6 ms·
Exxon CEO sues against fracking in his own backyard
- ck2 13y agoBy the way, another problem they recently discovered is that states are ignoring or not properly doing air quality testing around fracking and some seriously bad chemicals are being released into the air. It is insane how we are going gung-ho into this with basically the whole USA as a testing ground, so what if it causes cancer clusters a decade later, the wells and the owners will be long gone.
- sentenza 13y agoIt's also wreaking geopolitical havoc. The USA now have a lot of cheap energy available. Good for them. Bad for the green energy revolution in Europe.
- lugg 13y agoHow so exactly? Less research funding? Offsetting the global prices making it cheaper in euro therefore more expensive to go green? Just curious. I wouldn't have thought it would be that big of a deal. I also wouldn't call fracking cheap in any sense of the word, far more expensive than liquid oil extraction and the repercussions of it are at least somewhat unknown so far. (Yeah yeah I know its totally safe if you do it right and Exxon et al are soo trustworthy when it comes to this stuff.)
- m_mueller 13y agoIt's amazing to me how people keep being so ignorant about the likely most troubling issue for the next two centuries. Climate prognosis for the next 80 years keeps getting worse. The most recent studies suggest one degree of warming per decade on average, assuming that CO2 production levels out just about now. Until humans are CO2 balanced, every ton we blow into the atmosphere simply keeps raising temperature with some time delay. 8 degrees warming on average worldwide means that some outlier regions, potentially the ones where raising temperatures are the most damaging, will see a temperature increase of 15 degrees. We're the frog inside the heating pot, except we even steer the gas burner - and we're still discussing which way to cook ourselves would be the most economical.
- lugg 13y agoI was halfway through my post when I reworded it to avoid this point. Not really sure how hn likes the doom talk yet, but seeing as you brought it up.. I watched a ted talk a while back where the speaker basically laid it out like this: 2 degrees c = screwy weather patterns, extreme storms 4 degrees c = sea level rise, no real seasons anymore, just a big swinging mess from extreme drought to extreme storms 6 degrees c = mad max 8 degrees c, he basically said humans were long gone at this point. Remember, 1 degree average = massive localised changes. Hmm now that I've written all this, I'm not sure, were you speaking in celsius or fahrenheit? edit, specified celcius, also I think this may have been the guy but not quite the same talk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pznsPkJy2x8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pznsPkJy2x8
- m_mueller 13y agoI was talking Celsius / Kelvin. I'm assuming the speaker was referring to Fahrenheit - I'm thinking mankind as a whole might be able to survive +8 degree K iff we find efficient synthetic food sources that work in such a climate (which I assume we will) - however it would probably be at a fraction of the population we have today - whether our civilization could survive an indirect genocide on a global scale to have the infrastructure to do this is another question. edit: re your edit: if it's true that +6 degrees sets perpetual heating mechanisms in motion which lead to +12 degrees by 2300 (as suggested in the ted talk), yes, we probably wouldn't survive +8 in the long run. it's damn scary, really - if we screw this up in the next 20 years, we basically damn the whole planet.
- adambard 13y agoYou mean, mankind might survive +8 degrees F (about +4.5 deg celcius)
- m_mueller 13y agoI meant Celsius, but see my edit - I have to revise that guess. Given that +6 degree C will probably cause runaway warming processes to initiate (which I wasn't thinking about before), surviving for even a few more centuries suddenly becomes a tough order.
- bsder 13y agoLess oil consumption by the US. Natural gas isn't as easy to transport or store, so it tends to get consumed locally. It's actually a good thing as it should displace some of the dirtier coal-fired power plants. Not to mention that gas-fired power plants should be easier to spin up and down with power demand. However, it lets the US off the hook in terms of political will to remove themselves from fossil fuels because the economics demands it. Fortunately, it seems like the world is now paying enough attention that green energy companies now can make their own way economically.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoActually, its going to be pretty awesome. We're going to start shipping our coal to China, since we'll have switched aging coal plants to combined natural gas turbines. The price of natgas will then go up in the future (duh); at that point, we'll either have to try to outbid China for the coal or drive more money into renewables. I'd like to think we'll go the right route, but this is America. We don't do the right thing until we've tried everything else.
- lugg 13y agoYou can convert natural gas into synthetic petrol pretty easily these days. New Zealand has been subsidizing its fuel usage this way with a 20%?synthetic at the pump mandate since the 70s?. As the price rises america will do the same if it isn't already. I thought that was kind of the point for fracking?
- sentenza 13y agoBasically yes. "Going green" increases energy prices and thus comes with a disadvantage regarding the cost of production/doing business. This cost is proportional to the relative offset to the global energy prices caused by green energy. So if the shale gas revolution drags down energy prices, it becomes politically harder to maintain the "go green" plan over here.
- a3n 13y agoI would hope that anyone in any other community fighting fracking would reference this lawsuit as evidence that Oil and its executives believe there are situations where they shouldn't be allowed access, at the least.
- Puer 13y ago>You see, while Tillerson believes that the inevitable noise pollution that accompanies the fracking process—not to mention the potential for water contamination and other dangerous side-effects even when it is done safely (and some would strenuously argue that it is not possible to frack safely)— is of no real significance when it affects someone else’s neighborhood, he surely thinks it to be a pretty big deal when someone dares to get involved in fracking in Rex Tillerson’s neighborhood. I'm 99% certain it's about decreased land values, not any possible environmental issues.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- adaml_623 13y agoI can't tell if you are being serious or not. Environmental issues include visual and noise pollution of the property and town. There is no clear line between 'pollution' that is bad for your health and 'pollution' that is just there descreasing the value of your land.
- Zancarius 13y ago> There is no clear line between 'pollution' that is bad for your health and 'pollution' that is just there descreasing the value of your land. It seems you're commenting solely to split hairs. I think Puer is right. In Mr. Tillerson's case, it's almost certainly a matter of land value. And probably a little selfishness, i.e. "not in my backyard." Indeed, I wouldn't be surprised if his concern was strictly a matter of worth and the dollar value of his property.
- pasbesoin 13y agoAnd all the "little people" whose land value is negatively impacted? They don't count? At least this "big guy" can afford to live somewhere else. Imagine having the environmental concerns, and not being able to sell and get away from them.
- 13y ago
- bsbechtel 13y agoJust some food for thought here....Many proponents of green energy (e.g., the Kennedys) in the form of wind farms throughout the Midwest put up a huge fight when plans for a wind farm off of Nantucket Sound got a little too close to home for them as well. This doesn't excuse the behavior taking place here, but it happens on both sides of the aisle.
- Zancarius 13y agoFunny, I was just thinking of that when I read this article. This isn't really so much a matter of hypocritical energy company CEOs as much as it is a reflection on the behaviors of the rich and privileged.
- scott_karana 13y agoI'd say it's the behavior of humans: selfishness is in our nature. The same situation plays out time and again with cellphone towers. People bitch about poor coverage, but as soon as a tower is going to be installed in their neighbourhood... :-) Similarly, people buy houses under the foot of airport runways, complain about the noise, and eventually the airports close... (NIMBY: Not in my backyard)
- Zancarius 13y agoI agree completely. It's almost humorous (I've been guilty of thinking some of these before sooooo...) Though, I do wonder if it isn't completely selfishness, including instead a pinch of resistance to change as part of the social recipe that drives us. In some of my other comments, I've suggested it's entirely greed or selfish motivations, but reflecting on my own experiences, resistance to change fits the bill fairly well. (Excepting financial motivation as partial to the cause, mind you.) We are creatures of habit, after all.
- michaelwww 13y agoThe opposition fight is being waged by the third Koch Brother http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/23/us/koch-brother-wages-12-year-fight-over-wind-farm.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/23/us/koch-brother-wages-12-y...
- us0r 13y agoYou can't make this up. Priceless.
- sethbannon 13y agoUnpalatable but unsurprising hypocrisy.
- roboneal 13y agoThe actual lawsuit isn't against fracking itself. It is to prevent construction of a 160 water tower that would be used to fill trucks with water for fracking and other oil/gas exploration activities and this is in violation of the existing zoning ordinances in the ranching community in which he lives. While it appears a subtle distinction to those looking for an example of glaring hypocrisy, would it be any different if he (and his other rancher neighbors) were protesting a construction of a 160ft water tower intended for some other purpose?
- kolbe 13y agoWhen you can afford the best lawyers, you can always find some way to be in the right. He would never directly fight against the right to frack. He needs to find something else that would prevent the fracking without affecting the right that he lobbied so hard to get.
- cykod 13y agoYou do know that there are no communities that have zoning ordinances allowing 160ft water towers, right? So there's always a variance of some sort involved if fracking is done near any residential community, but I don't think that's stopped the guy or Dick before. I still think the hypocrite card can quite validly be played here.
- roboneal 13y agoSo I can just build my own privately owned 160ft industrial structure wherever I want?
- PaulHoule 13y agoScary. This is what happens when people in power don't care if the system looks legitimate or not.
- WhatTheFrack 13y agoWhat a fracking joke! Hypocrisy at it's finest folks! This shows just how out of touch the 1% are with the 99%. ExxonMobil has bullied those cites, counties & homeowners that have tried to sue them to stop projects like the one Mr. Tillerson is so outraged about!!! So basically isn't he sorta just suing himself? People like this don't care about safety regulations, EPA regulations or people in general. It's the mighty dollar they have a relationship with! Watch as he uses his money to support a Tea Turd Candidate that wants less government, like The EPA to further their Fracking Cause. Gullible citizens that support their hand picked candidates do this by telling what you want hear not what the candidates are planning on doing once elected. These vultures just like the Koch Brothers don't care about these citizens they just want someone(candidate & special interest groups) to do their dirty work. They bankroll and fund the crap of their hand picked candidates campaigns all the while hiding in the shadows. They never speak in public or news interviews because people will do it for them. So my Question Is: "don't those supporting their idelogy & views realize their supporting something that is against their(your) best interest?"Wake up these slime balls are buying government to further their agenda. They want no regulations so they can deepen their pockets. They could care less about your home, land, town, city, county or state. Just read about the growing number of earthquakes in Oklahoma! If you vote for their candidates these scum support then you CAN NOT whine or moan once a well, water tower, pipeline or project like this runs right through your community! THINK!!!!' Think before voting this mid-election 2014. They could give a FRACK about your livelihood.
- WhatTheFrack 13y agoHOLY FRACK! Are you kidding me? What a fracking joke! Hypocrisy at is finest folks! This shows just how out of touch the 1% are with the 99%. ExxonMobil has bullied those cites, counties & homeowners that have tried to sue them to stop projects like the one Mr. Tillerson is so outraged about!!! So basically isn't he sorta just suing himself? People like this don't care about safety regulations, EPA regulations or people in general. It's the mighty dollar they have a relationship with! Watch as he uses his money to support a Tea Turd Candidate that wants less government, like The EPA to further their Fracking Cause. Gullible citizens that support their hand picked candidates do this by telling what you want hear not what the candidates are planning on doing once elected. These vultures just like the Koch Brothers don't care about these citizens they just want someone(candidate & special interest groups) to do their dirty work. They bankroll and fund the crap of their hand picked candidates campaigns all the while hiding in the shadows. They never speak in public or news interviews because people will do it for them. So my Question Is: "don't those supporting their idelogy & views realize their supporting something that is against their(your) best interest?"Wake up these slime balls are buying government to further their agenda. They want no regulations so they can deepen their pockets. They could care less about your home, land, town, city, county or state. Just read about the growing number of earthquakes in Oklahoma! If you vote for their candidates these scum support then you CAN NOT whine or moan once a well, water tower, pipeline or project like this runs right through your community! THINK!!!!' Think before voting this mid-election 2014. They could give a FRACK about your livelihood.