3 ms·
"...should schoolchildren be taught the capital of Colombia? " Should bodybuilders lift weights? Should basketball players run on off days? OP never mentions
by edw519 17y ago
"...should schoolchildren be taught the capital of Colombia? "
Should bodybuilders lift weights?
Should basketball players run on off days?
OP never mentions what learning facts really is: exercise.
The purpose of education isn't to know the capital of Columbia. The purpose of education is to learn. Which requires exercise. Just like the body, the mind needs exercise, too.
There are as many ways to exercise the mind as the body, some better than others. Like taking the elevator, using a search engine may get you the answer faster, but not much mental muscle is built.
- DannoHung 17y agoI think the problem comes in the categorization of useful data versus trivial factoids. If you're going to spend time memorizing facts, they should be very useful facts.
- edw519 17y agoAnd who should be the judge of "useful", student or teacher? I've never had to run from a tiger (fortunately). But I'm sure glad I put in the roadwork to be healthy enough to catch a bus or pick up my luggage. If I didn't know any better I would have thought I was wasting my time back then.
- ken 17y agoThe trouble is that I often don't know what a "useful fact" is even after I've learned it. I certainly don't expect to be able to figure that out before I've learned it! A segment I once saw on Reading Rainbow (airdate: 1986) recently changed my life. Trivial factoid for 2 decades, then boom, useful data point. Nobody could have predicted the set of experiences I'd have that would create a context in which this was useful. When my dad was in college, a classmate of his complained that he'd never need something taught in a particular course. The professor's response was "The only way to be sure of that is to take the course!" (If you still think it was worthless on your deathbed, I'll give you a refund...) If you can figure out a priori what's going to be important without knowing it, I'd like to see your stock portfolio. :-)
- sfphotoarts 17y agono, using a search engine saves you from having to remember things, freeing the mind to focus on the actual mental agility of processing the facts, reasoning, finding connections etc. The mind needs exercise, but remembering facts that are trivial isn't helping much. Think of Google as the calculator for knowledge. A calculator saves you from having to find the square root of a number, allowing you to figure out something useful and meaningful from the answer.
- edw519 17y ago"The mind needs exercise, but remembering facts that are trivial isn't helping much" You base this fundamental conclusion upon what data? (I guess you'll google it.)
- sfphotoarts 17y agono, I thought about it. It's not a conclusion, its a supporting comment. Think what gives your brain the most exercise, remembering the 15th decimal place of PI or working out in your head how much extra light enters an aperture when you increase the radius by 20%.
- andreyf 17y agousing a search engine saves you from having to remember things Being able to pagefault into Googling something is very different from knowing it off-hand. You're easily able to relate and see patterns in immediate knowledge, but not in things you'd need to look up.
- barrkel 17y agoI strongly dispute the idea that memorizing facts not useful to oneself is useful "exercise" for memorizing facts that one finds useful. I, for one, did relatively poorly in secondary school not least because I was primarily learning about computing and programming, in my spare time, when I "should" have been doing homework. Most of school time spent "learning facts" was a * * waste of time * *.
- JulianMorrison 17y agoI'd call that a poor excuse. The bodybuilder can name and point to the muscle he's exercising. He doesn't practice by lifting some random heavy object (piano, car, girder) that might not even use the muscle group in question. When I see education justified with that excuse, I'm tempted to say "OK, replace that with a targeted exercise", because I know the reaction would be horror. Exercise is the way you sell the task to skeptical persons. The actual aim is to require them to learn the capital of Colombia. Just because. And that is ridiculous.