8 ms·
Don't Give Money to Fancy Colleges
- pkfrank 13y agoIf your goal is to help increase the # of high-achieving, low-income students at highly-selective colleges, you could choose to support a program such as QuestBridge. They find / link low-income high school students -- who otherwise wouldn't have the means or access to even apply to many of these schools -- with partner universities. I'm not sure if the article is trying to persuade potential donors to instead consider "lesser" colleges which might have more socioeconomic diversity. I guess it becomes a question of supporting: fewer low-income students at "better" schools; more low-income students at "worse" schools; or a totally different strategy to level the economic playing field in higher education.
- skywhopper 13y agoThe last paragraph of the article answers your question: "If you want to do something useful for low-income people, give them money. If you want to do something useful for the education of low-income people, give some money to an institution that educates kids from low-income families. That could be a community college or a public charter school or an afterschool program or neighborhood school or whatever you like."
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoIsn't the purpose of these donations to help your children, and their children, to get into the school? To establish your family as part of the tradition of that institution? To say that you like what that school is and does and that you want to connect yourself and your descendants to it?
- bilbo0s 13y agoBINGO! The implicit premise of the author is incorrect. The majority of these donations are not about helping the poor. If some of the money ends up doing so, well, that's gravy, but not the motivating intent.
- irishloop 13y agoI think the author is trying to imply (somewhat ineffectively, imo) that because Ivy Universities are now seen as bastions of progressive thinking, that perhaps people think giving them money would further the progressive cause, whereas in reality, it is contributing to the widening wealth gap.
- rbcgerard 13y agoNot really - most schools are pretty explicit (behind closed doors) about what it costs to get your kid in...submit an application, admissions looks at how qualified the candidate is, tells development, and they come up with a "suggested donation" a at Harvard a kid with good grades and SATs etc that would be a shoe in for say a top tier small liberal arts college (but wait list/rejection at Harvard) might cost ~$500k to $1M...so when you see people making really large donations it usually has more to do with legacy...or believe it or not appreciation for the opportunities afforded to them by their alma mater...that being said the whole notion of student aid is skewed by inflated/fake tuition prices...it's like paying $500 for an aspirin in the hospital the Medicaid patient paid 2% of that price, the Medicaid patient paid 10% private insurance 50% and cash 80-100% how much does an aspirin cost?
- jpmattia 13y ago> Isn't the purpose of these donations to help your children, and their children, to get into the school? There is certainly a subset that thinks like that. "Legacy" admission to a top tier school is probably not doing anyone any good, but that is a separate can of worms. But to your point above: There are a serious number of donors who believe that they are doing a small part in improving society. As an example: Few people outside of tech know the name Cecil Green, but his donations have had lasting effect on several generations of students.
- lmm 13y ago> we can assume that very little of that 5% is coming from the really truly poor No, you can't, not when it's the whole basis of your argument. My impression at an elite university was that if anything the upper-working class was least represented; there were plenty of students from the top, and some from the very bottom. If you're going to claim that Harvard or MIT's financial aid is poorly targeted, you need to actually provide evidence for this.
- 001sky 13y ago"you need to actually provide evidence for this." This is disingenuous. Documentary evidence is restricted by privacy laws, but the anecdotal evidence is self-evident. That's why the evidence they do show, eg about the 70% in the top quartile, makes sense and is consistent with your comments (100-70-5=25). Most "diversity" is from black lawyers, hispanic diplomats, and "poor white" children of liberal arts PhD's.
- res0nat0r 13y agoBut... the plural of anecdote is not data.
- 001sky 13y agoYes, but so what? Data itself is not evidence of relevance. Nor does lack of "data" imply lack of relevance. We know the requested data will not be forthcoming, so be-moaning the lack data is an empty gesture. It also ignores the data that is present.
- res0nat0r 13y agoBut, you said there isn't any actual data, just anecdotes. So without any actual measurable, quantifiable data, the above shouldn't be considered scientific and could be incorrect.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- MetalMASK 13y agoThe whole article is based on the assumption that people make donation to universities as charitable donations. I find that a bit unrealistic. Give money to universities are gesture of appreciation from alumni, gain more opportunities of networking/recognition from the university for the donor and his/her family, etc. For donations with the pure purpose of helping the poor, there are other institutions for that.
- btown 13y agoMost people don't donate to an alma mater just to support financial aid for lower-income students, nor just because they want to establish their family as a legacy; they donate in order to improve the institution and the quality of education, research, and inspiration it produces. It's a way of paying it forward, much the same philosophy as why people might go into education.
- xacaxulu 13y agoI'd never give money to a for-profit institution that sold something worthless at an incredibly inflated price, it's just not smart business.
- sosborn 13y agoDid you just argue that a degree is worthless? If you think it is tough getting a job with a degree try getting one without.
- rjbond3rd 13y agoDoes that really apply to people with outstanding skills in, e.g., programming? I can't imagine something less relevant to programming than formal education. It's not a good indicator for me.
- quaffapint 13y agoUntil big business changes - or heck even hiring at facebook - you need that piece of paper. It's absurd a lot of times - forced to take a lot of meaningless classes just to get a piece of paper that isn't worth a hole lot vs real world experience.
- sosborn 13y agoI'm in total agreement, but that doesn't change the reality of hiring practices.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoAgreed. I will never donate money to University of Phoenix, Devry, or ITT. But those other schools (Stanford, CMU, Harvard) are all non-profits.
- Patrick_Devine 13y agoThis post made me wonder why there isn't a Watsi for post-secondary education. Why not make a service where people could contribute bursaries directly to students or community colleges?
- gohrt 13y agoOne reason is that community college is already really well priced, and low-wealth students are currently eligible for financial aid at most institutions (community college and other colleges)
- plg 13y agoThese elite colleges (like the ivy leagues) will often place significant weight on "family legacy" factors when deciding whether to admit students. What more do we need to say?
- Vervious 13y agoAll that reducing donations to selective research universities will do is to reduce the quality of research. Given that universities like MIT and Harvard form the scientific backbone of the United States, I hesitate to condone the idea of sacrificing that for the sake of reducing Ivy League "elitism." It shouldn't be a situation where we have to pick 1 option out of 2. If you really want to reduce the socioeconomic gap in education, spend more money on public education as a nation. Donations from wealthy donors with next to no affiliation to local community colleges won't solve anything.
- ForHackernews 13y agoIn the United States, most scientific research is funded through government grants from agencies like the Department of Energy, Defense Department, or the National Science Foundation. Comparatively little research is actually funded from the endowments/operating budget of the universities themselves.
- whathappenedto 13y agoPlease don't make such a blanket statement. Donations do indeed fund scientific research directly. When a faculty member is hired, they get a "startup fund" to get through their first few years before they have grants, most of which is donated money. There is also a lot of research which is not "billed" to a grant, but is still meaningful, and supported by "internal funds" which are smaller university fellowships for pilot projects. These internal funds are also the only source of funding outside the physical sciences (for areas like humanities and social science) and are almost entirely provided for by donations.
- pcrh 13y agoThe amount of funding that the University supplies directly is obviously dependent on the field, and it's own traditions. However, in biomedicine, when a new prof has "startup" funds, these are often linked to their contributions to teaching and "service", i.e. admin, pastoral care, etc; they can later "buy-out" their service obligation by raising grants equal to their salary and costs, or more. So the "startup" funds are usually not entirely paying for research.
- ChristianMarks 13y agoA general principle is to never contribute to anyone else's power law distribution.
- ef4 13y agoElite institutions with big endowments get so little of their operating budget from tuition that I don't think it's outrageous to expect one to break ranks eventually and go tuition-free. Then I will happily give, and I expect a lot of deep pocketed alumni feel the same.
- MichaelDickens 13y agoI believe Stanford University gets something like 40% of its annual budget from tuition (other top universities are similar). That's not huge, but it's big enough to make it totally infeasible to simply stop charging tuition.
- nerfhammer 13y agoThe interest on Harvard's $32B endowment could pay its students' tuition in perpetuity
- hga 13y agoFor better or worse, these figures aren't quite as significant as they seem, because a lot of alumns restrict what their donations can be used for. E.g. the Widener one for Harvard's main library, which was fantastically restrictive even for that, and also required a swimming test since a son died in the Titanic disaster (not that being able to swim would have made much difference in water that cold). So, yeah, the interest could pay for all the tuition, except X of it is restricted to the law school, Y to the med school, Z to arts and sciences but not in any way that it can contribute to tuition, etc. Ah, and tuition money is particularly valued, because it's unrestricted....
- MichaelDickens 13y agoIt could, except that Harvard already uses a lot of the interest on that endowment to cover expenses. If they didn't have the endowment, tuition would have to be a lot higher.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoTuition isn't really the issue. Most top schools have needs-blind admissions, so conditional on getting in, you will get funding if you need it. Inequality stems from the fact that by the time they reach college admissions, students from richer families are already more qualified (at least in the eyes of admissions committees). Addressing this would require either changing the admissions process, or helping students from poorer families to become better qualified prior to the admissions process.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoJust because money benefits the rich disproportionately, it does not mean this money is not well spent. This is because the students at fancy colleges are not only richer, but also smarter, more ambitious, and harder working, on average. Furthermore, donations don't only benefit students, but researchers working at those universities. So while giving to fancy colleges is not necessarily the best use of money, it is not enough to show that the students there are privileged. If the students at those colleges were only there because of their privilege, then the author's point would make more sense.
- mkbhd 13y agoThe dynamism of America partly depends on new entrants into the uber-elite of money and power. (Poor kids becoming super rich within one generation. They shake things up and change the way things are done. This is partly a result of: 1. Poor kids getting into elite universities 2. The existence of highly elite universities If you provide less funding to the Harvards and MITs of the world do you really expect them to keep getting better and better? And if the overtime become "less awesome" then the benefits one derives from attending will decline. In that case, the poor kid that managed to get into Harvard, etc (or any of the Ivys, they all provide great financial aid) wouldn't benefit the way today's attendee does. The path for that poor kid to break into the uber wealthy just became harder. The Mark Zuckerbergs, Steve Schwarzmans of the world make America dynamic. Poor or middle class kids that break into the uber wealthy and disrupt the way things are done. Non-elite universities don't make that path easier - regardless of how much money you throw at them. Elite universities provide poor kids with things we need: 1. Status / credibility - maybe not important in tech, but definitely important in high-finance, politics, etc 2. Exposure to those who come from families that have done really well 3. Access to leading faculty and research opportunities You can throw tons of money at non-elite colleges, they still will not be able to provide the above. I'm not saying that non-elite universities are useless - they are incredibly important for having a healthy middle class. But what makes America great in my opinion is that every few years 5-10 kids that grew up poor make it to the top, change our world, and kick those that were complacent while at the top out.
- danielweber 13y agoIf you contribute $5,000,000 to Harvard or MIT, the marginal number of students from lower-middle-class and down backgrounds that would be admitted over the next 10 years would change by 0. They are already need-blind. There are other valid reasons to donate to a university, but the really big names aren't going to start recruiting more poor kids if they only had a little more money.
- mkbhd 13y agoAgree completely. At the margin, $5m won't make a difference, just like at the margin donating $10 to cancer research won't make a difference. But that $5m check along with many other checks does make a difference - both in helping these school achieve even higher levels of excellence and in their ability to fund poor and middle class student tuition.
- rayiner 13y agoI would argue that perpetuating hierarchy is almost the point of big donations. Yale alums are invested in making sure their alma mater's endowment keeps pace with that of Harvard and Princeton. Etc. The other part is tribalism. If you're a Harvard alum you donate to Harvard because you believe in their mission and want to help them carry out that mission. Other schools can depend on their own tribes for the same. I don't think donors are confused about these motivations.