8 ms·
A Major Coinbase Milestone: 1 Million Consumer Wallets
- joezydeco 13y agoI realize it's all startup-y to pat yourself on the back about growth, but aren't you painting a target on your back for those that want to perform the next heist?
- dangrossman 13y agoPretending they're tiny and poor isn't a long-term strategy for becoming a mainstream, trusted brand in e-commerce. Security is one front they need to win on, just like every other successful payment processing business; they can't hide and become big at the same time.
- ceejayoz 13y agoI'm pretty sure anyone interested in heisting Bitcoin had Coinbase on their radar already.
- joezydeco 13y agoTrue. So let's go with the hubris angle, then. Like others have said below, we trusted that Gox was secure as well.
- ceejayoz 13y agoAny prominent Bitcoin site is going to be the subject of continuous attacks at this point. If Coinbase has vulnerabilities like Gox did, chances are they'll get found.
- BlackDeath3 13y agoIf you're avoiding press for security reasons, you may be doing it wrong.
- singularityyy 13y agoNo security is perfect of course, but Coinbase has over 98% of the funds in cold-storage. See: http://antonopoulos.com/2014/02/25/coinbase-review/ http://antonopoulos.com/2014/02/25/coinbase-review/
- waterlesscloud 13y agoGox claimed 95% of their coins were in cold storage. Unproven claims aren't worth much.
- jonknee 13y agoTechnically that still appears accurate. The inaccurate portion was that they didn't have anywhere near the correct number of coins (cold or hot).
- grey-area 13y agoThat's what mtgox said too, I believe their figure was 98%: On average 98% of customer bitcoins are held in cold storage...Offline wallets are generated from an offline system and kept in paper format in three separate locations, using a technology based on raid. https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=23938.40 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=23938.40 http://www.managementtoday.co.uk/bulletin/mtdailybulletin/article/1282210/this-end-bitcoin-mtgox-goes-offline/ http://www.managementtoday.co.uk/bulletin/mtdailybulletin/ar... But of course, they weren't really in cold storage or offline after all, because somehow they all disappeared... Not that I mistrust coinbase specifically, but without insurance, audits and regulation (i.e. without a banking license), I'm not sure I'd trust anyone to store significant amounts of money.
- patmcc 13y agoBanks that hold large amounts of cash either insure it against fire/flood/theft or self-insure with other assets - what is Coinbase's plan if these cold-storage coins are destroyed, either by malicious attempt or disaster? That link shows the coins are locked away, are apparently not accessible, but how safe are they against actual loss?
- TacticalCoder 13y agoAs I understand it if security is done correctly then "stealing bitcoins" amounts to breaking strong cryptography. At this point nothing indicates that the elliptic curves or the cryptographic hashes (SHA-256, RIPEMD-160) used in Bitcoin are at risk. Under the assumption that the crypto used in Bitcoin is safe, there's, for example, nothing an attacker can do to spend the coins in offline wallets. Not even a 50%+1 attack that'd be sustained for days... If anything, the recent fiasco with Gox (which is more than shaddy) gives me lots and lots of confidence in Coinbase to do "the right thing". Now I'm not saying they'll never get pirated or anything like that. But Bitcoin implemented correctly seems to be very safe and there are many people out there who have bitcoins which are "sleeping" safely on offline wallets in deep cold storage. Most people holding bitcoins and most companies like Coinbase only need a fraction of their bitcoins "online" to be able to operate. And even for those bitcoins I take it Coinbase is taking security very seriously.
- MichaelGG 13y agoYeah, we'd hope they have some serious M-of-N key system in place to safeguard access to the wallets. The biggest thing that gives me pause about Coinbase is their decision to use MongoDB. There may be a reason, but I certainly can't find one. Their use case is perfect for proper, old-fashioned, reliable RDBMS. They've also had a fair amount of customer service issues, including "we rebooted and our job queues didn't run anymore" problem where they tried to rip that guy off. Even so, the security of the offline wallet is so important, you'd think their investors will have insisted on some auditing and third party implementation. Maybe some of the big wallets are even partially held by outside people.
- thinkcomp 13y agoThat's one million consumer accounts with no FDIC insurance, no surety bonds, and no other backstop in the event of a problem. I'd love to see a Coinbase blog post about why Coinbase doesn't need to be licensed like every other MSB registered with FinCEN.
- mulligan 13y agoyeah, but just think of how much they save on transaction costs when they buy something online [without the ability to chargeback]!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- thinkcomp 13y agoFinancial accounts. One person can have many bank accounts. I would guess they're using the word "wallet" to avoid regulatory scrutiny that might be applied to financial accounts. People might feel like "wallets" can get lost or stolen. "Accounts" shouldn't. These are accounts.
- JoshTriplett 13y ago> People might feel like "wallets" can get lost or stolen. "Accounts" shouldn't. That's exactly why the term "wallet" should be used. This is cash, and should be treated accordingly and thought of accordingly. Terms like "wallet" help people develop a reasonable mental model that fits reality.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> That's exactly why the term "wallet" should be used. This is cash, and should be treated accordingly and thought of accordingly. Cash held by someone else on your behalf is an account (even if it is physically stored in their wallet). So, sure, bitcoins are in a sense analogous to physical cash, and bitcoin wallets are in a sense analogous to physical wallets full of cash -- but some third party business who keeps bitcoins in their own wallets and contracts with you to transmit them according to your instruction is providing you with an account, not a wallet.
- sillysaurus3 13y agoQuick question: What's preventing Coinbase from shutting down operations tomorrow and walking away with everyone's money, as MtGox walked away with mine? Or, what if the founders orchestrated some sort of disaster wherein all of the coins are claimed to be lost, but in reality they're simply transferred to the founders? I know they wouldn't actually do that. My question is, what's stopping them? Why wouldn't someone try to do that, other than their morals?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- thinkcomp 13y agoActually, no. PayPal is licensed and bonded in 47+ states. Coinbase is licensed in 0. I don't think it's the best regulatory framework, but it's all we've got.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- thinkcomp 13y agoYou're right, the surety bond system is fundamentally flawed. But it's $9 million more in security (in California, since different states have different bond requirements) than Coinbase has. I've advocated for an FDIC-like system for money transmitters, run by CFPB or some other entity, for three years. Congress is hard to reach these days. http://www.thinkcomputer.com/corporate/whitepapers/heldhostage.pdf http://www.thinkcomputer.com/corporate/whitepapers/heldhosta... http://www.thinkcomputer.com/20140214.cfpbcomment.pdf http://www.thinkcomputer.com/20140214.cfpbcomment.pdf
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- thinkcomp 13y agoNothing. And good luck finding their worldwide "cold storage" locations. They're apparently not in the United States, and not required to disclose them to any regulator.
- singularityyy 13y agoConsidering any positive comment will be buried deep under in HN, I think it's important to celebrate this success. Price of Bitcoin is meaningless, all other metrics seem to point to higher and higher adoption of this new technology. Great news!
- cassetti 13y agoThe main reason I chose to buy BTC through Coinbase is because they're funded by A16Z and USV. Very prominent and influential investors that would also come under scrutiny if anything nefarious happened internally.
- panabee 13y agohow are they able to guarantee an exchange rate? aren't they exposing themselves to the huge fluctuations in bitcoin price (though the price seems to have stabilized recently)? for instance, there were some days this month where the price fluctuated by more than 40%. somehow the price and volume must work out where this is a calculated risk to cultivate the broader bitcoin ecosystem. would love to see some numbers if anyone has any ...
- erikpukinskis 13y agoI suspect they don't need to expose themselves because they are holding large amounts of both Bitcoins and cash, so they can simply sell them to people at whatever price they want to. It's not like they take your USD and then have to run out and buy Bitcoins to cover them. They do have to worry about the value of their Bitcoin and USD holdings becoming worthless, but that's something all Bitcoin and USD investors have to worry about. If they are taking some risk, by making commitments that they don't have backed with currency, it's trivially easy to calculate their exposure and figure out how high their fees need to be to cover it. That's a problem actuaries solved decades ago. Currency exchange is not a new business.
- wmf 13y agoThey don't guarantee anything; if they don't feel like processing your trade they'll just cancel it.
- Istof 13y agoI have a few empty (never used) wallets