4 ms·
The problem is that if you don't fill the period with busywork? The students don't build up the intuitive, gut-level skills they need to handle the higher-leve
by Pxtl 13y ago
The problem is that if you don't fill the period with busywork? The students don't build up the intuitive, gut-level skills they need to handle the higher-level stuff.
Math requires building muscles in your head, and muscles take reps. Lots of reps. Let's look at the elementary level: it's not enough to simply introduce BEDMAS or least-common-denominator and write a few problems that get the student to check off "okay, I know that" from the list of stuff they know.
The student has to be so practiced at these concepts that they could do it while trying to juggle 9 other extremely complicated brand-new concepts in their head because that's what you need to do when you build calculus upon factoring upon algebra upon fractions upon arithmetic.
If you fail to do this, you get kids walking into grade 9 math class who've forgotten everything they were supposed to know about fractions and teachers have too much new material to cover to re-teach fractions (my wife is a math teacher. This happens way, way too much - too many students enter her class missing necessary prerequisite skills). Students struggling with applying the basics cannot properly grasp the new material - so the basics have to be rock solid.
- 6d0debc071 13y agoTo a certain extent that's a product of a bad curriculum though. If you teach something, tick it off, teach something else, tick that off. And build a large number of things ticked off in that manner - that don't reuse the things taught earlier - then of course you're not going to get the reps in. As compared to, say, the syntax in a programming language. Where you don't write out hello world sixty times to get the bracket rules, you just reuse the rules in other things you're doing often enough that they become ingrained.
- katbyte 13y agopersonally, busy work just never sticks for me, i don't remember almost any of the math i did in HS and uni that was just "do these problems over and over till you remember it" because it just wasn't all that interesting, and this goes for any subject. However some concepts, limits, derivatives and integrals i remember perfectly well (5+ years later) because my math teacher explained how the all fit together, what they represented wrt the real world and how they can be useful and that actually got me interested. Yea you need to know the basics, but i daresay busy work isn't the best way to teach them.
- Pxtl 13y agoIt's the difference between skills and knowledge. Limits/derivatives/integrals are interesting knowledge so you can discuss them verbally, even if you don't have extensive practice in using them. The basic, core stuff is the opposite. Fractions, bedmas, etc. you don't care enough to talk about, but if I handed a problem that used those concepts you could do it in your head, because they're skills that have been developed down to an instinctive level. Common factoring is dull. There's nothing to say about common factoring. But if I show you an equation where you can apply it, you'll spot it instinctively because you've had common factoring ground into your reptilian brain.
- minikomi 13y agoDull work can be made fun with a little effort. One of my high school teachers had us form lines, we refactor on the fly, said the factors of a quadratic out loud, and then were able to shoot the opponent (like a duel).. After a few shootouts everyone got very quick at refactoring. That little fun boost made the grind feel meaningful.
- j2kun 13y agoThere is quite a lot to say about 'common factoring.' For example, nobody knows whether there is an efficient algorithm to factor integers (where efficient depends on the number of digits in the integer). However, there is an efficient algorithm to factor polynomials, and you can write all irreducible polynomials of a certain degree as factors of one mother polynomial. Moreover, being able to factor integers efficiently would allow you to break a lot of encryption schemes.
- sitkack 13y agoSo many incorrect words, tired analogies and pithy statements.
- j2kun 13y agoThe problem with your comment is that busywork is not (and never has been) mathematical weight lifting. You don't gain thinking skills by memorizing multiplication tables or practicing adding fractions, you gain it by solving problems you don't know how to solve. Of course it's not enough to state something, but making the students reiterate what you've stated a hundred times is only marginally better. Another problem is that no student really learns ANYTHING until they need to use it to do something else. No student learns fractions until they need to use it to do algebra, and they don't learn algebra until they need it to do calculus. And they don't learn calculus until they need it to do engineering/physics or higher mathematics (real analysis, which they don't really learn until they do measure theory...).