5 ms·
The differences in the taste of chocolate between the US and Europe/the rest of the world all stem back to the late 1800's & early 1900's. This is when the gre
by tjpd 13y ago
The differences in the taste of chocolate between the US and Europe/the rest of the world all stem back to the late 1800's & early 1900's. This is when the great modern confectioners got their start as (mostly puritanical) family firms. Daniel Peter invented solid milk chocolate in 1875 in Switzerland. John Cadbury followed suit in England with his first milk chocolate bar in 1897. Milton S. Hershey in the US built his first chocolate manufacturing plant in 1903. Franklin Clarence Mars founded Mars in Washington in 1911 only to fail & restart in Minnesota in 1920.
Prior to David Peter's invention of solid milk chocolate in 1875 chocolate was known as a drink. One of the challenges of making the, now familiar, milk chocolate bar was reducing the water content of the milk to make it easier to emulsify and set the chocolate. This had to be done in a way that kept the creaminess and didn't burn or scorch the milk and that wouldn't spoil. The Swiss got there first it. Cadbury figured it out (or just copied the Swiss). Hershey struggled. He had a chocolate manufacturing plant that was closely guarded not to avoid someone stealing his chocolate recipe but to avoid anyone discovering he didn't have one.
One day in 1904 he cracked it & depending on who you believe, either by perseverance or by parsimony. Hershey's advocates will tell you that late one night, after many failed attempts he & his colleague John Shmalbach discovered just the right slow evaporation of non-fat milk that produced a creamy, faintly bitter chocolate. Hershey's detractors will tell you how a tight-fisted Milton Hershey did not want to waste a large delivery of milk powder that had soured and instead used it & found it sold surprisingly well. Either way that's when Hershey's distinctive "sour" flavour was introduced.
Then the Great War happened. Supply problems & rationing hugely restricted Cadbury & the other European manufacturers. Hershey, despite producing what many thought was a worse product had fewer supply issues and, without European competitors, a US market largely to himself. By the time Europe has finally picked itself up after the Second World War the American palate and taste for chocolate has long since been fixed.
TLDR: Americans have terrible chocolate because in 1914 a Moravian took a wrong turn and got an Austrian shot by a Bosnian
p.s. I love chocolate. I can't stand Hersheys.
- eru 13y agoInteresting. What about proper bitter chocolate that doesn't contain any milk?
- ghayes 13y agoYour telling of the history is interesting. Stating your opinion as fact? Less so. E.g. yogurt is sour (fermented) milk, and is quite delicious. Or you might think it's terrible. How about we both agree that Hershey's chocolate has a "distinct, sour flavor" and leave it at that?
- TazeTSchnitzel 13y agoIt is fact, not opinion, that Hershey's chocolate contains an olifactory compound found in vomit.
- jrabone 13y agoYes. It's hard to convince Americans just how absolutely revolting Hershey's is to the European palate.
- JetSetWilly 13y agoEuropeans must hate Parmesan cheese then. It is the exact same olfactory compound found in Parmesan, and is responsible for Parmesan's unique taste. That Europeans aren't falling over themselves to condemn the revolting nature of Parmesan suggests to me their dislike of Hershey's is largely based on snobbery.
- nly 13y agoCheese is overripe milk though, it's kind of expected. Many people have a sensitive palate and won't eat any cheese: it all tastes rotten to them.
- JetSetWilly 13y agoHow exactly? It just amuses me that people bring up the vomit thing (actually butyric acid) like it is some laughable feature of Hershey's and inherently horrifying.. but they never mention all the other foods that are high in butyric acid, and are in fact loved by foodies. People can dislike hersheys, but going on about how it "is made to taste like vomit" like it is a shocking revelation, is a double standard.
- danmaz74 13y agoActually, solid chocolate (but not milk chocolate) was invented in Turin at the start of 19th century: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Paul_Caffarel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Paul_Caffarel
- bluedino 13y ago>> Americans have terrible chocolate because in 1914 a Moravian took a wrong turn and got an Austrian shot by a Bosnian That's like saying America has terrible cheeseburgers because of McDonald's.
- jessedhillon 13y agoActually, given that their purchasing power is so immense it actually changes what's available to every other burger maker in the market, that might be true.
- adamdavis 13y agoExcept that its observably not (true).