5 ms·
Reading Perlman's descriptions it does sound like distributed beamforming. Perlman is a smart guy, although I expect he would be more successful selling this te
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
Reading Perlman's descriptions it does sound like distributed beamforming. Perlman is a smart guy, although I expect he would be more successful selling this technology initially to crowded venues (think large stadiums, or conference centers) which would allow those venues to both offer consistent high performance access to fans as well as high performance wireless channels for things like flying cameras (which is currently quite the mismash of technologies).
That said, I continue to remain dubious because his claims are fairly out there in terms of bandwidth. I don't know if Claude Shannon were alive today if he could figure out if there was an upper limit of directed traffic in a channel but that is the principle that feels like its being violated here. All of my training has taught me to think of a bit of spectrum like a single wire, and sure you can attach a bunch of things to that wire, but there isn't a lot of theory around how that becomes a bunch of separate but equivalent channels.
- lutusp 13y ago> That said, I continue to remain dubious because his claims are fairly out there in terms of bandwidth. No additional bandwidth is required beyond what cell systems already provide. The idea behind this method is that each outgoing packet has some extra information about phase for each antenna that will be used to transmit it. The extra information is calculated using Perlman's data center and added to the data structure of a specific packet meant for a specific device. The extra information tells the transmitting antennas which phase delay to apply to maximize the signal at the device's current location. My point is that this method doesn't change the bandwidth required for the cell system -- in many ways everything is as it was before, except that each participating device experiences better reception. This system relies on a relatively simple phase adjustment at each transmitting antenna, but because of the number of devices, the number of antennas and the math involved, a dedicated data center would have to be added to an existing cell system. But there's no change in terms of bandwidth -- that remains the same.
- ChuckMcM 13y ago"The technology would do away with wireless network congestion by giving each smartphone and tablet its own super-fast connection instead of asking these devices to share bandwidth pumped out by a cell tower." "In demonstrations at his laboratory, Perlman showed off iPhones, Surface tablets, and TVs streaming massive files—the 4K UltraHD version of House of Cards from Netflix, for example—via his own wireless networking equipment" These are both bandwidth narratives, not signal quality narratives. (granted they are the naive reporter's narratives but still). His breakthrough is that "all these devices can stream 4K ultra HD" that says that somehow he getting more bits to more machines, and that is a function of bandwidth not signal strength. Lets assume for the moment that the basestation is connected to some multi-lambda super fiber with a 40G connection back to the Internet. He's going to give every LTE phone a 100Mbps to 1Gbps connection to that? That works for the first 400 or 40 people but then what? 5 bars and stuttering video? This story, and others like it, have made the argument that the problem is congestion not signal clarity. Congestion is a function of channel bandwidth and operation rate. That is what leaves me dubious, I haven't seen how he can increase the bandwidth of the channel with his gizmo.
- lutusp 13y agoI think the journalist didn't understand what he was seeing. Clearly if signal strength is improved and phase distortion is removed, the error rate will go down and this will improve apparent bandwidth, but without requiring more bandwidth than the system already can provide in principle. To me, the first sentence in your quote from the article is simply hyperbolic but has no connection with reality. The method doesn't do away with network congestion, it simply improves the signal at each participating device. > Congestion is a function of channel bandwidth and operation rate. I think the congestion this method addresses is that caused by unsophisticated signal treatment methods and an overall decline in performance. Obviously if the system can optimize the phase at each transmitting antenna and improve the received signal for each device, then more devices can use the system simultaneously. That's not how I would define "do away with network congestion", but again, I think the journalist just had no idea what he was describing.
- TheEzEzz 13y agoI'm not sure if I'm reading you right (not my area of expertise), but my understanding of the system is that this does increase total bandwidth. Each cell phone gains access to the entire spectrum of the transmitting source, rather than all phones splitting/sharing the available spectrum. It's as if only a single cell phone was in a given tower cell, and the tower was dedicating all its bandwidth to that single phone.
- lutusp 13y agoNo, I don't think so. If that were true, the cell system would have to upgrade its throughput. That would make this scheme unattractive to cell companies. I think the reason for all the attention given to this method is because it greatly improves the performance of a cell system without requiring any bandwidth increase. Remember that dropped packets are at times a big limitation on cell system performance, and much existing bandwidth is often wasted on packets that don't get decoded properly because of weak signals. > It's as if only a single cell phone was in a given tower cell, and the tower was dedicating all its bandwidth to that single phone. If the system can adjust the phases of the transmitting antennas to maximize the signal strength to a particular device, for each transmitted packet, then for all practical purposes that's true -- the entire bandwidth of the system really does become available to that particular device, for the duration of each packet meant for it. I don't know the statistics on dropped packets, but I think it's substantial in modern times for high-speed networks. The ratio of dropped packets essentially represents a bandwidth decrease. If that could be eliminated, it would improve throughput, and someone will be tempted to claim that bandwidth has increased. Only sort of.
- wmf 13y agoAFAIK the Shannon limit applies to a channel with a single transmit antenna and a single receive antenna. MIMO can get a factor of N more throughput without breaking Shannon by using N antennas.
- foobarqux 13y agoShannon's channel capacity theorem applies to channels generally, including MIMO channels. It is a theoretical maximum which cannot be exceeded for a given channel. But a MIMO channel is a different channel than SISO and has a different capacity.
- lutusp 13y agoNot if the antennas are all carrying the same signal. In the described system, the antennas get phase adjustments, but they do not get different signals, and this idea doesn't rely on multiple, independent data channels. So the Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem still applies.
- cma 13y agoI imagine it is something like a XOR-swap: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XOR_swap_algorithm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XOR_swap_algorithm I imagine two phones X and Y and one antenna sends X XOR Y while the other sends X XOR Y XOR Y. A phone getting both signals could determine X and Y, but it would take twice as much bandwidth. If you can XOR the signals in the air through superposition somehow, X might be received in one location, and Y in another. So 2 antennas cant service more than 2 phones at full speed, but they can service those two phones at full bandwidth. This might not seem like an advantage over directional antennas, but it relaxes the physical constraint of making sure the phones are in two separate enough places to be serviceable by the two antennas. Like maybe your phone would have two antennas and get twice the data--not very feasible if your phone were somehow serviced by two directional antennas. I haven't worked out how superposition could do something exactly like XOR, or if it maybe has a minimum of 3 antennas to start being possible, etc., but it seems plausible. Anyway, the idea would be sending signal X and Y. You want X interfering with Y at some time offset to yield desired phone signal A, and X interfering with Y at some other time offset to yield phone signal B. The phones never receive X or Y, but some superposition of the two, The phones couldn't cheat and just record the two waves and timeshift internally to yield twice the bandwidth, because they don't receive the two waves separately, they only get the superposition of the two.
- Dylan16807 13y agoThe beamforming means that each channel can use less power and get a higher SNR. Thinking of aimed signals as a single wire is wrong. The hardware analogy is a single wire in a highly-directional antenna aimed at each client. There's no real sharing of spectrum. The only difference is that you can use software plus 100 undirected antennas to simulate having directed antennas.
- kalleboo 13y ago> although I expect he would be more successful selling this technology initially to crowded venues I would expect he would be more successful patenting the hell out of it and licensing it to Ericsson, NSN, Qualcomm, Cisco, etc than trying to sell it to individual venues and customers.
- femto 13y agoIt reads like a type of cooperative base station, which means geographically separate antennas are used to transmit signals that add up to a "clean" signal at the receiving antenna, in which interference is cancelled. That's equivalent to a form of MIMO, in which the antennas are widely distributed in space. Consequently, I'd expect it to be subject to the same limitations as MIMO. I'm predicting that the breathless claims of "no limit" are based on being the only show in town. As long as the system is controlling every transmission in a volume of space it will do well, and you will be able to add users until you reach the same limits that a MIMO system would hit if it was the only transmitter. Start adding uncontrolled interference, and things will start to degrade. Maybe the next step, would be for the distributed base stations to use receivers to sample the spectrum. This data could be fed back into the cloud and an attempt be made to predict and cancel the uncontrolled interferers. The FCC (or local equivalent) might take a dim view of this though, if it turned out that the cancellation was effectively jamming other users. --- Edit. Just adding, in my experience, if you want to understand the latest radio communications technology, speak to a radio astronomer. When MIMO first came out and people were trying to figure out its limits, it turned out that the radio astronomers already knew the limits, based on their knowledge of large antenna arrays. I'd guess the astronomers would look at this current technology and think "very long baseline interferometry".
- darkmighty 13y agoYou bet this is just like interferometry -- astronomers those days can actually perform it with thousands of miles of separation. Although they're not really forced into the economies required here.