6 ms·
Inventor stumped by 43-year patent delay
- sehugg 13y agoHyatt's microprocessor patent was invalidated in 1996, but not before he extracted $70 million or so in royalties from Japanese and European companies. More context: http://www.nytimes.com/1996/06/20/business/for-texas-instruments-some-bragging-rights.html http://www.nytimes.com/1996/06/20/business/for-texas-instrum... http://www.allgov.com/news/controversies/who-invented-the-microprocessorhyatt-v-patent-office?news=844054 http://www.allgov.com/news/controversies/who-invented-the-mi...
- thinkcomp 13y agoGilbert P. Hyatt's patent applications, assignments and lawsuits can be found here: http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/index.html?id=1391559 http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/index.html?id=1391559
- jdreaver 13y agoI've become extremely jaded against intellectual property recently. Far too often, IP law is used to for long, drawn out legal battles that do nothing to help society, while costing the tax payers a ton of money. Property is a way to deal with scarcity. Two people cannot simultaneously wear a shirt, for example, so one of them "owns" the shirt. Two people cannot both drive a car to different locations at the same time, so one person "owns" the car. Of course, you can lend your shirt or car to someone else, but the final say as to how those two resources are used belongs to the owner. The product of intellectual labor, using this scarcity condition, cannot be considered someone's property. The only tangential relationship IP has to property is that one person uses force, namely, the government, to prevent others from using "their" idea for economic gain. This scarcity is artificial because absent that threat of force, everyone would be able to use the idea freely. Physical goods are subject to scarcity as a consequence of physical law; a car acn't be in my driveway and your driveway at the same time. (This argument applies directly to patents and copyrights, but also to trademarks in that a word or phrase can't be used to market something for economic gain.) Besides the moral argument, which I know some people don't care about (it is subjective, of course), there is a utilitarian argument. Some act as if, without IP law, no one would be willing to create new ideas; it's as if the only incentive for creation is economic gain from a government-granted monopoly on an idea. Just take a look at the news to see that IP law is more commonly associated with patent trolls and corporate legal battles than protecting Joe Inventor's new idea. At the very least, I wish people would stop comparing downloading movies and music from the internet as stealing. If I steal your car, you can't use it. If I "steal" a song from the record label by copying the exact sequence of bytes that represent a song from my buddy's hard drive to my hard drive, we can both still listen to the song. I understand that some people support the song creator's claim to the song as "property," in the form of IP. However, even then, there has to be a middle ground between copying against the wishes of the song's creator, and theft in the eyes of the law.
- biehl 13y ago"You wouldn't [download] a car..." Why, yes - yes I most definitely would.
- jessaustin 13y agoHas GP post changed? I don't find that statement within it.
- mattkevan 13y agoYou wouldn't steal a policeman's helmet... http://youtu.be/ALZZx1xmAzg http://youtu.be/ALZZx1xmAzg
- dredmorbius 13y agoGood news: you can. http://opensourceecology.org/wiki/Global_Village_Construction_Set http://opensourceecology.org/wiki/Global_Village_Constructio... http://opensourceecology.org/wiki/Open_Source_Car http://opensourceecology.org/wiki/Open_Source_Car
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sillysaurus3 13y agoAt the very least, I wish people would stop comparing downloading movies and music from the internet as stealing. Games released via Steam have shown evidence that when a singleplayer game is unavailable as a torrent for free, then people will pay for it. The counterargument to this is that most people who torrent wouldn't pay for it anyway. But I assert that there is a third class of people: those who first check to see if it's available for free, and if not, pay for it. Whether these people constitute a significant portion of revenue is an open question, but it's hard to classify their actions from a moral standpoint as something other than stealing. The closest classification other than "stealing" would probably be "sampling." I've often been frustrated at an inability to try out a certain kind of dev tool before buying it outright, and their free version is usually missing features which I really need to test. But there needs to be a large-scale study as to whether people really behave this way normally, or if they just take what they can get for free. Unfortunately it's difficult to find an unbiased source of funding for such a study, so the resulting research paper would probably be slanted in one moral direction or the other instead of presenting the raw data. It's not an easy question to answer. I think technological capabilities will decide how companies will behave, because those who don't accept reality will go out of business.
- semisight 13y agoMy grandfather helped Hyatt to write his patent. Interesting to finally see any press about him.
- wglb 13y agoCool. Was he a patent attorney?
- EGreg 13y agoCopyright protects work that people did from being copied. It is fairly narrow. Patents protect "ideas". It is much more likely that someone may come up with the same or similar idea completely independently, than someone would come with up the same exact computer program or book. Patent protection is very broad. Especially in the US due to the Doctrine of Equivalents. Soo... I am for copyright protection and not patent.
- loceng 13y ago'"I respect Gilbert Hyatt's work — the process of engineering is difficult," Bassett said in a telephone interview. "But innovations are more than ideas. The broader context matters. If Gilbert Hyatt had never existed, I believe the microprocessor would have developed in the same way that it did."' This pretty much goes for every innovation..
- Perseids 13y agoTrue. But the stronger argument is that they would also happen at roughly the same time, as hinted by the fact that many ground breaking innovations were found independently by different scientists once the necessary prerequisites were discovered. This dependence on the scientific society as whole is often conveniently ignored by those arguing for strong IP[1] protection. And even worse is that many patents actually severely hinder the spread of the concerned innovation. As an example in cryptography see the Offset Codebook Mode for authenticated encryption. Even though the authors have now granted free use for open source software it has remained an extreme niche solution. Or see NTRUEncrypt, probably one of the best shots for post-quantum public key cryptography. [1] I don't like term intellectual property, because in it lies the quiet acceptance of the idea in general, that thoughts and knowledge can be owned. Calling it IM - intellectual monopoly - is more to the point. We should not forget that a huge part of the fight for the public opinion is won or lost by the concepts our language provide us with and limit us to.
- loceng 13y agoAgreed. And updating the terminology would be good. I have a blog post draft written up relating to perhaps using the word "times" and "monies" instead of merely time and money - as the brain is likely to see "time" and "money" as a singular, fixed object, which will not allow the brain to be as fluid when thinking about times and monies - more fixed, means more scarce - more fluid, means variability and more possibility, less pressure.
- marincounty 13y agoThe biggest problem I have with the U.S Patent system is cost. They should price the fee for issuing a patient on yearly income. This would level out the playing field. It just might prevent some entities trying to patient rounded edges? And it would allow the poor investor a fighting chance of protecting their idea. The Internet has changed Everything. Brilliant ideas will be lost because of lack of funds.
- dhoulb 13y agoNo, sorry, this is a terrible idea, Every broke idiot with a pen would write up every idea under the sun. Companies, with resources to actually bring those ideas to life, would have to pay way more to be able to do so, driving up the cost of innovation in markets. Also, presumably, a company would just pay a broke guy to submit the patent on their behalf, and pay them a small fee. Leading to a horrific industry of 'broke guy recruiters'. Lone inventors are actually the primary group harming innovation here, not large companies (contrary to what your politics and gut might wish for). They patent some broad thing they have no intention of making, and sell those 'inventions' on for a quick buck to holding companies who make their money from suing people. Patents need to not exist any more. For all the noise companies make about patents being important, if you took them away tomorrow, the world would be exactly the same. Nothing would change.