing-in-firefox-nightly/ https://blog.mozilla.org/ux/2013/11/australis-is-landing-in-...
- Pxtl 13y agoOh yuck, they're bringing back the big wasted void along the top of my page? The fact that Firefox replaces the title-bar with tabs is my favorite feature of the darned thing.
- mrec 13y agoChrome and current FF have the same "big wasted void" when not maximized. You need something you can grab to drag the whole window about, as opposed to a single tab. It goes away when maximized, and I'd hope Australis will stay the same.
- leeoniya 13y agohttps://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/classicthemerestorer/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/classicthemer... you're welcome :)
- ehsanu1 13y agoThis also highlights why Firefox's addon system is in some ways superior to Chrome's extensions - this would be impossible in Chrome.
- dingdingdang 13y agoTry Palemoon, it highlights FF's basic openness (and compile-ability on a _not_ 8gb+ rig) very well too and fast while it's at it.. Also I would advocate using a custom userChrome.css file for FF instead of extensions, much lighter and clearer setup in my opinion.
- ubercow13 13y agoHonestly when you actually use it it doesn't really look or feel like Chrome very much in my opinion.
- rhelmer 13y agoThe new UI (Australis) has landed on the Firefox Aurora channel, if you'd like to check it out for yourself: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/channel/#aurora https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/channel/#aurora
- Touche 13y ago> demos Asm.js needs fewer demos and more finished production applications. Apparently Epic isn't excited enough about this technology to release one of their games on the web.
- pcwalton 13y agoThere aren't even any native Unreal Engine 4 games out yet that I'm aware of: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Unreal_Engine_games#Unreal_Engine_4 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Unreal_Engine_games#Unr... That's the purpose of this demo: to show that the Web stack is ready even for upcoming AAA games, not just ones from a few years ago.
- Touche 13y agoBeing ready for games doesn't mean games will come, just as U3 games haven't come (except for the one that hasn't shipped yet). Would be nice if Epic shipped one of their games; why haven't they?
- zxcdw 13y agoDoesn't matter who ships, as long as it can be done without reasonable tradeoffs. The nature of the Web as we know it gives so many benefits in form of e.g. ease of deployment that it'd be outright wonder that there wouldn't soon be a rush of games exploiting the platform.
- rhelmer 13y agoThere is a link in this blog post to one from late last year that describes the first commercial game powered by asm.js being launched: https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2013/12/12/first-3d-commercial-web-game-powered-by-asm-js-unveiled/ https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2013/12/12/first-3d-commercial...
- taeric 13y agoThis is neat and all, but I wonder if things are really better moving to "in the browser." The discussion is of "upwards of 60% as fast as native." Is this using the same amount of processing power as native, or is this "67% as fast as native, using 200% of the CPU as a native solution?" I mean, I realize that processors and machines are only getting more capable. It seems silly to start requiring faster and faster processors to achieve what slower ones could have achieved. I would rather we just kept achieving more.
- stcredzero 13y agoFor a high level managed language, 67% would be pretty godlike. There are some C programs that are less than 67% the speed of their own -O2 compilations. If 67% native speed winds up being the average efficiency, that's plenty good enough for the vast majority of computing. As recent history has been teaching us, doing more with less has mainly to do with getting more mobile, distributed, and ubiquitous. We're quickly reaching the point where that means something even "smaller" than a web browser. EDIT: Could WhatsApp be the 2nd coming of WAP?
- taeric 13y agoYou ignored my 200% mark, though. If I could run this demo in the browser and it pegs all of my cpus, compared to running the same demo "native" and having half my system capable of idling, I'm not sure I see the win. Even if it gets to 100% of "native." (I hate that it sounds like I am claiming that is the case here, as I really don't know.)
- stcredzero 13y agoA game like this is a singular and extreme case. I can see a really big win for lots of business software. With browser deployment, lots of logistical problems just disappear. Heck, the notion of traditional corporate structure starts to disappear: Corporations exist because they can provide lowered transaction costs in specific contexts of production. I'm not sure I see the win. Even if it gets to 100% of "native." Even if Unreal engine FPS don't get to 100% of native, that doesn't preclude the disruption of lots of other software distribution models, including entire subgenres of games. But it goes much farther than just games.
- clarry 13y agoEpic Games and Mozilla are demonstrating how the Web is continuing to evolve as a powerful platform [..] And you're still using a youtube embed because a single, simple tag like <video> is too effin' problematic. Yeah yeah, I get it. <video> isn't relevant to gaming. WebGL and gaming are cool new stuff, <video> is prehistoric crap nobody cares about anymore. The world has moved on.
- pvnick 13y agoThis is very exciting. I've had the chance to meet Brendan Eich a couple of times at Moz conferences, and he never fails to strike me as a visionary and a super nice guy. Between the asm.js stuff and Rust (which I actually had the privilege of witnessing the much-anticipated unveilling several years ago. Honestly I thought it was an overly-ambitious fools errand but that's why I'm not cto of mozilla), he really seems to be driving Mozilla exactly in the right path of where the web is going.
- Pacabel 13y agoFrom what I can see, Mozilla is generally going in a direction that's alienating existing users, without necessarily bringing in any new ones. For example, it's widely understood today that Firefox has a much smaller share of the market now than it did a few years ago. Most measures I've seen show a drop from somewhere in the mid 30%'s down to under 20% today. Proportionally fewer Firefox users means less influence over the future direction of the web, of course. SeaMonkey never really had that much penetration to begin with, and still remains basically irrelevant. Firefox OS doesn't really seem to be taking off. While it may sound nice from an ideological standpoint in terms of openness and standards and all of that, in practice it doesn't sound very enjoyable or practical to use. I've seen enough people show displeasure over the low-end devices it's commonly used with, with the highly restrictive development environment (being forced to essentially use JavaScript/HTML5/CSS for apps), with a lack of features, and a lack of apps. Those are very serious and fundamental shortcomings. Thunderbird and Persona have both been "turned over to the community". That appears to be a polite way of saying that Mozilla has given up on them. Asm.js is pretty unremarkable. It's a human-unfriendly subset of JavaScript. NaCl is a much better approach that would ideally be adopted by the major browsers. Unfortunately, we've seen nothing but hostility toward it from Mozilla. Rust sounds appealing, but it's not really usable today. We keep hearing that there will be a stable release sometime later this year, but we'll need to see that actually happen first before it'll have any chance at being widely adopted. Even then, it's doubtful Rust alone will have any major impact on the web any time soon. Servo may, but that's clearly very much also an unusable work in progress at this point. So overall, I don't see Mozilla as heading in a very positive direction. They really haven't had any wildly successful new offerings in quite some time now, and what they have been working on lately doesn't seem to be getting all that much adoption. Without a large base of users, their influence over the development of the web will just get weaker and weaker.
- higherpurpose 13y agoThis doesn't even use WebGL2?
- azakai 13y agoWebGL2 is a work in progress, but I believe this demo can use some WebGL extensions. And I think WebGL2 will include those extensions by default. So there is some connection.
- pjmlp 13y agoThis is very nice indeed, except it does not work on mobile devices.
- azakai 13y agoCurious why you say so? Have you tested it? WebGL works on mobile devices, not all browsers have caught up yet, but there is progress.
- pjmlp 13y agoApple does not allow WebGL except for iAds. On Android, only the users that install Chrome besides the native browser, have very up to date version of Android and a device that isn't blacklisted can see WebGL. WP is still not there. Most casual users don't install third party browsers like FF. Why bother with WebGL on mobile, when native allows for using the handset resources properly, not drain battery and have a bigger deployment target?
- azakai 13y agoI agree, on mobile, the average device+browser today is not going to run WebGL well or not at all. But, beta versions of browsers on the same devices show good performance. I think it's just a matter of time. But again, right now, of course native on mobile is the way to go.
- pornel 13y agoIt does work. I've ran UE3 demo in Firefox on Nexus 5.
- pjmlp 13y agoBut it does not on iOS, WP and Android devices just with Chrome. Until WebGL is properly supported on mobiles it is just a toy and native is the way to go.
- ebbv 13y agoThey say "without plugins" but that's kind of misleading. Firefox includes asm.js functionality, but no other browser does. Just because it's included by default doesn't mean it's not a plugin. Chrome includes Flash by default, it's still a plugin.
- onedognight 13y agoasm.js is a subset of JS, so by the conventional definition, it is not a plugin. The game should run, albeit slowly, on other browsers.
- azakai 13y agoI would not say "slowly" - that sounds like it is objectively sluggish for the user, which is not the case. Try the Epic Citadel demo in chrome - works great. Depends on the benchmark, on many Chrome has already caught up, on others perhaps not. But there is constant improvement here.
- williadc 13y agoNot true: https://blog.mozilla.org/futurereleases/2013/11/26/chrome-and-opera-optimize-for-mozilla-pioneered-asm-js/ https://blog.mozilla.org/futurereleases/2013/11/26/chrome-an...
- cromwellian 13y agoI just bought Titanfall yesterday. I run this on a watercooled PC, dual GPU setup. I wouldn't have bought such a PC setup just to run at 60% of system performance. I think Mozilla is marketing this wrong. Triple-AAA titles go for squeezing every last ounce of system performance. I don't think there is anything to be gained to putting a game like Titanfall, which has 5 gigabytes of assets (some UE titles are much bigger and need blu-ray distribution) inside of a browser. Long downloads, long startup, half performance. But there is enormous value of running casual games with asm.js. Something like Clash of Clans, or Flappy Bird will run just fine. Pitching that asm.js is going to scale games from mobile up through desktop performance I think is overselling things and bound to lead to disappointment. Rather than believe we're going to get Call of Duty running acceptably on Firefox OS. Let's first settle for CSR Racing, or HayDay.
- nawitus 13y agoYou can cache the assets locally, just like on any other game. These tech demos are about pushing the envelope, which is needed to make the web a better platform for high-end games.
- Pacabel 13y agoHow is this "pushing the envelope"? Running existing software in some convoluted browser-based environment, and giving a worse experience in most ways, doesn't really seem like innovation to me. I think we could say it was pushing the envelope if the browser experience was superior to the native experience in every or almost every way. But that just isn't what we're seeing with these demos.
- azakai 13y agoIt is far superior in one major way - everyone has a web browser, and you can give them a link to run your game if it runs on the web. This avoids losing most of your users which is what happens if you ask them to install a plugin or a native app. Of course, on the other hand it is inferior in many ways. It's just another option for game creators (and other apps too). For some it will be useful, for others it will not, just like consoles are useful for some but not for all, tablets are useful for some but not for all, etc. etc.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThis is really cool, I've always had a soft spot for the Unreal Engine. But it reminds me once again, why the hell does Flash even exist any more? While I get the whole "HTML5 wars" thing, I've done standards and I know how those get mired in the muck, but if you can write a game engine with this level of performance, writing an open source 'flash' equivalent should be pretty doable right? And open source and open tools and don't bother with the quacking of the standards guys, just focus on something that works right?
- dave809 13y agoMozilla is working on it :) http://mozilla.github.io/shumway/ http://mozilla.github.io/shumway/
- mschuster91 13y agoAll the asm.js stuff... well, they still haven't ported UE3/UT3 to Linux, haven't they? Sidenote: IIRC all UE code is cross-platform compatible - so shouldn't it be possible to fuse the UE3 JS engine port and the UT3 content to provide a "cross platform UT3"?
- pcwalton 13y agoWhy not use Firefox on Linux? That's a Linux port.
- jebblue 13y agoIt's a YouTube video? Will it run on Linux? I still have UT3 in the box new, the promise of it running on Linux evaporated even though UT2004 ran better on my machine on Linux than when I ran on Windows on the same machine.
- azakai 13y agoYes, it runs on linux. (I use linux and I've tested many of these demos, perhaps not this specific build though.) The only issue with linux is if you have older GPU drivers, they might be blacklisted by the browser and WebGL support will be off. But if WebGL is enabled and your drivers are stable, will work fine.
- kayoone 13y agoIts quite contrary to the approach onLive and Gaikai have been taking with streaming games from the cloud to any device that is able to output a video stream. I tried some Gaikai demos before they were acquired and to my surprise it worked very well. Both have their ups and downs but as i see it the ultimate endgoal would be your desktop in the cloud accessible from any device by realtime low-latency streaming. In that scenario gaming in the browser would still be possible but make a lot less sense.
- soapdog 13y agoargh people here are so negative. You get a lot of the content you consume over the web. You can stream videos over the web and that is more convenient that using DVDs. you get "facts" from wikipedia and similar resources and thats easier than picking dead tree encyclopedia. This is about convenience. When games start being playable on browsers you won't need a local install or different ports for different platforms. You will need just a browser. It won't matter if you're on windows, mac or linux. It will just work. That means reduced cost for the studio. That means less support calls. That means easier setup. That will also mean that people will be able to experience with less mainstream stuff. Sharing stuff on the web doesn't require Apple, Google, whatever company approval. It becomes easier to create content and users have less resistance to opening a web page when compared to installing a game. Also its safer since JS language is pretty safe regarding exploits and viruses and general malware when compared with something built with native code on your machine.
- stoptalkingshit 13y agoClueless. Just clueless. None of these benefits are tied to the crap browser platform that's been foisted on us. The stewards of the browser did a terrible job of designing it, as proven by shoddy hacks like asm.js. Did you know that it took WebGL to get them to introduce typed arrays? They weren't smart enough to see the usefulness of this, they had to bumble into it. Same with async HTTP requests. So woopty-doo you've caught up to where the JVM was over a decade ago. Semantic HTML has been destroyed by this mindset also.
- stcredzero 13y agoNone of these benefits are tied to the crap browser platform that's been foisted on us. No, but they are tied to the web, for which browsers and JavaScript are an incumbent technology. You are right, in the same way that Windows has nothing in particular to do with games, outside of a fortunate adoption of DirectX. It's just that it's the way the world turned out. Admittedly, there are downsides.
- stoptalkingshit 13y ago