5 ms·
Yes yes yes. The mechanics of basic calculus are remarkably simple. After a while it becomes a game of sorts with a pretty simple set of rules. Once you learn
by bane 13y ago
Yes yes yes.
The mechanics of basic calculus are remarkably simple. After a while it becomes a game of sorts with a pretty simple set of rules. Once you learn to "see" parts of the equation as symbol blocks (instead of numbers needing computation), you can move them around freely so long as you follow the rules. Algebra is simply a subset of the rules.
Teaching kids to think symbolically will help them in so many other fields.
I'm pretty convinced that with a little thought, you can teach basic derivation and integration to pretty young kids. Carefully craft the problems to avoid difficult division problems, avoid trig, let them use lookup tables for multiplication and you might be able to get kids under 10 to even do some of this.
Then "vertically integrate" other algebraic and trigonometric concepts into this framework, like adding new pieces to the game.
- sp332 13y agoHm, you're talking about teaching symbolic manipulation using calculus, but for me the real ideas of calculus are integration and derivation. I think those ideas are very valuable, and symbolic manipulation is just one way to solve those problems.
- bane 13y agoCan you provide some examples? To me, the basic mechanics I remember (for simple equations like x^3 d/dx) were almost entirely "solvable" by moving bits of the equation around... 1. move the 3 in front of the x 2. where the 3 was, subtract 1 from it and put that back where the 3 was but if you think of it as symbols you get more like 1. move the exponent symbol in front of the x symbol 2. subtract 1 from that exponent and put it back where the original exponent symbol was For me at least, bridging the gap from the specifics of the first example to the more generalized second approach meant that when I was given something like 3x^(y^4) d/dx my mind was absolutely blown because I didn't know if there was some rule I needed to know if the exponent had an exponent or something. Going from the years of the arithmetic approach to really groking the symbolic manipulation approach was really hard for me, and looking at lots of young kids suffering through algebra it was the same. Learning how to recognize the symbols through the specificity of the numbers was something I don't think I really got at all until calculus and it's because the mechanics of the rules of simple derivatives and integration really force you to recognize the underlying symbols...more than algebra did (which for me just seems like a really complicated arithmetic rather than what's actually a pretty simple symbol manipulation exercise). It's odd, because like most technically minded kids, I was already great working with symbols and breaking things down and building them up. I could build huge structures out of various small assemblies with legos, write simple software, crank out papers for English class that would guarantee an A and so on, but understanding that the teachers no longer wanted me to be a human tabulation device but to be a manipulator was something I never really cottoned on to. I know from spending a little time with nieces and nephews younger then 10 that you can teach basic derivatives in about an hour or two and have them fairly reliably doing simple work like the above in an afternoon if you don't worry them too much about simplification of the result or all the arithmetic. My gut says that if you start adding more rules, like what do you do when you have something like (x^3)/(x^2) and how exponents should be subtracted, and with a little care in the examples you show them of this rule in action, you end up showing them all of algebra, fractions, exponents and later trig, logs, etc. while building up and hanging all of these concepts off of calculus. TBH I don't know enough about early childhood education to know if this should be used instead of basic arithmetic or not, but I bet if you use shapes and colors instead of letters and numbers and start to teach basic rules, you can just slowly introduce numeracy later anyways when their brains are more developed.
- sp332 13y agoWell as a simple example, you can draw a curve on the board, then lay a ruler up against it and estimate the slope of the curve at that point. Now you have the value of the derivative at that point. Or use a car's speedometer to show the rate that your position is changing. This is an easy example for integration as well: given 60 MPH for 5 minutes, how far did we go? I'm having a hard time thinking of general solutions instead of single points, but I remember we did several in class.
- gus_massa 13y agoYou are confusing the "derivation rules" with the "derivation concept". The rules are an easy way to calculate the derivative of a function, for example (f+g)'=f'+g'. They are important, because using the definition is tiresome and error prone. The main idea of derivation is that each function f has an associated function f' that is the slope of the tangent lines. This is new function is useful to describe some properties of the original function. (Approximation by the tangent line, increasing and decreasing intervals, ...) It interesting to use the intuitive idea of derivation to understand some of the rules, for example (f+g)'=f'+g'. Something like: If when x increase 1 unit, f increases approximately 3 units and g increases approximately 2 units, then the sum increases approximately 5 units. If f or g are too curved we need to analyze smaller steps like increasing x in 0.1 units. Now f increases only approximately 0.3 units, but the rate of increment is still approximately 3, ... (It's much easier with a graph and hand waving.) And in an advanced course it's important to transform this intuitive idea into a formal proof. Another interesting example is the discussion of where is the minimum of x^2+16/x. The general form of x^2 is well known (graph) and also the general form of 16/x (graph) and then it's possible to draw x^2+16/x approximately (graph). The minimum is where the rate of increment of x^2 is equal to the rate of decrement of 16/x, so x^2+16/x is "horizontal" in that point. This is an intuitive idea, and is exactly what 0=(f+g)'=f'+g' says. In a class you can do the formal calculation of the derivative of x^2+16/x. Then find the exact value of x. Show it in the graph. (Explain that the graphs are approximations, so it's not strange that the minimum in the graph is slightly bigger. Ask if they have a graphic calculator?) If there is enough time evaluate x^2+16/x in a few points near the minimum to see "experimentally" that it's really the minimum.
- sitkack 13y agoTeaching integration with various shapes and boxes of ping balls is really fun. Then use smaller balls to get a better estimate. Physical, visceral and chaotic with balls bouncing everywhere. Even counting a hundred-ish balls is hard and methods have to be devised (good way to intro number bases). Exercise can also be done in 2d with colored squares or circles. Which is a nice segue into guestimation. Cover the entire curve to be measured with a square, value can't be large that as the square totally covers it, ask them to find the lower bounds. Then get them to make estimates with other things they have around (bananas, shoes, etc), someone will come up with rectangles. Introduce the trapezoidal rule! Then we are off into history with Newton and Leibnitz and that shit is good drama enjoyable by any age. None of what I have presented requires counting past 20 (which really most of us can't do anyway).
- trhway 13y ago>but for me the real ideas of calculus are integration and derivation you mean the ideas of a dual space of a linear space and of tangent bundle to a manifold? :)
- nzp 13y agoWhy not? :) All these things are really simple in their essence. They're abstract but an average 14 year old in modern civilisation already has the cognitive machinery necessary to grasp such abstractions. In fact, I think at that age, when they discover abstraction and formal reasoning and what they can do with it (there's a reason teenagers are so full of all kinds of ideas, they're starting to explore the world in full generality), it would be extremely stimulating food for their minds.
- NAFV_P 13y ago> The mechanics of basic calculus are remarkably simple. Interesting comment, calculus in its modern form took around two hundred years to get a firm logical foundation.
- lutusp 13y ago> Interesting comment, calculus in its modern form took around two hundred years to get a firm logical foundation. That's true, but while it languished in limbo because of some technical misunderstandings, it still produced practical and useful results, and people who used it could accurately say they understood the topic. Calculus was eventually analyzed in depth and the various issues and objections were addressed, but these changes had little effect on those who applied it to technical problems.
- donatj 13y agoWhen I started Calculus in high school everything made so much more sense! Trigonometry was just memorizing equations, not having any real idea why the equations were what they were. With Calculus on the other hand, I could come up with the equations I used in prior classes. I instantly wondered why they didn't start with this?! Trig/Pre Calc was just a waste of my time.
- NAFV_P 13y ago> Trigonometry was just memorizing equations, not having any real idea why the equations were what they were. The old proofs of those equations are geometric, they are a bit harder to get your head around than learning complex algebra. Taking Euler's identity: e^(ix)=cos(x)+i*sin(x) > e^(ikx)=cos(kx)+i*sin(kx)=(cos(x)+i*sin(x))^k Expand the right side of the equation, then split into real and imaginary parts. That is a quick way to determine sin(kx) or cos(kx) if sin(x) or cos(x) are already known and k is a positive integer. EDIT: bloomin' asterisks.
- malisper 13y agoMy favorite is a way to prove the sum of angles formula for sine and cosine. cos(x1+x2) + isin(x1+x2) = e^((x1+x2)i) = e^(i*x1) * e^(i*x2) = (cos(x1) + isin(x1)) * (cos(x2) + isin(x2)) = cos(x1)cos(x2) - sin(x1)sin(x2) + i*(sin(x1)cos(x2) + sin(x2)cos(x1)) Since the imaginary parts have to be equal and the real parts have to be equal: sin(x1+x2) = sin(x1)cos(x2) + sin(x2)cos(x1) cos(x1+x2) = cos(x1)cos(x2) - sin(x1)sin(x2)
- NAFV_P 13y agoYeah, that's a more generic form of what I said. ok, hold on... e^(i*x)= cos(x)+i*sin(x) e^(-i*x)= cos(-x)+i*sin(-x)= cos(x)-i*sin(x) cos(x)= (1/2) * (e^(i*x)+e^(-i*x)) sin(x)= (-i/2) * (e^(i*x)-e^(-i*x)) cos(i*x)= (1/2) * (e^(i*i*x)+e^(-i*i*x))=(1/2) * (e^x+e^(-x)) sin(i*x)= (-i/2) * (e^(x)-e^(-x)) That's the amusing part.