5 ms·
Here's a PDF for anyone who wants to take a stab :-) http://brbl-dl.library.yale.edu/pdfgen/exportPDF.php?bibid=2002046&solrid=3519597 http://brbl-dl.library.y
by adamnemecek 13y ago
Here's a PDF for anyone who wants to take a stab :-)
http://brbl-dl.library.yale.edu/pdfgen/exportPDF.php?bibid=2002046&solrid=3519597 http://brbl-dl.library.yale.edu/pdfgen/exportPDF.php?bibid=2...
- WalterSear 13y agoNice.
- neur0mancer 13y agoSomeone should build a web plataform to allow to decode it using crowdsourcing ..
- scott_karana 13y agoCrowdsourcing? Researchers already collaborate on works like this, so all we would get are unexperienced looky-loos and trolls. (Or were you being silly :P)
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoQuantity is a quality of it's own. I think getting large number of people to try something is a good way to move forward. Sure it is not efficient, but fairly reliable.
- rantanplan 13y agoAu contraire. It is efficient but fairly unreliable :)
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoI would beg to differ. It is not efficient from standpoint of labor allocation. Not experienced people are rarely efficient at completing complex tasks. On the other hand once problem captures imagination of the significant portion of population amount of progress made goes way up.
- rantanplan 13y agoIt depends on the problem. There are problems that are higly parallelizable and problems that are not. There are problems where expertise is paramount and problems where it is not. What you said is true but what I said is also true, if you stretch enough the definition of "fairly unreliable" :)
- Renaud 13y agoYou mean like a large number of people with no qualification and experience went looking for the Boston bombing suspect? I'll leave it here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-22214511 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-22214511
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoI would argue that this is more of a mob lynching, rather than constructive combined effort. To look for models that work, look no further than open source. Projects with high amount of interest quite often do better.
- catshirt 13y agoi assure you it was intended to be a constructive combined effort. i only skimmed the article linked but it doesn't seem to reference the fact that the kid who was falsely identified was found dead, presumably by his own hand. "hell is full of good meanings, but heaven is full of good works", as they say. on a lighter note, if you consider an open source project "crowdsourced" then i posit the current collaborative academic efforts to decode the manuscript are "crowdsourced" as well.
- pyre 13y agoWhich kid is that? The one that was already missing before the bombing? http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-04-26/falsely-accused-bombing-suspect-confirmed-dead/4652176 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-04-26/falsely-accused-bombin...
- 8ig8 13y agoSomething like _Voynich Genius_ ? http://rapgenius.com http://rapgenius.com
- Geee 13y agoHah, on the page 85 that 'P' character got a bit out of hand. :) It's weird that every paragraph starts with either the 'K' or 'P' characters. Not sure if that could be possible with real languages.
- itchitawa 13y agoThis observation lends weight to my naked women theory. That extravagent P has arms, legs, a head and ... :P
- lloeki 13y ago> It's weird that every paragraph starts with either the 'K' or 'P' characters. It's not like many languages out there end (or wrap, even!) their sentences with a couple of unique symbols.
- russellsprouts 13y agoIt could be a poem. Psalm 119 has 22 stanzas, with the first letter of each sentence of the stanza being with the same letter of the Hebrew alphabet. In the first stanza, each verse starts with aleph, in the second beth, and so on.
- PeterisP 13y agoIt could be quite feasible if the symbol has a similar meaning to an article in English.
- msbarnett 13y agoIt's not that unlikely in highly formalized writing. You see similar phenomenon in very formal English registers, where you might see a whole run of sentences begin with "Whereas...." One after another.
- itchitawa 13y agoSurprising discovery about the Voynich manuscript - it contains hundreds of pictures of naked women, probably outnumbering the pictures of plants. Maybe the focus on botany is misguided!