7 ms·
Why I am Not a Professor, or The Decline and Fall of the British University
- javanix 17y agoAnd here we have the reason why just about every single CS department in the US teaches Java instead of C or Scheme.
- amichail 17y agoJava is an improvement though, especially under Eclipse. Even better would be using Python followed by Scala. Perhaps the issue is that too much class time is spent teaching details of a language and its libraries.
- javanix 17y agoYes, the hours upon hours of instruction in basic CS courses that were devoted to the various mundanities of Java abstractions drove me nuts. I'd much rather have spent that time learning the more-useful mundanities of memory management in C.
- Locke1689 17y agoNo. Java and Python and Scala are not improvements. Why? They're too easy. Pointers are hard (relatively). Compiler design is hard. Complexity theory is hard. A loss in any one of these sections is a loss to the degree as a whole. The ACM ICPC helps a little in promoting intelligent problem solving (every CS student should be able to write a program to use Dijkstra's algorithm in under 20 minutes from memory), but it's the university's fault in the end. Fortunately in the United States, some of our top universities seem to have (thus far) escaped the treatment that other ones did. Stanford, Yale, Caltech, MIT, CMU, et al. all continue to teach very much the same curriculum that they taught intro CS students 10 years ago. Systems is a required course and taught in C. Intro programming is a required course and taught in Scheme/LISP. Unfortunately, many schools did not fair so easily and now teach Java or some-such exclusively. I think that this is partially to blame for the number of unfortunately bad computer science students with degrees. How to change this, I have no idea.
- cpuddle 17y agoAbout pointers being difficult...I don't think that pointers are difficult to understand. To me it was more the syntax C uses that got in the way.
- gacek 17y agoYou have got to be kidding us. But I don't really get it - what is difficult in & and * operators? I do teach programming, and most of the time I see both the concept of pointers, and syntax is pretty understandable. The real trouble begins when you expect students to use them to their advantage - but it really is beyond syntax.
- cpuddle 17y agoUnfortunately I'm not. I tried learning C as my second language after VB and the syntax seemed unnecessarily complicated to me (like '->'). As a newb, you get bogged down in the details and knowing the cases for when to use &,* seems like an added complication.
- tetha 17y agoSee? This syntax trouble is already lesson #1 you learn from pointers: The _address_ of some value and the _value itself_. If you have a pointer (that is, the address), then you need to prefix it with a * in order to get the value in order to do useful things. If you have a value, you need to prefix it with & in order to get the value's address in order to pass it around more efficient (at least it will be more efficient if it is some large data blob). Did anyone ever mention addresses and values and their difference when looking at Java from a users point? Not to me, to be honest.
- Retric 17y agoPointers are easy. I thought several people in our CS program how to use them in ~2 hours. What's hard for most people is thinking abstractly between what the code looks like and what happens when you run it. Pointers are simply the first thing that forces most coders to consider that split. But, a reasonably competent JAVA developer moving to C can pick them up in little time. The problem is reading other peoples C code that looks more like line noise than structure. But, pointers are a tiny step along that path.
- thras 17y agoI'd rather see C taught than Scheme. Hardware matters, and a good CS-education should be centered in languages that recognize that. Software engineering, on the other hand is too important a subject to be left to the schools. Let them learn Scheme on their own. They'll appreciate it more that way.
- javanix 17y agoC would be my first preference as well, but I also appreciate that Scheme (or another functional language) would provide better opportunities than C or Java for students to learn more "advanced" algorithmic techniques such as recursion. The problem with Java (and C, to a lesser extent) in basic problem solving is that you can almost brute-force-code and get a working solution that will get full credit, but after writing it a more elegant (and efficient) solution isn't always obvious. In functional languages, that "more correct" solution almost always seems to stand out more, at least to me.
- sketerpot 17y agoRecursion is only considered an "advanced" algorithmic technique because people are taught to think of it that way. Recursion is actually pretty straightforward once you have a bit of practice using it.
- javanix 17y agoWell, yes, most things do become easier with a bit of practice. If a functional language was taught in beginner CS classes I think it would be easier for students to see how it works. It certainly "clicked" for me once I'd learned a bit of Scheme in my first AI class.
- Locke1689 17y agoIntro CS courses at MIT, CMU, and Northwestern are taught in Scheme.
- 17y ago
- tybris 17y agoThe real failure here is the words "instead of". It's really not hard to learn both and especially good to learn when to use which.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jzachary 17y agoMy god. It's truly amazing how any technical or academic topic seems to degenerate into a Java vs C debate. Is there a law for that?
- tetha 17y agoI think the "Java <-> C"-debate is an instance of the problem "Should studying computer science be mindwreckingly hard or should studying computer science make you able to program things?". Plus, you can also bash Java in this special instance, which is always nice coughs. Other instances include "Compiler construction or not?", "Theoretical computer science or not?", "Assembler or not?".
- javanix 17y agoThat would hold up if learning a bit of memory management was actually "mindwreckingly hard".
- DarkShikari 17y agoAfter reading the first sentence of said post, I actually thought he was trying to criticize Java.
- tetha 17y agoAnd then you had to debug something which resulted from corrupted pointers into the stack, partially being still good data and partially being nonsense.
- omail 17y agoAt my university, Intro to Prog. is in C and C++ (yes, both), and the course that immediately follows is in Scheme, some made up language (we had to build an interpreter for that language in Scheme) and Haskell (for the motivated students).
- scott_s 17y agoI think comments like there are border-line trolls in a community like HN. The languages used in various parts of a CS curriculum are one component to the whole. Holding up that component as the reason that the sky is falling is, at best, disingenuous. I can construct terrible CS curriculums that start with C, and terrific ones that start with Java. If those who construct the curriculum want the beginning courses to focus on algorithmic thinking, I think it's fair to use a language that abstracts away much of the physical machine. The abstractions can be peeled away in later courses. If, instead, they want the beginning courses to focus on the realities and difficulties of dealing with computer systems, it makes sense to start with something like C. They can then introduce the abstractions that let people manage those difficulties in later courses. I think both approaches are valid, as long as a student gets a view of the important points of the field. I can even see arguments why one approach might be better than the other. But claiming that one approach represents the failure of our CS academic system is zealotry.
- gaius 17y agoYou have to meta it one level. The reason C was taught was because it was close to the machine without actually being assembly language. That's pedagogically useful because it exposes the student to all the properties of the Turing machine without having to be too specific about implementation (not that MIPS assembly isn't also a good choice). Similarly, the reason to teach Smalltalk is to teach OO, the reason to teach Lisp is to teach Lambda Calculus. The only reason Java is taught is because students demand it because they've heard that if you know Java you can get a good job. Now, that doesn't imply that Java shouldn't ever be taught. But the reasons for choosing any language should be academic reasons. Particularly, it is bizarre to see academia trailing industry in language adoption.
- scott_s 17y agoYou claim that "the only reasons Java is taught is because students demand it," and it appears your objection is based on this claim. Do you have any support for this claim outside of your personal belief? My undergrad made the switch to Java right before I graduated, and they are a counter-example to your claim. Also, I doubt your claim about C is true. C was used because it was close to the machine without actually being assembly. I suspect C was then taught because it was used everywhere.
- DrJokepu 17y agoI had very similar experiences as a Computer Science undergraduate not many years ago at a prestigious British university. The expectations were so low that eventually I stopped attending lectures and got a full-time programming job and I still kept getting quite good grades. The problem is so widespread that it's not just about undergraduates; as an undergraduate I have met several PhD students who struggled with even basic programming or mathematical concepts. Still, in a class of 300 people, there are still about 10 very talented and bright students who'd rather be (and not afraid of) writing Prolog interpreters and doing similarly interesting and cool stuff. There should be a way these students could learn advanced concepts with while being mentored by professors.
- edw519 17y agoGraduating computer-illiterate students who had to do a project in computer science was more of a headache. For whom, you or those of us you have to work with them?
- sketerpot 17y agoEveryone. Although, really, this goes beyond being just a large headache for everybody involved; it's more of a startling clusterfuck. I mean, honestly, how does a system get to be so broken that they graduate CS students who can't program a computer? Or simply stop offering core classes like compilers?
- jlees 17y agoA really interesting read and very much echoes some of the reasons I chose not to pursue a career in academia. When you realise you're at a fork in the road, and down one route lies being a supervisor's paper-churning-out slave, researching something that doesn't even interest you so the department can get more funding...grnnnh. Edit: To clarify, this was my problem, as a PhD student with a PhD supervisor (not sure what the US term is; adviser?) who was forcing me to do the wrong thing all in the name of academia.
- brent 17y agoI wouldn't say that is an entirely accurate characterization. I don't know anyone in my department doing research that doesn't interest them. Students generally love the research they are doing and are probably a bit more autonomous than your comment seems to imply. I've taken both directions (industry then academia) and in industry I was a code-churning-out slave working on something that barely interested me. Now I work on my own on a topic that really interests me!
- amichail 17y agoWouldn't you say that pursuing a startup is better than both industry and academia?
- tome 17y agoNot if you enjoy really theoretical work which is far away from the money.
- amichail 17y agoTrue, but the number of such people is very small.
- bbgm 17y agoNot at all. Not a CS guy, but research was some of the most fun (and trying) times of my life. Figuring how things work, or how to make them work better is a ton of fun. It's not for everyone, sure, but all scenarios have their pros and cons
- ivanyv 17y agoThat was very interesting. I live in what you'd call a 3d world country (Mexico), and this stuff makes me think about why empires fall and others rise... The rising stars get to watch how an empire falls ;-) One of my dreams is to open a school that's much better than most of the schools in Mexico, using the good and bad examples of schools in countries like the US and the UK. My 2 cents to leave to the world.
- jacquesm 17y agoYour dreams are definitely worth pursuing!
- dangoldin 17y agoAnd probably a lot easier in the modern day as more and more people get access to the web. I'm very interested in web learning and am trying to put something together for it too.
- jacquesm 17y agoI've had a long conversation with someone that is very much into this and there are some challenges but it definitely is possible. Already there are tons of lectures online in flash video format. It's amazing the stuff you can learn about but to actually make lesson material and tests work in an online environment is far from simple (cheating for instance!).
- dangoldin 17y agoI imagined something along an entirely different approach. Putting videos online is just doing it the same way over a new medium. I am thinking of a way to take advantage of what the web has to offer. We'll see how it goes.
- jacquesm 17y agoYes, I got that, sorry for not being clearer. The videos are a simple starting point, there is no interaction and so on, it's just like watching TV (only worse quality...). The subject of the discussion was basically a complete virtual education from grade school level all the way up to university level. Interactive lectures, web based self-study units the works. We realized that this is a very complex undertaking and that it would require fairly massive funds to be executed properly as well as an enormous amount of expertise.
- bkovitz 17y agoCertainly, there's loads of stupid "research" in academia—cranking out papers that interest no one, in order to justify tenure and more grants. However, "90% of everything is crap". The relevant question, before you throw out the entire institution, is: Are there real opportunities to do good work? Good work takes two main forms in academia: research and teaching. Is good research work being done? Is good teaching being done?
- jerf 17y ago"The relevant question, before you throw out the entire institution, is: Are there real opportunities to do good work?" I disagree. The relevant question is, "What is the best possible way to do good work, including practical concerns taking into account the behavior of real people and not just theoretical people, and is that what we have? If not, how can we get there?" The way you ask the question is basically the same thing as the sunk cost fallacy. Yes, we've got a lot of investment in the current system, but if it isn't working, it's time to change it to something that will. Whatever that may be. And, again, the question is whether it is working with real people, not hypothetical people who are custom-designed to work with the system you want to be ideal.
- nostrademons 17y agoThe best is the enemy of the good. I'd shorten the question to "Can we do better?"
- jongraehl 17y agoI'd rather start with with pondering "what's the best way (that I can imagine)" and then move to "what's the surest route to improvement". I don't think it's usually the case that someone who asks "what's the best ...?" is really only interested in things that are absolutely the best.
- bkovitz 17y agoIndeed, comparison with other opportunities is most important. I didn't make that clear. If you can do better teaching and/or better research outside the university, then go for it. (I am wrestling with this decision right now.) That would be a good reason to resign professorship, not the fact that a lot of university people are doing mediocre work. My understanding, BTW, is that there is lots and lots of fantastic research being done in universities. You have to find it and hang around with the right crowd. Dr. Tarver's problem may simply be that he didn't find the opportunities.
- imack 17y agoTo be fair to the time, in 1999, there was the dot-com bubble going on and a lot of students were going into CS for the wrong reasons so there could have been more at play than government objectives. I suspect there were a lot of CS students who did not enjoy programming in such programs, thus accounting for seniors who couldn't do projects. I know CS and programming are not the same, but I liken it to studying Shakespeare and not enjoying reading or writing. Our school (UWaterloo) noticed a huge drop in CS enrollment soon after that, between 2002 and 2004 (roughly). At which point business programs saw a spike in enrollment. I wonder if this professor had stuck around whether he would have noticed an improvement once the stories of 24 year old billionaires were removed from the headlines.
- karanbhangui 17y agow00t for UW (CEng student here). pew pew.
- christofd 17y agopew pew. we have lazerz :)
- christofd 17y agono, you guys don't get the background story, regarding University of Waterloo's new logo.
- karanbhangui 17y agoseconded.
- Locke1689 17y agoI am an American, so forgive me, but I was under the impression that UWaterloo was also regarded as one of, if not the best, CS schools in Canada. I would argue that many of the more elite universities have managed to beat back this trend for the most part, as I do not believe that Stanford or MIT are graduating substandard computer science students.
- 0wned 17y agoWe can't generalize. Not all students are like the ones described in this article. I work with CS and CE graduate students 40 hours a week. I help them conduct research. The best of these students have an eagerness and desire to learn. They work on projects at home in their spare time, they learn new languages (just for the sake of learning them), etc. They want to learn C and C++. They love it. Since I work directly with these kids and have seen dozens come and go, it's easy for me to quickly pick out the good ones. They are the most fun to work with too as they teach me as much or more as I teach them. I see the average/bad ones too. The ones who do just barely enough to get by. The ones who "code by Google". They are far more common than the good ones. Their work speaks for itself. Poorly written, plagiarized and seldom delivered on time. Hopefully employers have methods in place to weed out the bad and average kids. And incentives to hire and more importantly keep the best ones. Just my 2 cents.
- sasamat 17y agoI can't comment on the US experience, but as a student in the UK in the 80s and Canada in the 90s I concur with Mark Tarver. This is not just a CS issue, it's universal and the real damage is being done in the second tier establishments where grade inflation and dumbed-down courses are endemic. The tier one establishments (Oxbrige, Ivy League etc) can still use their own screening methodologies for aptitude and smarts to minimize the problem. As a result---and to continue Tarver's analogy of the Cultural Revolution---the 'party' is looking after its own whilst the rest goes to rot.
- cabalamat 17y ago> This is not just a CS issue, it's universal and the real damage is being done in the second tier establishments where grade inflation and dumbed-down courses are endemic. It's worse that that, because the dumbing down doesn't just effect universities. Secondary school science education has also been badly hit. The links that follow contain actual questions from GCSE science exams (note for non-British people: a GCSE is an exam typically taken by 16 year olds). For example, in a biology exam, a question asked whether you see with your eye, ears, nose or mouth -- http://cabalamat.wordpress.com/2009/03/30/do-you-see-with-you-eyes-ears-nose-or-mouth/ http://cabalamat.wordpress.com/2009/03/30/do-you-see-with-yo... Here's a physics exam, that's not quite as absurd -- http://cabalamat.wordpress.com/2007/08/31/gcses-are-dumbed-down-and-getting-worse/ http://cabalamat.wordpress.com/2007/08/31/gcses-are-dumbed-d...
- IsaacL 17y ago"For example, in a biology exam, a question asked whether you see with your eye, ears, nose or mouth -- " No it doesn't. The question is "which organ contains light receptors?", which although simple, does requires some knowledge of scientific jargon. And this is on the foundation paper, for which the maximum mark is a C - IIRC, the intermediate and higher papers don't include questions this easy. This type of question is not for A-Level candidates, it's for distinguishing between the weaker students. Of course it's worthwhile keeping track of what kind of questions appear in exams as a benchmark of educational standards, but only looking at the worst examples you can find does not give a clear snapshot.
- blasdel 17y agoJust yesterday he announced that he's quitting his Lisp dialect, computing in general, and Britain: http://groups.google.com/group/Qilang/browse_thread/thread/592773c562017d87 http://groups.google.com/group/Qilang/browse_thread/thread/5...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tybris 17y ago> By pre-1990 standards about 20% of the students should have been failed. Interesting, I find that number quite low. The failure rates for most CS courses at my BSc/MSc university (VU Amsterdam) usually hovered around 50% in the post-00s era, especially for the hard-line courses such as computer networks, finite fields and data structures. We were allowed to do an unlimited number of retrials (6 months in between), but still over a third of the students would drop out before completing their BSc. When I started my PhD at a British university I was obliged to do some MSc courses. Basically every course started with: No one will fail this course. At first that seemed like a comfortable idea since I didn't want to be distracted from my research. Soon I learned that actually means the course is going to be boring as hell. I don't believe the Dutch system works better than the British one. We've had our share of choice fanatics. Despite Andy Tanenbaum raking in millions, my current department is also a whole lot better funded than the VU. I think it has more to do with attitude than politics. Tanenbaum basically created the department with his bare hands, writing Minix and his well-known books in the process. He's no longer actively involved in teaching, but he created a culture of outstanding education. There's still an enormous amount of attention on making courses more interesting, challenging and up-to-date. It's easy to get lazy and lower your standards, but not impossible to say no and become a better university.
- BrentRitterbeck 17y agoThis is the result of the university becoming more of a business than anything else. If you start flunking people out, you lose revenue.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThis would be true if the business were selling degrees. If the business were selling an education, then it would actually result in increased revenue, since students would have to stay around longer to learn required materials. Lots of business sell education instead of certifications. The problem here is the government stepping in and mucking around with standards, creating financial incentives that looked good in theory but don't work in the real world. This happens a lot with well-meaning politicians trying to "help"
- b-man 17y agoI think most people are missing the point here. What he is saying is that CS (and the university model itself) has stopped being a correct vehicle for preparing students for a technical society. I happen to agree with the guy. The model is broken, and we should move on to something much more libertarian, where the individual is in control of its own learning.
- bkovitz 17y agoAs a completely self-taught software engineer, I'm inclined to agree. Except for one big doubt: A large percentage of people do not excel on their own. They rely on social standards to specify what counts as "good enough" and to provide them a roadmap through the learning process. Of course, that's what vocational schools are for, not universities. Universities got confused when they started pretending to offer job training.
- alanthonyc 17y ago" the counterfeit academic Mozarts are common and a contributory cause to global warming and deforestation." A gem of a quote, and a worthwhile read.
- springcoil 17y agoYeah I worry about the fact that this discussion became an emotional discussion in regards programming languages. There is a lot of evidence that students learn Java, because of the job market. I've worked in a school as Physics Teaching Assistant for a year (while at grad school) and the huge problem in Ireland, the UK and the USA is that people assume that students know best about choice etc. The fact is students are rubbish at telling what they'll enjoy, and most students will shirk away from thp the harder sciences etc. But the responsibility is to keep up the standards of academic rigor. Some wise young Cambridge scholar said to me recently 'When u audit something you change the standards, and the aims of it. League tables made schools focus on results, modularization make students focus on results, the job market makes people look for certain skills' and that is true. My most useful course in Philosophy at University, was a course I despised at the time. Perhaps we need to just let professors set the courses, or we get to the scenario that scares me the most when I get Physics graduates who don't understand what a Partial Derivative is. A CS graduate who doesn't know what the Lambda calculus is, is perhaps the same?
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoHe does have a point, but something is missing in most such lamentations of watered down academic standards. It's that education, in the past, was not meant to be vocational training and therefore the eoconomic case for broadening access just wasn't there. Knowing classic literature was not (functionally) why upper class kids of past times went on to earn much more than their lower class peers. It was just part of the symbolic glue that allowed members of that class to recognise each other. Throughout history, access to good education was by birth, not by talent. Most analyses featuring Mozart are flawed. It's probably because nobody is quite sure whether the purpose of education systems is to find those rare individuals with innate genius, or rather to teach a large number of reasonably intelligent people something so they are more capable of solving particular problems as a result. I don't think there is one approach that is suitable for doing both. Mozart is often introduced into the debate by those demanding more stringent standards of admission. However, if it's about finding the Mozarts of the world, radical and indiscriminate broadening of access must be the top priority. It's the nature of innate genius that it occurs just as likely in illiterate african street kids as in the offspring of english professors. Taking on a large number of totally unprepared kids and exposing them to interesting stuff is probably the most beneficial approach to finding the Mozarts. Demanding good preparation and high entry standards is a social filter, not a talent filter. So I think, universities must commit themselves to actually teaching students something instead of whining about low entry standards. I fully understand that the author of the article does more than that, and I agree with his other points. But let's face it, universities are there to bring as many people as possible onto a high level of knowledge and skill. The goals are largely economic ones and that should not be lamented. They are no longer the kind of upper class culture club they once were, and they are not primarily an endeavour to find the Mozarts and Einsteins.
- Goladus 17y agoThere are lots of problems with the Mozart analogy. For one, Mozart was trained by his Father. His education in music began at a very young age (which is common among many if not most of the highly successful classical concert musicians in the world). For another, despite the fact that Mozart's music was creative (I've loved every Mozart piece I've ever heard performed well and most of those that haven't), from a superficial perspective many of them are also remarkably similar. If you aren't ready to appreciate subtle differences you aren't ready to appreciate Mozart for many of the reasons his music remained popular for 200 years after his death. Which brings me to the next point, which is that he talks about Mozart's music existing in a sort of historical vacuum, and doesn't bother to compare Mozart's work to the work of his contemporaries [1]. Most of his contemporaries have been forgotten by the mainstream, for various reasons, but while they were alive they still produced a lot of music. Finally, while there is creativity in science and one can take a scientific approach to creating (or "discovering") music, it's difficult to argue that the importance of scientific rigor is not more important in a paper about Algorithms for Mesh Analysis than in a Piano Concerto in Eb Major. [1] Wikipedia lists 64 composers in Mozart's era: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Classical_era_composers#Late_Classical_era_composers_.28born_1750-1770.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Classical_era_composers...
- IsaacL 17y agoShould be "The Decline and Fall of a British University". The only thing this article tells us is the quality of the students that study at Leeds. It's a bit of a stretch to extrapolate from experience of one department in one university to claim that the same is happening everywhere.
- gaius 17y agoIt's up to you to show that central government's national policy only applies to one university...
- incandescant 17y agoNo, he's right. I've experienced this first hand during my undergraduate and second hand through friends at different Universities. It's the sad truth of (the majority*) of British CS education... I'm led to believe Cambridge, Oxford, York and probably a few others still teach good CS courses to strong students, but on the whole ...
- coolestuk 17y agoHis experience at Leeds is not uncommon. I originally graduated from one of the better known universities in 1983, and returned to post-graduate study and teaching in 1989. I experienced an even worse scenario then he - teaching as a part-time temporary lecturer at several of the 3rd tier universities (polytechnics). Even when students turned in work that was totally incoherent (unfinished sentences and half the size of the minimum word count), I wasn't allowed to fail them. This was on modular degree courses, were most (if not all) of the assessment was of such submitted work. For years I witnessed half the students turn up to class with no recriminations against the non-attendees, and with only half of the actual attendees having read the 1 or 2 articles which were required reading for that class (photocopies of which they had been given previously, so they didn't have to find the original journals themselves). The overall level of education and comprehension was appalling. I realised that pursuing such a career was a path to frustration. In 1997 I decided I couldn't be part of this sham any more. I have friends who had gone through the same experiences as I, and they too decided to quit and find new careers. The story of one of them was even written up in a national newspaper ten years ago. I have other friends who teach only at post-graduate level. They are shocked by the lack of basic maths, basic grammar and basic essay-writing skills of the graduates they teach. And in their institutions they too provide the students with all the reading matter, so that these post-graduate students don't have to find their way round a library or find out anything for themselves. Degrees from UK universities were now meaningless, and it was only a matter of time before the wider world found out. What will probably happen is that employers and/or students will realise that in the majority of work-related degrees the degree itself doesn't indicate anything in terms of skills or competencies. Several of my neices and nephews have gone to university. Whilst I went there to study, their principal purpose is to party. My partner is Thai, and I know several of his family and friends who graduated from Thai universities. Some have completed post-graduate qualifications. Yet they would never read a book that was more complex than Harry Potter (even in Thai). Nor would they ever go to a museum or art gallery. Degrees have just become something that most people do either as a way to move out of home safely and/or a stepping stone to a job. For most graduates there is no sense of education being important in itself.
- teeja 17y agoThe gentleman is right on; in the US too it's far from a new story. The decline started in secondary and then spread up through higher education. But does the fault really start with the students, as he claims, or is that blaming the victim? Certainly noone wants to work as hard as people used to ... that's a fact. The old culture (50 to 100 years ago) also supported a much lower population, and there were many more resources - many trees to chop, dams to build, necessities to invent ... all that's now paved over. Many more people wanted to attend college to get 'the good jobs'. Only,there was only such much demand on the high-end. You wind up with an over-educated population, deep in debt, with Great Expectations that just won't be happening. Those who can't be anaesthetized with TV or video games or web-surfing inevitably turn their frustrated analytical skills upon the powers-that-be. So, well, here we are. Clearly colleges are in for a deep re-organization. We need to recreate eduction - but to what end? what future will we re-tool to create?. And how will we provide opportunities for all that 'computing power' waiting to be harnessed!