6 ms·
BBC News website: responsive design in beta
- gabemart 13y agoDirect link to responsive site: http://m.bbc.co.uk/news http://m.bbc.co.uk/news
- techwizrd 13y agoThat link still loads the normal site for me. Is the beta invite-only? I didn't see anything in the article about a link to the beta.
- stuartmemo 13y agoIf you scroll to the bottom of http://m.bbc.co.uk/news http://m.bbc.co.uk/news and click "mobile site", it forces the new responsive site.
- gabemart 13y agoAh you're right, it was just giving me the mobile site because I already had the cookie I guess
- nagrom 13y agoThat link just seems to detect that I'm on a Macbook and give me the regular desktop site. Are you sure that's not the mobile page for BBC News?
- sthulbourn 13y agoTry: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news?view=beta http://www.bbc.co.uk/news?view=beta
- yread 13y agoI like how the feedback in the comments is unanimously negative. >Please DO NOT spoil the easy to read nature of BBC news page on the PC desktop >please refine the design at desktop resolutions >Seems to me that content starts to disappear or change whenever there's a 'responsive design' revamp. >A huge backwards step for desktop users >Looks like another redesign which will result in reduced service for anyone who uses a desktop
- GenesisMachines 13y agoWell that's an ambitious project for a company that just fired all it's developer departments so it could hire cheaper workers in Salford. For those of you who don't know Salford, it's the music of Joy Devision made solid.
- dblacc 13y agoThey still have developers in London
- sthulbourn 13y agoYes there are. I'm one of them.
- Veus 13y agoWhy let the facts get in the way of a good rant? :)
- alanmackenzie 13y agoAs a London based developer for BBCWW who grew up in Glasgow I can tell you this is definitely a good thing, the BBC is far too London centric.
- mattmanser 13y agoThe redesign has been complete disaster for readability on the desktop. Go look at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/correspondents/robertpeston/ http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/correspondents/robertpeston/ See how little actual information they've managed to fit into the desktop design, you have to scroll miles just to scan the stories. The design itself is rubbish with everything seemingly randomly spaced out. Not impressed at all. I'm actually getting really disillusioned with the mobile first movement, what it seems to actually mean is completely broken desktop experiences. And bootstrap, as much as I love it, is part of the problem moving to mobile first.
- LoonyPandora 13y agoI can see zero difference in the information density between the existing non-responsive design of that page [0], and the beta version of the responsive design [1]. While your point that mobile first design inevitably causes a lack of information density at desktop resolutions has some merit, it does not apply in this case. [0] http://cl.ly/UFuw http://cl.ly/UFuw [1] http://cl.ly/UFzs http://cl.ly/UFzs
- mattmanser 13y agoThey have been using those blogs to test the new layout. If you went there over the last few months you'd be asked to give feedback on the new design.
- hrkristian 13y agoI could not agree more. BBC.co.uk used to be one of my daily check-ins, before the redesign some months back which brought with it that horrible slideshow with unintelligible pictures and a ridiculous lack of text. I can't actually find what I'm looking for anymore, and I never even bothered making an effort to. Awful.
- afandian 13y agoBy my count there's approximately half as much content on the new responsive site. It feels lazily designed.
- callum85 13y agoAre we looking at the same thing? I've got the new site open side-by-side with the last, and the total amount of content looks the same.
- afandian 13y agoI counted the number of items on each page (links to news stories) and came up with 38 vs 75. I make that approx half the amount of 'stuff'. Here's a side by side screenshot of what I see. http://imgur.com/HmiHhe2 http://imgur.com/HmiHhe2 EDIT: I was counting items in the whole page. In that screenshot I count 11 vs 51, which is a greater difference.
- callum85 13y agoAh ok fair enough. There's no less content on many other pages I compared though. And as for the amount of stuff on the homepage, I wouldn't say the old site necessarily had the 'right' amount. I find the new design a bit easier on the eye, easier to scan, and more conducive to delving into specific topic pages that interest me. I don't know though, I might just be subconsciously overcompensating for all the negative comments because I feel they're overly harsh. It's impossible to really know how good a redesign is until you've lived with it for a while.
- Nagyman 13y agoAgreed. Looking at old and new is striking. I much prefer the new as it focuses on the important content. The old looks like a product of organic growth (understandable) that seeks to pack in as much on the homepage as possible (and "Above the Fold"). The homepage isn't the be-all, end-all of a website and should pull you in to other areas for exploration. Calling it "lazily" designed is condescending and disrespectful of those who put their time and effort into this. Thick skins are required for web design/dev, but some professional courtesy is appropriate, I think. The developers themselves are here. How about something more constructive? What would YOU change? (OP, not callum85)
- redact207 13y agoA lot of valid points on the downsides to the design. But from a progressive enhancement perspective it's an interesting approach. The users who benefit from this are the ones with a slow connection and old phone, with the desktop + broadband users paying the penalty. As a desktop user, I don't like progressive enhancement especially as the content I'm trying to read bounces around the page as it gets built. If the goal is to optimise the user experience, I would have thought a nicer way (for the user, not so for the developer) would be to create content bundles for the different responsive modes and get it served up server side based on interrogating the user agent and looking up which support html5 etc.
- danso 13y agoAt the last newspaper I worked at, which admittedly was in a state capital, the vast majority of our readers were during the work hours, at their office desktops. It's never made much sense to me the idea of treating that use case as archaic and ancillary...except that making things "responsive" is seen as a catchphrase of being forward thinking, something newspapers are desperate to jump on having missed the boat for far too long
- sthulbourn 13y agoI'm one of the developers working on this site. For those of you who are on a wanting to see the site mentioned in the page: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news?view=beta http://www.bbc.co.uk/news?view=beta You can ask us about any of the technical points of our site here: http://github.com/bbc-news/feedback http://github.com/bbc-news/feedback
- danso 13y agoThank you for taking questions and I apologize for sounding belligerent, I haven't had my coffee yet :) Can you explain the rationale (besides that it's the default behavior for Bootstrap breakpoints) for making the iPad portrait mode similar to what I imagine the phone version is? Here's what I see on my (Retina) iPad: http://imgur.com/GUoDwOQ http://imgur.com/GUoDwOQ It's not that the Ukraine crisis isn't important, but this is the kind of treatment I would expect if Ukraine and Russia broke out into full fledged war. In fact, what would the BBC front page look like (on the iPad, or not-full-screen desktop) if war broke out? The current catch-all-and-put-it-into-a-uniform-box doesn't leave much room to emphasize anything. Furthermore, if BBC's top story of the day happened to be something like, well, "China sets growth, defence targets" (which is currently the second story)...I can't imagine this doing anything but killing the habit of visiting BBC as an impulse, because after awhile, as a reader, I'm trained to think that the BBC has ONE BIG STORY...and often, that story is boring. But as a developer, I see this as, well, they're just using the default breakpoints in Bootstrap. So is that going to be changed? Or is this really what everyone has signed off on? And if so, what are the contingencies? I mean, that is, what happens if: a) War or something like 9/11 * 10 breaks out? or b) Justin Bieber gets arrested for peeing again (more likely)? What are the mockups for those scenarios, and how do they look different than what I've posted in the above link? edit: And this is what the "Most Read" tab looks like, in every implementation, including stretched browser: http://i.imgur.com/ulgdLm1.png http://i.imgur.com/ulgdLm1.png I'm assuming that will be changed, but speaking for experience, it's non-trivial to reorganize the fundamental content blocks, especially to add them. I think this is where mobile-first is especially troublesome for content-heavy sites...and in many situations, this kind of view (even though it is given extremely high prominence as the second of 2 tabs) will be left as is, either out of neglect or because, eh, at least it's legible. But what a waste of screen real estate.
- lclarkmichalek 13y agoEugh, I _hate_ change
- callum85 13y agoI read the negative comments before looking at the site myself, and was expecting to agree with them. But now I've looked at it, I think it's pretty good. The design could do with a bit more 'refining', but then so could the old one. It's just the old one has the advantage of being something that millions of people have already gotten used to. It's hard to fairly compare your feelings about something you use every day vs something new.
- Grue3 13y agoSeems like there's way less content visible on desktop in beta mode. It's not responsive design, it's just lowering the design to the lowest common denominator.
- callum85 13y agoI'm pretty sure it only seems like it. If you compare the sites side-by-side, it's all still there, it just feels less crowded. Which is a good thing.
- thedrbrian 13y agoYes, finally the sidebar can take up a third of my ten inch iPad screen. Yes.
- nly 13y agoI'm curious how this design is responsive when, on the desktop, it still doesn't utilise my browser windows full width. It feels even more plain and full of whitespace than the current site. The screenshots in this post don't show the vast swaths of whitespace on either side of the page. Is everyone inside the BBC still using a 800x600 CRT?
- stuartmemo 13y agoAn extremely wide site risks becoming unreadable due to long line lengths, so a max-width will be set to prevent this happening.
- nly 13y agoBBC news pages don't tend to have long bodies of text though. Even news reports tend to be concise. There's nothing to stop full articles and analyse from columnists being columnar, but imho the news front page could use space more effectively. It's currently just a big list of headlines, and when I go in to a category that interests me (like Tech or Science) ... i just get another list of headlines. How about two columns at least? I've used Firefox's zoom feature to make it fill the page, and it'd look fine if they did so... you'd just get more on screen. I can't imagine how the vertical use of space is further burdened for US readers who have ads to contend with.
- Kartificial 13y agoA representative of the technical team did a talk at the Mobilism conference. Which was my favourite of all talks that conference. Interesting stuff. Video: http://vimeopro.com/mirabeaunl/mobilism-2013/video/68025331 http://vimeopro.com/mirabeaunl/mobilism-2013/video/68025331 Slides: http://www.slideshare.net/jcleveley/mobilism-2013-a-story-of-how-we-built-responsive-bbc-news http://www.slideshare.net/jcleveley/mobilism-2013-a-story-of...
- edward 13y agoThe business page has a headline: "Energy firms told to hand back £400m". Is character encoding really that difficult? Screenshot: http://imgur.com/Sl2Hf1m http://imgur.com/Sl2Hf1m