7 ms·
Will it take every single voting age person in America having a first-hand experience like this to change health care? How can any sane person prefer this over
by grecy 13y ago
Will it take every single voting age person in America having a first-hand experience like this to change health care?
How can any sane person prefer this over the alternative offered by Developed countries?
- atmosx 13y agoNo not even that I think. People in the USA perceives any kind of added tax, as money stolen from the state. Most of them do not have the notion of public regarded as something positive. Let's say it's a very different perception of property, compared to Europe. I am trying to convince myself that it's not wrong it's just different. I try to accept the fact that I don't understand their approach and get over with, otherwise turns me kinda crazy.
- sp332 13y agoThe government is in bed with the industry. I don't trust the government with increased power over health care, because they will just screw everyone even more and give money to corporations. I have 0 confidence in the federal government to represent my interests, and that's the only reason I don't want them to have more control over my healthcare costs.
- fennecfoxen 13y ago> People in the USA perceives any kind of added tax, as money stolen from the state. Hmm? The typical perception (among those who actually share the perception, which is not all Americans) reads more like: additional taxes are money stolen from the people and transferred to the state, whereupon significant chunks of it are wasted by a soulless bureaucracy (and sometimes select corporate sycophants) before the bureaucracy gives the People back a lot of substandard services. Of course, enough US citizens were willing to vote for certain Congresspeople and presidents that a significant law was recently passed, with the ostensible goal of reforming health care. You may have heard about it as "the Affordable Care Act" or, colloquially, "Obamacare". So be careful with generalizations about American attitudes. Perhaps study of this law's actual effects will ultimately be able to demonstrate the accuracy or inaccuracy of this perception? Disclaimer. This post attempts to describe attitudes only, without endorsing or condemning them.
- wmt 13y agoThere's no need to raise taxes, just provide universal healthcare. US is already spending as much per capita on public healthcare to European countries![1] This means that instead of tax hikes you would need to use the existing budget for public healthcare to provide free public healthcare to everyone, just like all other countries who provide a "free" public healthcare paid with taxes. [1] http://www.marketwatch.com/story/10-countries-that-spend-the-most-on-health-care-2013-07-30 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/10-countries-that-spend-the...
- danielweber 13y agoHow did they arrive at $4000 per capita on health expenditures? Times 300 million people, that's $1.2 Trillion. DHHS including Medicare and Medicaid was $940 Billion in 2013. Anyway, I'd love to see a system that reallocated the money that the government is spending right now only on certain groups and used it to provide the best boost to public health it could for all Americans. But you would be running right into the AARP lobby who would frame this as taking care away from seniors. That's a fierce lobby, and you'd need some sort of plan.
- ahomescu1 13y agoI'm European, and I perfectly understand this approach. Increased taxes can go to increased services (and they do, in some countries), or they can go into the pockets of corrupt government officials (which they do, in many other countries). It's insane to pay higher taxes, and see no benefit in return. I often wish my own country had much lower taxes, to "starve the beast", in a way.
- pg_is_a_butt 13y agohow can a sane person accept death?
- danielweber 13y agoYou say "the alternative" as if every other country on Earth has one system, and the US has a second system, and that first system is what we should have. Whereas all those other countries have a bunch of different systems (compare Canada to the UK to France to Singapore). And each of those systems has real tradeoffs for real people. (To be clear: I'd be fine with many, even most, of those tradeoffs, but people who aren't can't be convinced to my side just by insulting them.)
- grecy 13y agoAll developed countries (excluding the US) share similarities, that when painting with a broad brush, can be called the same. Namely: People pay taxes that pay for healthcare for every single citizen. No person is without care. (end of comparison). (You can tell people it's exactly the same as how they pay for Elementary and High School, how they pay for police and firemen, etc. etc.) EDIT: Implied in my broad statement is No person pays out of pocket for care, other than the original taxes.
- btown 13y agoYou should note, however, that in OP's case his mother does have some amount of health insurance; her case would very much fall under "no person is without care." It's the fine print of how much care is given in which the problem lies, and there is a fundamental tradeoff here that all countries implement slightly differently. Is the U.S. at the Pareto optimum, if such an optimum exists? Almost certainly not. But there's no guarantee that any other country is at this optimum themselves.
- vacri 13y agoIt depends on the treatment. Not all systems offer full cancer treatment, which is really expensive. What the other systems do have is free basic care - you won't be bankrupted if you break your arm or need a gall bladder removed. It's a myth that all healthcare needs are free everywhere. There's always some diseases that will fall through a net somewhere. This of course does not mean that the situation in the US is not abysmal, just that 'everywhere else has fully free medicine' is a myth.
- soperj 13y agoMain reason I never want to live in America is health care. Just knowing that no matter what I'll be admitted to the hospital and treated is something I never want to live without. *2nd reason would be gun violence.
- declan 13y agoYou seem to be mistaken on both counts. First, a federal law called EMTALA requires hospitals to provide emergency treatment regardless of citizenship or ability to pay. Second, there is more violence in the UK (about 2.5x-3x times as much per capita -- 993 violent crimes/100K vs. 399 violent crimes/100K) than the United States. And more pro-2A decisions from courts have led to a trend of reduction in US gun violence, including DC murders falling below triple digits post-Heller for the first time since 1963. (Of course it's possible that you live in a very peaceful society and view the UK as also having an unacceptable level of violence.) Now you may or may not choose to ever live in the United States; I don't care and it doesn't affect me either way. But you may want to educate yourself first.
- adamnemecek 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentiona... US: 4.7 per 100,000 inhabitants UK: 1.2 per 100,000 inhabitants Germany: 0.8 per 100,000 inhabitants
- robotresearcher 13y agoThose violent crimes in the UK don't tend to involve guns and/or becoming dead. UK homicide rate: 1.2 per 100,000 persons US homicide rate: 4.7 per 100,000 persons You are more than twice as likely to get beaten up in the UK than the US. You are around 4 times as likely to be murdered in the US than the UK. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentiona... The UK has a violence problem, probably at least in part due to the drinking. I feel less safe in London than LA. But it is crazy to deny that US gun violence isn't a thing.
- eli 13y agoTell me how to vote for change, and I'll gladly do it. In addition to being terrible, the current system discourages entrepreneurship and effectively taxes small businesses.
- grecy 13y ago> Tell me how to vote for change, and I'll gladly do it. Turn off your TV, get off your couch and get outside and protest like any good citizen of a democracy is required to do. Look what happens in France when the government tries to take away a single public holiday, or make changes to maternity leave. What your government is currently offering for health care is completely and utterly unacceptable beyond belief. It's your job to make them change it.
- LyndsySimon 13y ago> What your government is currently offering for health care is completely and utterly unacceptable beyond belief. It's your job to make them change it. Many of us argue that it's reprehensible that government is "offering" healthcare at all. We are protesting, though :)
- grecy 13y ago> We are protesting, though :) Really? I've never seen anything on the news about it, yet I see plenty of citizens of other countries in the news because they are protesting things their government is doing. You must not be protesting loud enough ;)