2 ms·
Ah, I see what the issue is here. I typically (used to) work in experimental placebo research, rather than clinical placebo research (I'm a psychologist by trad
by disgruntledphd2 13y ago
Ah, I see what the issue is here. I typically (used to) work in experimental placebo research, rather than clinical placebo research (I'm a psychologist by trade) so I would be more interested in those studies, rather than clinical trials.
In terms of what's left over after accounting for no treatment, Vase and H&G got into a big academic fight about this, and it appears that the effect size for placebo effects in pain is approximately (d=0.5), which is a relatively large effect (especially within psychology). This doesn't entirely account for experimenter effects, though with the use of a balanced-placebo design, those can be accounted for.
In terms of clinical trials, I would tend to agree with your second definition. Its not perfect, but its as good as it tends to get.
I think that one of the issues with placebo research is this notion of mind-over-matter, in that such a viewpoint is the reason that it is perceived as special, and also a reason why people disbelieve in it.
Based on old research (Levine, 1979) many (but not all) placebo effects in pain appear to be mediated by endogenous opioids,which I would take to mean that they are pretty naturally mediated by the brain, and so its a physical phenomenon. Many people do go a bit crazy with the woo around it though, I do agree.
Funny that this came up today, when I'm currently finalising a hopefully final draft of my thesis on the placebo (PROTIP: never, ever leave your university before submitting a PhD, it tends to go badly).
- garyrob 13y agoAre you posting your thesis online? I'd like to have a look.
- disgruntledphd2 13y agoIts on Github, in a private repository. When I'm finished, I plan to make the repository public (which is probably going to be embarrassing).