7 ms·
Plan To Split California Into Six States Gets OK To Gather Signatures
- bruceb 13y agoIn other news MySpace wants to regain its lead over facebook.
- thyrsus 13y agoHow do you convince a Republican to vote for this?
- thatthatis 13y agoThe two eastern Californias would be republican slam dunks for senate seats.
- CWuestefeld 13y agoI would think the question is the other way around. It's a step (possibly a small one) to diluting the DEM monolith that his California. Today CA can be depended to field a DEM slate of senators, and send DEM electors to the electoral college [1]. If broken up, then some of the new senators would presumably go GOP, as would some of the electoral votes. It would be fascinating to see the outcome of such a plan. The results would be interesting from poli sci, economics, and sociology perspectives. [1] Is CA an all-or-nothing state, or is it proportional? I don't recall.
- dmm 13y agoThere is no way the other states would allow california to get 12 senators. Right?
- protomyth 13y agoPlaying the long game, if the split was right, yep they would because then California could not pull some of the stunts it has in the past[1]. Textbook companies are another area that would change because of split CA. 1) latest one http://www.kansascity.com/2014/02/04/4798111/missouris-koster-sues-california.html http://www.kansascity.com/2014/02/04/4798111/missouris-koste...
- mbell 13y agoHere are the results from the 2012 Senate election by county: http://www.politico.com/2012-election/map/#/Senate/2012/CA http://www.politico.com/2012-election/map/#/Senate/2012/CA I'd venture a guess that 2 maybe 3 (if also looking at the numbers for the house elections) of the 6 new states may go republican.
- mhurron 13y agoTell them it will make it so the liberal hippies they currently share a state with will end up in another state and they'll be free to oppress any group they feel like.
- pliny 13y agoOffer a split that creates an equal amount of Democratic and Republican senators.
- protomyth 13y agoTake the two top states (purple & blue) and make them vertical (one coastal, one inland) as opposed to horizontal. That would probably be enough to tip the scales. I do think it might be a problem for Democrats in the first place because CA would no longer be an electoral fortress. Much like the plan to split NYC and surrounding counties from NY state. I am more interested in water policy once a split occurs. I would imagine some desalination plants would finally be built.
- dllthomas 13y ago"I am more interested in water policy once a split occurs. I would imagine some desalination plants would finally be built." I agree, although there are some desalinization plants already.
- protomyth 13y agoI'm figuring once LA and SF have no political influence over the former CA farmland, there are going to be more.
- dllthomas 13y agoI agree; I was just clarifying.
- protomyth 13y agoActually, I only saw Carlsbad desalination plant and it isn't done. It seems like this article http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Desalination-plants-a-pricey-option-if-drought-5239096.php http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Desalination-plants-a-pri... shows none completed.
- dllthomas 13y agoHm, Wikipedia says "California has also begun producing a small amount of desalinated water, water that was once sea water, but has been purified." That may need a "citation needed", at least - at a skim I'm not seeing support for it.
- samstave 13y agoYay! More DMV franchises!
- tribe2012 13y agoWould this mean everyone in CA would need to get new licenses?
- protomyth 13y agoYes for all licenses with the possibility of different rules. The redone letterhead will be a major cost (no, I'm not joking).
- jack-r-abbit 13y agoThink about all the flags that the whole nation would have to replace.
- protomyth 13y agoThink of all the state drop-downs that need to be replaced.
- hartator 13y agoI don't really see the point, is it for a more strong separation between rich and poor California? edit: It seems they target to have a better ratio senators/californians and to get rid of the debt. details: http://techcrunch.com/2013/12/19/tim-draper-six-californias-secede-silicon-valley-ballot-initiative/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/12/19/tim-draper-six-californias-...
- BryantD 13y agoIt's for a more strong separation between rich and poor California. This plan would create the nation's poorest state by per capita income (Central California), and I think Jefferson would also be in the bottom 10. http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2014/02/05/rich-state-poor-state-vcs-six.html?page=all http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2014/02/05/rich-stat... http://bber.unm.edu/econ/us-pci.htm http://bber.unm.edu/econ/us-pci.htm (per capita income list as of 2012)
- mktgtheweb 13y agoActually, you think Central CA would be the poorest, although that's assuming policy remains unchanged. Imagine a conservative state within 1+ hr drive of the bay area, that could eliminate personal income tax attracting workers from Silicon Valley, affordable housing, better weather, water control (delta), and agriculture.
- dllthomas 13y agoBecause the Altamont Pass isn't enough of a parking lot during the commute.
- BryantD 13y agoYes, I do, because I'm from New England so I don't have to imagine those things. I've lived in New Hampshire: a conservative state within an hour drive of Boston with no personal income tax and housing that's way more affordable than Boston. These factors don't magically make it more affluent than Boston.
- EGreg 13y agoThis is a joke, right? I ain't buying new flags...
- TallGuyShort 13y agoNot a joke, but probably very unlikely. There was recently a motion to split Colorado into 2 states with very strong support internally, and it went nowhere.
- Xdes 13y agoThis is a good thing. If bigger states break up then there will be better representation in congress.
- Aloisius 13y agoExcept you know... they won't be the same state anymore. It won't be too many years before they act like six competing states because of competing interests. By staying one state, California has the benefit of being one of the most powerful economies on the planet which, even without having things pass at the federal government, allows significant world power. California's car efficiency standards over the years for instance basically forced every car company that sells a car in the US to up their efficiency. There is no chance that would happen if it was just 1/6th of California.
- BryantD 13y agoPrevious discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6957282 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6957282 That discussion includes some breakdowns of possible voting numbers (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6957513 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6957513). I don't think it would be a slam dunk for Republican senators but it would be a lot more likely. (dragonwriter's followup to my numbers analysis is important and accurate.)
- tansey 13y agoGood luck convincing the rest of the country to give your region 10 new senators.
- dllthomas 13y agoStacking small states until you have CA's population, you have enough senators to sustain a filibuster. We have 2. This is both undemocratic and unreasonable.
- twoodfin 13y agoThe undemocratic part was considered a feature, not a bug. As to unreasonable: It's a rare issue that unites the smaller states. From a national political perspective, Vermont and Wyoming couldn't be much further apart. So I am not persuaded by arguments that assume there is a threat of a small-state Senate alliance against the overwhelming wishes of the rest of the country. On the other hand, if you want to argue that overuse of the filibuster has put an inordinate amount of legislative power in the hands of the Senate majority leader and a dozen middle-of-the-road Senators, I agree. But the solution to that problem is to fix the filibuster, not destroy the Constitutional balance between states and the Federal government.
- dllthomas 13y agoUndemocratic is a feature and a bug. It shifts over firmly into "bug" territory when it gets too extreme. "From a national political perspective, Vermont and Wyoming couldn't be much further apart." Vermont and Wyoming are strongly united on a number of issues (guns immediately springs to mind). I'm not the least bit sure that Central California and Silicon Valley would be united on fewer. The notion that Vermont and New Hampshire should be separate; Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Rhodes Island should be separate; Maryland and Virginia should be separate; but Sacramento, San Diego, Los Angeles, and San Francisco all belong in the same state is laughable. "But the solution to that problem is to fix the filibuster, not destroy the Constitutional balance between states and the Federal government." Right, because when they wrote the Constitution, Jefferson and Madison and friends carefully laid out California's borders. When California entered the Union, its population was less than 1% of the total US population. Now it's well more than 10%. The borders that made sense when it was a state like Wyoming don't make sense anymore. It has population like the eastern seaboard, it has industry like the eastern seaboard, it should have borders more like the eastern seaboard.
- julienchastang 13y agoThe problem with the United States is that there are too many states rather than not enough of them. The states are too small and weak to solve their own problems (e.g, health care, high speed rail) so they have to rely on a dysfunctional federal government that can't solve any real problems these days (e.g., education, immigration, and of course health care).
- FireBeyond 13y agoAgreed. You should not be able to drive across a state in less than two hours.
- cafard 13y agoThose managing the Delaware toll booths on I-95 seem to agree with you. However, many eastern states can be traversed in on common travel routes in about that time. In clear traffic, you can do the Maryland stretch of I-95 in about two hours. Connecticut and Rhode Island are not particularly large.
- Aqua_Geek 13y agoCalifornia isn't exactly a shining beacon of problem solving.
- dba7dba 13y agoThis isn't about Dem versus GOP imo. It's about Silicon Valley against the rest of the world.
- poweredbytofu 13y ago>>"Supporters of a plan to divide California into six sates" I would take this news article a bit more seriously if they had spelled "states" correctly in the first sentence...
- nkoren 13y agoI actually think that a lot of good could come from splitting up California. This would allow the intense stupidity of its politics to be less monolithic, and would permit more experimentation with policy, which might have a good outcome. That said, as a former San Luis Obispan, the notion of being an adjunct of Los Angeles (see http://www.sixcalifornias.info/ http://www.sixcalifornias.info/) makes me shudder. And having Los Angeles and Orange County in separate states makes no sense. If you were going to carve up California along lines of economic and cultural interest, then I'd adjust the Six Californias as follows: Jefferson (blue, in the far north) -- looks about right (and has a great history, worth reading about). Northern California -- I'd swap Alpine, Mono, and Inyo counties into this state (from Central Valley), as this creates a state which is dominated by wilderness, tourism, and natural resources. Central Valley (red) -- I'd take San Benito from Silicon Valley, to create a state which is unified by agriculture. Silicon Valley (yellow) -- I'd shift San Benito to Central Valley and Monterrey to Central Coast (green), creating a more technology-centric state. Central Coast (green) -- take Monterrey, but send Ventura and Los Angeles to Southern California. This is a rural area dominated by nature and tourism, and shouldn't be swallowed by Los Angeles politics. Southern California (orange) -- take Ventura and Los Angeles from Central Coast, so as not to split up the overall conurbation. Chances of this (or any version thereof) actually happening? Nil -- but it's kind of fun to think about.
- quanpod 13y agothese proposals pop up every season - interesting that it looks like it could be reasonably balanced (from a senate perspective - central, west, and another could vote more 'red'), that means Democrats would lose a part of the gigantic electoral votes CA brings. All in all, probably not going to happen.
- dllthomas 13y agoOn the other hand, every Democratic president for a long time would have still won their election if CA had gone the other way.
- wf 13y agoI imagine Silicon Valley turning into The Capitol in The Hunger Games.
- chiph 13y agoI guess central CA would get to keep the bear on their flag. West CA could use a Range Rover as their symbol. South CA might use the Joshua Tree. Silicon Valley would have the iFlag...
- Aloha 13y agoBalance of Payments. Bay Area and LA Area pay the bulk of the taxes in the state - there is a net transfer of money from the rich counties on the coast to the poorer ones in the north and east, in short, it would take counties that get many services paid for and supplied by the state as a whole, to a level that could possibly resemble a third world country. California is unmanageable - but its because via the initiative process the voters have boxed everything into a corner.