5 ms·
Dot-Com IPO Insanity Returns With Coupons.com
- ignostic 13y agoI can agree that the market is over-valuing coupons.com, but not with the overall emphasis on past profits in IPOs. "But they're losing money and hugely over-valued!" is a sentiment I hear a lot from traders and observers who deal in established companies, but it may or may not apply to IPOs and new companies. Coupons.com has been around for a long time (1998), and if it hasn't figured out a way to be profitable in 15 years I don't think a cash infusion is going to help. I don't see any evidence of a new product or service or a new revenue stream. In fact I'd bet against coupons.com growing as users become weary (for the non-technical) and wary (places like HN) of additional browser addons. COUP aside, sometimes it's wise to ignore profits in an IPO. Emerging markets, new technologies, and early-stage high-growth startups are good examples. For example, Tesla lost over 55 million the year before its IPO.[1] Some said the shares were too high, but it paid off[2] for those who saw the potential. Musk pointed this out himself: "A lot of people were puzzled about why we were going public without profits,” Musk told reporters outside the Nasdaq building in Times Square. “The reason we are not profitable today is because we are in the midst of expanding with the Model S." New product, new market, growing company. Check. Proven management team with realistic expectations and a strong proof-of-concept? Check. In Tesla's case it makes sense to ignore past losses and bet on the long play. While coupons.com could become profitable, I'll be shocked if the premium paid on this IPO pays off. [1] http://www.wired.com/autopia/2010/06/tesla-ipo-raises-226-1-million/ http://www.wired.com/autopia/2010/06/tesla-ipo-raises-226-1-... [2] https://www.google.com/finance?q=tesla https://www.google.com/finance?q=tesla
- tonyhb 13y agoI really don't think that it's fair to compare Tesla with Coupons.com. Tesla has net assets of $2.4 billion, with IP that's worth a considerable amount. This is evidence to show that it may be worth investing. What does coupons.com have? A failing 16 year old business that hasn't once turned a profit? Edit: Just noticed you said COUP aside. I agree with you – the comparisons from tech or unprofitable IPOs don't add up.
- notahacker 13y agoThe real litmus test is whether high-growth companies' revenue-exceeding expenditure has mostly been invested in developing a unique product that should be a cash cow in future (Tesla R&D) or in acquiring customers which tend not to have a reason to stick around (Groupon)
- kolbe 13y agoTSLA, FB, AMZN &etc are still all being >80% valuated on potential. We can quibble about whether COUP deserves to be be given the honor of having that valuation model, but the fact is that the world doesn't have a great standard model for how much a bird in the bush should be worth relative to one in your hand, but the markets seem to be pricing in one-to-one for some of these growth stocks.
- trg2 13y agoWhen a company like this goes public, do they have to include in their filing specifically which channels are driving revenue? For example, do they mention what % of Coupons.com revenue is from SEO vs. SEM vs. Email Marketing vs. Direct traffic - or does Wall Street just understand all that as one big "Internet" channel?
- pkfrank 13y agoMy (relatively weak) understanding is that they'll disclose that information in their S-1. They'll also have to make a bunch of disclosures about risks to their business (IE: "Google changes their algorithms which materially impacts a core part of our business.") edit-- Here is a link to their S-1: http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1115128/000119312514030698/d612699ds1.htm http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1115128/0001193125140...
- AJ007 13y agoHere is a hint: http://www.similarweb.com/website/coupons.com http://www.similarweb.com/website/coupons.com The question is, which one is a bigger stinker, coupons.com or retailmenot? Both make a significant portion of their revenue ranking organically on Google for other big companies' name. What happens when this traffic shrinks or is lost? As an investor I am very concerned when a company publicly publishes that they make tens of millions or hundreds of millions of dollars off of a free stream of traffic from Google. Companies can establish a brand from that position, but its ultimately their financials which determine their long term survival. Zynga offers an alternative example, grew very fast due to a never to be repeated level of free visibility on Facebook's news feeds. Multi-billion dollar mobile gaming companies are in very similar positions today. I'm not saying these companies or websites are worthless, but the valuations are insane for the risk they entail. High valuations make companies spend more and borrow more than they should. Does a company own their user base? That is a pretty good indicator of long term viability. Ironically, Microsoft of the 90s looks like a fairly friendly neighbor in comparison to the "platforms" software businesses are built upon today.
- ssharp 13y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but Retailmenot's business model is drawing in people seeking discount codes and then tags their affiliate codes when the user clicks through to site to actually make a purchase. Coupon.com's business model is to be the online distributor of manufacturer and store coupons. I'd have to think Coupon.com's revenue comes more from manufactures and stores licensing / paying for inclusion on the Coupon.com website than from affiliate marketing. Retailmenot is getting 73% of its total traffic from search and Coupons.com is less than half of that at 35%. I think Coupons.com also has a more engaged audien than Retailmenot and a large network of coupon bloggers promoting the product and participating as affiliates.
- mastermojo 13y ago"But like so many other companies in these golden times, Coupons.com simply told investors to exclude about $13 million of normal everyday expenses and, abracadabra, it claims to be profitable on a nonstandard, cockamamie "adjusted Ebitda" basis. It's all part of the show." My impression is that Groupon made up their own mumbo jumbo financial metrics, but that adjusted EBITDA is a pretty standard financial metric.
- rhizome 13y agoStandard as in, "except for the bad stuff," maybe, but there's no limit to the undefined void of bad stuff.
- 001sky 13y agoadjusted EBITDA is a pretty standard financial metric No... EBITDA is already "adjusted earnings". Adjusted EBITDA is "Adjusted, Adjusted" earnings. Or more correctedly <opportunistically> Adjusted Earnings.
- waps 13y agoEBITDA is already opportunistically adjusted, it's just that people more or less agree which "bad" numbers get excluded. I understand the argument though. EBITDA is somewhat closer to $income - $cost. Whereas actual earnings involve tax, tax loopholes, exchange rates, and loads of other crap.
- Nicholas_C 13y agoThe adjusted EBITDA the author talks about is on page 12 of the S-1 filing[0]. The largest items that take the $11M net loss to positive EBITDA is $7M of depreciation & amortization and $5M of stock based compensation. [0]http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1115128/000119312514066562/d612699ds1a.htm http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1115128/0001193125140...
- hristov 13y agoI agree that COUP is overvalued, but I do not like this superficial stock analysis. A lot more goes into evaluating growth stocks. One has to consider the trajectory the company is going on, how likely it is it will continue on this trajectory, when things will plateau, etc. You can't just say "its not making money therefore it is a sell." Well you can, but you won't be a very good growth investor. You might be one of the many people that refused to buy google at $100 because their P/E was insanely high. Looking at COUP's S1 I can say a couple of nice things about them. They are showing good topline growth. Their gross margins are expanding. Their net margins (while negative) are improving very fast. From 2012 to 2013 they grew their revenues by almost 50% while they actually reduced their operating expenses. But most importantly, their revenue growth is accelerating. If they continue posting higher and higher revenue growth and expanding growth margins, they may start gushing money in a couple of years. As I said they are not for me. I am not sure they can continue high revenue growth for long because they do not seem to have a good lasting competitive advantage. But I can see how someone may be convinced to buy them.
- cheriot 13y agoIf anyone wants to read the filings for themselves: Coupons.com http://www.wellreadinvestor.com/companies/63241 http://www.wellreadinvestor.com/companies/63241 Groupon http://www.wellreadinvestor.com/companies/10946 http://www.wellreadinvestor.com/companies/10946
- semerda 13y agoYou should not compare Coupons.com to Groupon. Different businesses. Groupon sells deals - you have to put money upfront i.e. commit to a discount. Coupons.com prints money in the form of %/$ off discounts. No need to commit any money even after you acquire a coupon from Coupons.com.
- analog31 13y ago>>> The worst thing you could do is have a denominator in your price-to-earnings ratio that's greater than zero, because then your ratio would be positive, assuming your stock hasn't gone to zero yet. I've always wondered why folks don't use earnings-to-price ratio instead, which goes smoothly through zero instead of behaving, well, hyperbolically.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoMy take in bubbleness is people moving to California for the express reason of working in a startup. If you're doing that because you're an entrepreneurial type and you want to learn about the ins and outs of running a company and your not a stranger to hard work, rapidly changing priorities, and the journey is its own reward, great. But if you're doing that because "startups are cool" and "Man, you get in early and suddenly bam! your like a zillionaire even if you're the Janitor, dude, sign me up!" Well you're chasing a bubble not a career :-). The saddest part for me in the late 90's was the influx of business majors who were going to 'show up how its done' as opposed to problem solvers and team builders. That said, I'm feeling like there are more and more people in the bay area at least for the wrong reasons. And I for one, having lived through the first bubble, have been milking it rather than going all in (bought some FB when it got down to $18 and sold it once it crossed $36. bought some Tesla, sold it when it doubled) took the money out and put it in more diversified things (like index funds). Its boring, you don't make the 'big score' but when the music stops, and the music always stops, this time it won't all evaporate. At least that is what I keep telling myself :-)
- hnnewguy 13y ago>The saddest part for me in the late 90's was the influx of business majors who were going to 'show up how its done' as opposed to problem solvers and team builders. Funny, the saddest part for me, both in the late 90s and today, are the "Tech Stars" who are living high on the hog on other people's money, with some pipe dream of getting bought out and no plan to run a real, viable, sustainable business. Their businesses implode, they get "rich" (through money and contacts) and move on to the next project. Laugh all you want at the MBAs, but I can assure you that they, at the very least, understand that the purpose of a business is to create value for customers and generate a return for stakeholders. I think "Silicon Valley" could have used a bit more of that sort of thinking then, as perhaps more so today.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI think that 'ninja/rockstar/ego-driven' technologists are sad in their own way. Somewhat differently than unseasoned MBAs though. There was a joke that was old even when I moved to the Bay Area in the 80's that you knew you were a 'successful' engineer when companies issued a press release that you had joined them, but they had no idea what you were going to do for them. And like most jokes there was a painful truth that for some people it really is all about them. That said, I find it is also easy for me to fall into the trap of looking primarily at the excesses and sillyness and overlooking the cool things that get built. One of my long time friends is working at Intuitive Surgical and they are doing some really innovative and cool stuff that is not at all frivolous.
- BrandonM 13y agoIs it coincidence that their stock ticker is COUP? http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/coup http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/coup
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- stefan_kendall3 13y agoIs this any more insane that $CRM? Quarter after quarter of losses, and the market cap has been all over the place.