5 ms·
In fact, exercise does help people lose weight. A hundred years of research has proven it. Go read it. Your claim falls apart very quickly and very simply with
by adventured 13y ago
In fact, exercise does help people lose weight. A hundred years of research has proven it. Go read it.
Your claim falls apart very quickly and very simply with basic math (and everybody can test this starting immediately):
Scenario: I'm a 225 pound, 6'2" male, basically healthy. 30 years old. I keep my diet constant at 2500 calories, and begin burning 750 calories per day through exercise. I will lose weight, and likely gain muscle (which will accelerate my body's natural caloric burn rate), and there's nothing that can prevent that from occurring in a healthy person.
Weight loss is a total calorie equation. Exercise forces your body to consume calories at a higher rate, reducing the total left for the body to store. It's that simple.
Another extraordinarily easy proof for this: Michael Phelps. Phelps was famously consuming 10,000 daily calories, lots of it trashy carbs like pancakes. His exercise routine - swimming countless hours per day - is the sole reason he didn't balloon to a thousand pounds. So run this test: consume 10,000 calories per day, do zero exercise, watch your weight explode upwards by 50 pounds in about a month; begin exercising heavily, enough to burn the excess calories, watch as your weight 'magically' falls.
- maxerickson 13y agoA lot of the questions in the science are about whether an unsupervised person adding exercise will end up with a calorie deficit. There's no one serious that questions calories in vs calories out, but there are lots of people who question whether it is the right place to start, because of things like measurement difficulty and the relative unlikeliness of adherence to a given diet/exercise regime.