7 ms·
I was a terrible math student in school. Looking back, it wasn't because the material was hard, or boring, but because it was completely unmotivated. They may
by bane 13y ago
I was a terrible math student in school.
Looking back, it wasn't because the material was hard, or boring, but because it was completely unmotivated. They may as well have been asking me to organize piles of toothpicks or count ceiling tiles to fill up the class periods. There was simply no sense to it.
I think this is partially understood, and the attempted solution is to try to find applications for the math you're learning. Except that once you hit even basic algebra, you quickly run out of applications a young student can relate to. So they go home, ask their parents "what do you use Algebra for?" and get "I don't." and that's that.
I think, along with application concepts, the history of these maths...why were they created, about the creators who came up with the concepts, what were they trying to solve, let's solve the same problems with these new techniques, etc. This would have grabbed me and pulled me in. Instead you sometimes get a little box in the reading quickly going over all this (if you are lucky) before a hundred problems are dumped on you to drill through. It's rarely talked about in class, and if it is, it's by a teacher who doesn't know or appreciate the value of this history at all.
By doing this you show applicability to entire fields, even if the child doesn't understand what's involved in the field. Those kids that say "when I grow up I want to be a biologist" will encounter stories about people who learned to apply logic or math or fractions or whatever to solve difficult problems in biology or whatever, and then relive those moments as they try to solve the same or similar problem using the tools they were just given.
- wisty 13y ago> Except that once you hit even basic algebra, you quickly run out of applications a young student can relate to. Algebra is problem solving. You have a formula describing the problem, and want to re-arrange it to find one of the variables. It has a lot of useful and logical applications. Trigonometry though ... screw that. "Bob the builder has made a truss, and wants to figure out the angle A. He doesn't own a protractor, and can only measure a few of the lengths." Seriously?
- bane 13y ago> Algebra is problem solving. You have a formula describing the problem, and want to re-arrange it to find one of the variables. It has a lot of useful and logical applications. It does, but for average Joe and Carla, who's day job involves making sure the box of sprockets sitting on the loading dock matches the P.O., and who's most pressing math problem is balancing their check book every few days and using turbo tax once a year, they'll never encounter anything more complicated than very basic arithmetic. I think the hardest math problem most people encounter is figuring out percentages so they can fill out the "tip" on the credit card receipt when they eat out. Yeah it's "algebra" but it's a very limited class of problem and people just use a calculator or a tip calculator to do it these days. >Trig Yeah, trig really requires good motivation. The answer to most trig questions really is "buy the appropriate measuring tool" not "do a bunch of calculations and look up the result of the trig functions in a table". I don't ever remember having the calculations for cos(), sin() explained to me, they're just magic functions, number goes in, number comes out.
- kens 13y agoWhat motivated trig functions for me was writing 5 line BASIC programs as a kid to draw circles, spirals, etc. Realizing that COS was the X coordinate and SIN was the Y coordinate made it all clear. Unfortunately there's no easy, low-friction way for kids today to do that with their PC.
- trothoun 13y agoFortunately, TI continues to provide this to many students.
- dhruvmittal 13y agoI had the same experience, but with a TI-83.
- Pxtl 13y agoI feel like the educational and software worlds have failed to work together to provide a modern, powerful, 21st century answer to the TI-83. Being able to animate and play with your math helps a lot. GeoGebra is a good example, but it's not the holy grail.
- jwmerrill 13y agoYou might also enjoy https://www.desmos.com https://www.desmos.com
- sitkack 13y agoWith that kind of attitude we are just going to make more average Joe and Carlas. If you take what you are saying to a logical conclusion it leads to the exclusion of the many in fear of over education which I would argue can never occur.
- Patrick_Devine 13y agoThere's a really, really simple way to get kids to love trig. Get them to write a video game. Seriously, as a video game programmer, you use trig _every day_. If you want to find the distance between two points when you have the angle (eg. I'm firing a projectile at a certain angle), use cosine for the length of the x axis and use sine for the y axis. You get the hypotenuse from using pythagoras' theorem. If you want to find the angle between two points, use arc tangents. Once kids have mastered all of that, you can teach them law of cosines and get into linear algebra; simple rotational matrices which can let you do collision detection and a whole bunch of other really, really cool stuff. So yeah, Bob the builder might be boring as shit as a word problem, but Bob the builder might be a pretty cool video game. Without trig, as a game, Bob the builder is probably going to be boring as shit too.
- dllthomas 13y ago"If you want to find the distance between two points when you have the angle (eg. I'm firing a projectile at a certain angle), use cosine for the length of the x axis and use sine for the y axis. You get the hypotenuse from using pythagoras' theorem." Using cosine and sine and then Pythagorean theorem to get the length of the hypotenuse doesn't make sense - in order to get the length of the X and Y components with cosine and sine you need to already know the length of the hypotenuse.
- Patrick_Devine 13y agoYou're right, I did state it a little awkwardly, but the statements are correct. I'll give a more concrete example: I'm firing a projectile at 52 degrees and it needs to move 10 units. I'm at (5,7), where does the projectile end up? delta x = cos(theta) * 10 delta y = sin(theta) * 10 So my final position is (5 + 6.16, 7 + 7.88), or (11, 15). If I already knew how far the delta X and delta Y were, I could get the length of the hypotenuse with sqrt(6.16^2 + 7.88^2). That equals roughly 10, of course. If you want to try this out yourself, just remember that most trig functions are done in radians, so convert theta to radians with pi * theta (degrees) / 180.
- 13y ago
- theandrewbailey 13y ago> Trigonometry though ... screw that. "Bob the builder has made a truss, and wants to figure out the angle A. He doesn't own a protractor, and can only measure a few of the lengths." Seriously? You can also throw in some economics: Bob would be fired and/or get better equipment.
- Pxtl 13y agoThe problem is that if you don't fill the period with busywork? The students don't build up the intuitive, gut-level skills they need to handle the higher-level stuff. Math requires building muscles in your head, and muscles take reps. Lots of reps. Let's look at the elementary level: it's not enough to simply introduce BEDMAS or least-common-denominator and write a few problems that get the student to check off "okay, I know that" from the list of stuff they know. The student has to be so practiced at these concepts that they could do it while trying to juggle 9 other extremely complicated brand-new concepts in their head because that's what you need to do when you build calculus upon factoring upon algebra upon fractions upon arithmetic. If you fail to do this, you get kids walking into grade 9 math class who've forgotten everything they were supposed to know about fractions and teachers have too much new material to cover to re-teach fractions (my wife is a math teacher. This happens way, way too much - too many students enter her class missing necessary prerequisite skills). Students struggling with applying the basics cannot properly grasp the new material - so the basics have to be rock solid.
- 6d0debc071 13y agoTo a certain extent that's a product of a bad curriculum though. If you teach something, tick it off, teach something else, tick that off. And build a large number of things ticked off in that manner - that don't reuse the things taught earlier - then of course you're not going to get the reps in. As compared to, say, the syntax in a programming language. Where you don't write out hello world sixty times to get the bracket rules, you just reuse the rules in other things you're doing often enough that they become ingrained.
- katbyte 13y agopersonally, busy work just never sticks for me, i don't remember almost any of the math i did in HS and uni that was just "do these problems over and over till you remember it" because it just wasn't all that interesting, and this goes for any subject. However some concepts, limits, derivatives and integrals i remember perfectly well (5+ years later) because my math teacher explained how the all fit together, what they represented wrt the real world and how they can be useful and that actually got me interested. Yea you need to know the basics, but i daresay busy work isn't the best way to teach them.
- SamuelMulder 13y agoI think you're absolutely right that math has to be motivated. A lot of the effort to motivate it is to provide problems that students understand relate to the real world. Most of them come across as contrived. You hit on a good concept with the idea of incorporating the history of math. I'm working on a Geometry curriculum that does just that. Understanding math in the context of a grand story of mankind trying to understand the world around us is a lot more interesting than as a set of received wisdom that must be memorized. I would love to see more math material along these lines, but there isn't much out there, and it takes a long time to produce. I've been working on mine for around 6 months and am just up through looking at how the discovery of incommensurable lengths influenced Plato's philosophy. The idea is to work through the history and philosophy in parallel with Euclid's Elements, relating points back and forth where possible. I've tried teaching a history of math class to local homeschool kids along those lines, focusing on Egyptian - Greek history, with some success. It takes a lot of research and work though.
- bane 13y ago> It takes a lot of research and work though. Yeah, absolutely. In fact, I'd say that it's just as important that students receive confirmation of this history and motivation in their other subjects. For example, in various history classes, we learn about kings and wars and important philosophers. But we rarely learn about mathematicians and why their contributions were important, of if they were polymaths, we discuss their non-mathematical contributions, but omit their mathematical ones entirely. Then in writing and literature we spend endless hours on appreciating tiny non-relevant symbols, but don't read something like Ringworld and spend part of a session calculating and relating the size of it. Conversely, in Math class, writing a paper on the history and influence of Platonic solids or similar would have been an interesting break and let kids struggling with crunching numbers take an interest and shine a little. Or imagine a math course that analyzes things like agricultural output from Roman times to modernity, involving geometry, arithmetic, algebra, percentages (taxes to the king!), nutrition, etc. Extend out to how greater agricultural output per unit land produces surpluses that enable people to take up other labors like politics or art or music. Off the cuff examples that would need more careful thought, but hopefully the idea is sound. Bringing math into other non-math subjects, and bringing arts into non-art subjects I think helps prop up what students see as isolated subject "silos" that have nothing to do with anything. Literature and history courses mutually reinforce each other, and math and science course mutually reinforce each other, but there's a tremendous gap between these two groups of courses where they don't reinforce each other. This really needs to end because it all is connected and builds relevance for students.
- eliteraspberrie 13y agoThe irony is that all mathematics up to the high school level was historically motivated by practical problems. Algebra began as a system of rules to fairly partition land, for irrigation or inheritance, for example. But most of the high school math teachers are not actually mathematicians, so they themselves have no clue what algebra and calculus are used for. There ought to be incentives for professionals of all fields to go into teaching.