13 ms·
The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking
- Karunamon 13y agoAnother article that makes a really basic mistake involving "the secret". You don't visualize yourself taking the steps to accomplish a goal, you visualize yourself and your feelings as if the desired goal has already been accomplished. Not "I will lose 25 pounds!", but instead "I have lost 25 pounds and I look and feel awesome and am very happy and thankful to have done so!" - A great deal of the secret is replicating the emotional state you'll be in when your given goal is accomplished. The idea being that, I suppose if you were to remove the supernatural element from it, it somehow gets your subconscious to motivate you to doing whatever it is you want done. Calling it "positive thinking" really doesn't do the concept justice. Thinking of goals as already accomplished doesn't really fit that definition.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sp332 13y agoReally? I think I would rather sit around and fantasize about being fit than put in the effort to lose 25 pounds. If I get the emotional reward before the work, why do the work?
- kaybe 13y agoI guess it depends on what you're fighting. If you're just lazy you might be right, but if you're not doing things because you are not sure you're doing the right thing, not sure what you are doing and how and feel intimidated and unhappy, it can help to get into a better frame of mind beforehand. Some things are so much harder when bad feelings get in the way.
- jgroszko 13y agoThe reasoning goes that feeling the need for something actually pushes it away, or rather a feeling of neediness attracts more neediness. But if you feel satisfied with your weight then reality will find ways to bring you to a weight you're actually satisfied with, such as inspiring you to go work out.
- acheron 13y ago"It's easy to sit there and say you'd like to have more money. And I guess that's what I like about it. It's easy. Just sitting there, rocking back and forth, wanting that money." -- Jack Handey
- evacuationdrill 13y agoThis idea, making future consequences (positive or negative) of present choices more vivid and real is something I learned from this LessWrong article[1]. I think it will appeal more to this audience than _The Secret_. [1] http://lesswrong.com/lw/9wr/my_algorithm_for_beating_procrastination/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/9wr/my_algorithm_for_beating_procras...
- GFischer 13y agoVery definitely. I couldn't make it much past the first pages of The Secret. I absolutely hate messianic-style writing.
- npsimons 13y agoYeah, not to judge a book by it's cover, but everything about "The Secret" screams new-agey superstitious bullshit (redundant?). Positive psychology does seem to have some common sense things going for it (ie, if you think something is impossible, it probably is, for you), but there are better books out there (cf "The Happiness Advantage" by Shawn Achor; he also did a TED talk that sums up some of the themes nicely: http://www.ted.com/talks/shawn_achor_the_happy_secret_to_better_work.html http://www.ted.com/talks/shawn_achor_the_happy_secret_to_bet...)
- Sparkky 13y agoThe original post really is criticizing a straw man. Not just because they are missing the point such as how you are saying, but their paint positive thinking as relentless and illogical lies. Much like criticizing all liberals as being dreadlock'd pot smoking communists, or criticizing conservatives for hating everyone who isn't them and being heartless. Using these extreme examples does nothing more than incite arguments... But I guess in this guess arguments get you links, and links get you ad revenue... perhaps it's not so surprising why this article was written.
- Zigurd 13y agoIt is pretty well established that people will do what they think about doing. But it doesn't follow that if you consciously think more about something you will do it. That is, people who think about food all the time get fat, but people who will themselves to think about being thin don't get thin.
- Karunamon 13y agoThat's the difference though. Visualizing "getting thin" is a whole 'nother world from visualizing already being thin and the emotional state you'll be in once that goal is reached. Not "will do", but "already done".
- theorique 13y agoA lot of the problem with "positive thinking" is that it's also wishful thinking, rather than the design of resilient systems that make success a natural byproduct of practicing the system. Instead of naive positive thinking, psychological research in habit forming suggests that creating a robust system and habit (or set of habits) is much more powerful. Assuming and accepting infrequent shocks (e.g. on a diet, but ate 3000 calories at a wedding banquet) and building the system to handle these, is much more likely to create success than fantasy thinking.
- hosh 13y agoI've found a lot of system design and habit formation to be a kind of wishful thinking and naive in its own way.
- theorique 13y agoIf you design an overly elaborate "fantasy" system that you don't actually practice, I absolutely agree. So-called "productivity porn" tends to verge on this problem. David Allen talked about this - to paraphrase, he said that your real system is what you actually do when you are tired / hurried / overworked and don't have time to do all the steps of your idealized system. (Obviously, he recommends a very simple system that you can practice easily at any time.)
- zeidrich 13y agoHabit formation isn't wishful thinking, but I'd say that habit design is. Habit formation itself comes from routine. Not the desired routine. This is why we have bad habits. Good habits are hard, because they are not what we naturally tend towards doing (or we wouldn't try to build them, we'd already have them). Habits are self-reinforcing, and are really based off ideas of success and failure. If we fail to (and regret our failure to) carry out our habit, that is discouraging and actually makes it harder to keep up with the habit. The best way I have found to develop wanted habits is to never recognize failure in the habit. Always recognize success. You want to do something habitually, keep track of when you do it. Don't keep track in a way that lets you notice when you fail to do it. If you want to do something daily, don't mark on the calendar when you've done it, don't write the date that you did it the last time. Instead write down a simple tick each time you've done it. Increment a counter. Watch it go up. Say you want to start to wash your brontosaurus (named Rex) on a regular basis, say you never wash him currently. Start by washing Rex and mark a tick down. Then the next time you think about it, wash Rex, and mark a tick down. If you want to do it daily, the next time you think about it, consider whether you already washed him today. If you haven't, wash him, and put down a tick. Don't tally the ticks up. Don't look back to see how frequently you actually washed him every day. Don't get frustrated because for the past three weeks you washed him daily but last week you missed him three times in a row. When you worry about how well you are washing him, just think "Did I wash him today?" and then wash him if you didn't. You'll start washing him every day. Or you'll start to wash him every other day and be happy with it. Or you'll wash him from time to time. Think about the results instead. Do you have a brontosaurus that is sufficiently clean? If you do that's great, keep it up, whether you do it daily or monthly. Do you not? Then consider what else you could do besides cleaning him yourself to make him cleaner. Whatever you do, don't just get mad at yourself for not doing it and demand from yourself that you do it more often, and then promise yourself that you will. That won't work. You'll maybe do it for a bit and then burn out from frustration and failure. You can always do something like set a reminder if you don't think about it. But if you remember and avoid it, and then get angry with yourself for avoiding it (or rationalize your avoidance), you're doing the opposite of what is needed to make a habit. If you find you are avoiding it (Ah man, I'm too tired right now.) don't tell yourself you will make it up tomorrow. Don't get angry with yourself. Don't even acknowledge it. It's a habit, not a chore. It's something you want to do more frequently, not something you have to do. Acknowledge when you do complete it, not when you don't. As soon as you start to argue with yourself ("I should do this, but I don't want to") you're already losing the battle. Don't consider at that point what you should do. Just do it, or don't do it. Notice and feel good when you do it.
- jere 13y agoWhat a beautiful and appropriate photo.
- pkulak 13y agoAfter Barbara Ehrenreich got cancer and was thrust directly into the positive thinking movement, she wrote a really great book called "Bright-Sided".
- sliverstorm 13y agoMy path: "Hope for the best, plan for the worst"
- hermannj314 13y agoThat sounds like a much better definition of positive thinking. This article seemed to suggest that positive thinking means: "Plan for the best outcome and assume the worst will not happen." That is wishful thinking ('positive fantasies'). I don't think the two are the same thing at all.
- normloman 13y agoIf, by your definition, positive thinking includes preparing for the worst, how come whenever I bring up worst-case scenarios with my colleagues, they accuse me of being negative. I don't think most people share your definition.
- hermannj314 13y agoI respect that point of view. I have a simple mind and not a very strong vocabulary. I have no doubt that I am probably out-of-sync with popular opinion on this topic.
- awesomerobot 13y agoThat's not always what it means - but it's very often how the average person pushes it. As Barbara Ehrenreich points out in her book "Bright-Sided", insisting someone has to "think positively" isn't going to cure their cancer, and the refusal of some people to face the grim reality of certain situations is just absolutely idiotic.
- hcayless 13y agoJust what I was thinking. Thinking about how awesome something is going to be when I'm done with it just stalls me out. I have to think: what's broken now, and how do I fix it? Similarly, when it comes to exercise, I find I'm much more motivated by fear. I will tend to slack off if I don't have a goal, but if I enter a marathon, I'm constantly thinking about how much it will suck if I haven't trained enough, and I am motivated to get out of bed early and run, or run after a long day's work. I feel great after a run, but that's not what drives me. "Fear is the spur." As a good friend of mine once said :-).
- adventured 13y ago"in order to insure that you aren’t thinking about an unwanted idea, you have to continually turn your mind to that very idea. How do you know that you aren’t thinking of a white bear driving a red Ferrari unless you think about whether you’re thinking it?" I don't believe this is true at all. I'd argue the best way to stop thinking about something, is to divert your mental focus to other thing/s intentionally. Best way to stop thinking about your ex? Find a new boyfriend, dive deep into a work problem, find a new hobby to occupy your brain power, and so on. Want to insure you aren't thinking about something? Don't attempt to insure you're not thinking about it by thinking about it (a blatantly self-sabotaging concept). There's absolutely no need to constantly do mental reference checks to make sure you aren't thinking about the white bear in a red ferrari. In fact, that's the worst thing you can do. You can only focus on one thing at a time, and your brain is finite, as such it's not that difficult to saturate it and drown out competing thoughts. Given enough effort and time, the bear is banished from your short term memory and its emotional hold on you is dramatically lessened. After a while you then realize that it has in fact been a long time since you've thought about the bear, and you realize said bear's hold over you is no more. All accomplished without constantly thinking about whether you're thinking about the bear.
- nitrogen 13y agoI'd argue the best way to stop thinking about something, is to divert your mental focus to other thing/s intentionally. I seem to recall reading on Ars Technica a summary of a study that found that, in a controlled experiment, those who tried to stop thinking about something by directly shutting it down were more successful than those who tried to replace the thought with a different thought.
- diydsp 13y agoYes, the author cherry picks numerous inept counterexamples like the one you cite and this one: “Ceaseless optimism about the future only makes for a greater shock when things go wrong;" This is utter pessimism. I feel sorry for people who are on board with it. In my experience, the gains garnished from being super optimistic and taking chances have been much greater than had I sat around on the couch not trying. I never achieve up to the level of my goals and imagination - but that's because I continuously push them higher and higher. Instead, I aim for Alpha Centauri and land on the moon. I should also add that the emotion of _curiosity_ is a very powerful one for me. When I imagine the future, and I _don't know_ what something will be like, the curiosity is a very powerful motivator for me to at least try it out.
- benched 13y agoThis is quite an issue in my life. Believing and practicing positive thinking seems like such a self-evident, unquestionably good thing. Especially among a certain class of people, it's almost never popular or ... I don't know - "socially tenable" to challenge this. But I can't help but challenge it. Because to me, it just looks like a nervous tic. In fact, it looks like a stubborn, neurotic horse that insists on only turning to the right. It looks compulsive, and subtly fear-driven. In conversation, it's a non-stop, predictable and inescapable barrage of "Yeah, but", "Well, on the bright side", "Hey, at least" - and no matter what I say, they won't stop returning like it's tennis and they're scrambling all over the court to stop the ball going out of bounds by any means. And the people who do this are as offended by my view of the world as if I spilled shit on their white suit. I'm biased, but I don't see myself as overly negative. The way I see it, I just don't go out of my way to see the bright side, or try in a motivated way to hit positive notes while conversing. I don't feel motivated to be negative, either. But this sure as hell makes me the most negative person I know, by default. To me, I just can't have a view of the world other than the view I have; and I can't speak things other than what I think and see. From the other side, for myself, I have been guilty of the same thing in the past. But since I became more aware of it, I now try, when someone talks about bad luck or unpleasantness in the world, to listen and nod, rather than allow my larynx to reflexively spasm into a positive platitude. No, I am not fun at parties. Not to worry - I don't go to them. Also, yeah I think criticizing positive thinking in general, and The Secret in particular, both in the same short article, is pretty sloppy.
- Florin_Andrei 13y ago> it's a non-stop, predictably and inescapable barrage of "Yeah, but", "Well, on the bright side", "Hey, at least" In moderate dosage, it is useful to blunt negativity and hopelessness, which can also cause failure. But use too much of it, and you're lost in la-la-land. As they say, it's all in the dosage... I think the positive thinking method would get a lot better if it focused less on the outcome, and more on the process. Don't focus on having the great job and enjoying it, focus on the qualities that it takes to get there.
- benched 13y ago
- diydsp 13y ago> I asked Kappes why fantasies hamper progress, and she told me that they dull the will to succeed: “Imagining a positive outcome conveys the sense that you’re approaching your goals, which takes the edge off the need to achieve.” This is a massive oversimplification. I know many, many people, including myself, for whom imagining positive outcomes feeds a chain reaction of emotion and motivation which drives us to try things within and beyond our reach and ultimately to come out on top even in the face of numerous failures. Of course, as posters like theorique point out, it is not enough to merely fantasize. The positive fantasizing must, and will, motivate one to build successful habits. It is not enough to distract ones' self with a utopian mirage. It is necessary to include details and additional questions in the fantasy, such as "back from the future thinking." e.g. "Ok, my startup is successful, who are my customers? Who are they servicing? Which features of what I'm doing/did got me there?" And I believe doomsayers like the authors of this paper and this article know it damn well. There's just a more comfortable place for them in the larger cultural climate to negatively criticize the author of The Secret than there is in clarifying it. For the authors of the paper, there is more academic capital in running a "computerized content analysis" than there is to actually produce any results that help anyone. Furthermore the abstract of the Oettingen paper suggests serious misunderstandings of finance (1. Just b/c DJIA goes down doesn't mean the economy is bad. 2. The measurements were made during a financial crisis) and correlation vs. causation. So, fuck this article! Go out and do something awesome and visualize the shit out of it!!!!!!
- scott_s 13y agoSince you think that the research that investigates the effectiveness of positive thinking (such as this one: http://www.psych.nyu.edu/oettingen/Barry%20Kappes,%20H.,%20&%20Oettingen,%20G.%20%282011%29.%20JESP.pdf http://www.psych.nyu.edu/oettingen/Barry%20Kappes,%20H.,%20&..., linked from the article) has a methodological defect, how would you design an experiment so that we could correct for the problem? That is, your point is that the research conducted over-simplified the technique. If I understand your point, "thinking positively" is not enough; the subjects in the experiment did one step, but not the others that you think are required. So how do you design an experiment where thinking positively necessarily motivates "one to build successful habits"?
- 13y ago
- Jun8 13y agoFrom (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Stockdale http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Stockdale) When [...] asked who didn't make it out of Vietnam, Stockdale replied: Oh, that's easy, the optimists. Oh, they were the ones who said, 'We're going to be out by Christmas.' And Christmas would come, and Christmas would go. Then they'd say, 'We're going to be out by Easter.' And Easter would come, and Easter would go. And then Thanksgiving, and then it would be Christmas again. And they died of a broken heart." Stockdale then added: This is a very important lesson. You must never confuse faith that you will prevail in the end—which you can never afford to lose—with the discipline to confront the most brutal facts of your current reality, whatever they might be.
- irremediable 13y agoOn the other hand, I've heard Holocaust survivors tell me their optimism was what allowed them to survive. I don't think these witty sayings prove anything.
- dfraser992 13y agoWas it really optimism or rather the ability to find meaning within the experience? I ask because one of the top 10 books I've ever read is Viktor Frankl's "Man's Search for Meaning". He survived the death camps and figured out how he and others did so. Compared to it, _The Secret_ is revealed to be a shallow mindless "gimme, I'm entitled" attitude towards life where hard work is deemed unnecessary - i.e. reality is nothing but a psychological construct and you can manipulate it with merely your will. In others words, an excuse for airheads to indulge their inner two year old. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Frankl http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Frankl "optimistic outlook" vs "optimistic thinking" is far better, IMO
- keithpeter 13y agoThanks for this reference. The 'Statue of Responsibility' strikes me as a useful monument to build in many countries of the first world.
- 13y ago
- hosh 13y agoThe thing that's not made explicit about "positive thinking" is that: (1) It is not enough to think positively. You actually have to change how you feel. If you are out of touch with your feelings, then no amount of positive thinking will change anything. (2) In order to be in touch with how you feel, you first have to tune into how you feel right now -- whether that is "good" or "bad". Then accept it for what it is now. It's only after that, that change happens.
- WalterBright 13y agoYou have to back up the positive thinking with action, of course.
- scotty79 13y agoBacking up negative (or neutral) thinking with action happens more often or to the better result, studies seem to suggest.
- WalterBright 13y agoThe kind of negative thinking that leads inevitably to failure is the "I can't do that, so I might as well not even try." I don't regard making contingency plans for worst case results as negative thinking.
- scotty79 13y agoSoulcrushing "I can't do that" is depression (which is just faulty brain chemistry), not negative thinking in my book. Resonable "I can't do that" (because obese people don't jump 4ft high) is negative thinking but can be quite resonable and motivating to find another way. On the other hand blind "I can do that!" is still called positive thinking even if it's pure delusion that leads to disaster.
- alecco 13y agoThe TED talk "Smile or Die" explains problems arising when positivity is used as corporate or government policy. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5um8QWWRvo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5um8QWWRvo
- scotty79 13y agoNegative thinking seems to help me the most. If I'm afraid of something in the future I tend to obsess about it. The correct way for me to get free from this is to imagine the worst possible scenario that I can, as it already happened and think what's next. Then it appears to be not that bad. This helps me to calm down and actually take some reasonable actions that always prevented the worst case scenario and lot of not the worst but bad ones.
- manmal 13y agoNot the way to go if you have real anxiety. You will start to imagine you can contract Aids when using a public toilet.
- babyturtle 13y agoOne way to deal with anxiety is to flood your system with it.. habituate to it.. and you will stop caring and harden your shell. We are way to soft these days.
- scotty79 13y agoStill, imagining that I already got it and what should I do now would help me to accept the risk.
- gesman 13y agoHere's how things tends to work: Beliefs -> Emotions -> Thoughts -> Actions. So trying to force positive thoughts on top of negative beliefs will last as long as that exercise. When you "forget" to think positively - you get back to the default polarity of beliefs. So to make the change positive and lasting the beliefs needs to be addressed either directly or via associated emotions.
- babyturtle 13y agousually its actually emotion -> beliefs
- saraid216 13y agoUsually it's actually Beliefs <-> Emotions Beliefs <-> Thoughts Beliefs <-> Actions Emotions <-> Thoughts Emotions <-> Actions Thoughts <-> Actions
- babyturtle 13y agoThis is a messy, tricky subject, with many exceptions to these simplistic rules... but I think its mostly emotion->belief. Our primal reptilian brain reacts to things faster than our conscious brain does. People (almost always) choose/rationalize their beliefs by the emotions they get from them. Smokers believe it will kill them, but their emotions over ride the belief, with the new belief that "I like it" Religious people "believe" because: parent approval - good feeling heaven - good feeling rejecting belief -> ostracism - bad feeling How many people actually "believe" they are going to hell? No one ... because it unimaginably bad to entertain the idea for a second. Try to imagine youve got amnesia and your belief system is wiped... do you stop feeling emotion? (you might if you dont recognize your wife etc... but you will soon believe she is your wife by the emotions you get from her) Try to imagine you have no emotion except a baseline dull neutrality.. how does this effect your beliefs? (youd stop believing in anything because theres no reward/punishment to, you'd become ambivalent to everything)
- zeidrich 13y agoThe article conflates thinking positively with hubris or denial. Positive thinking, in my view, is more about saying "What do I need to do make this happen." instead of saying "I will never be able to make this happen." This article seems to use a destructive type of thought that is more like "This will happen to me!" "Gabriele Oettingen and Doris Mayer asked eighty-three German students to rate the extent to which they “experienced positive thoughts, images, or fantasies on the subject of transition into work life, graduating from university, looking for and finding a job." I agree that simply imagining things simply working out for you can be damaging. But I think that there's something like positive thinking that doesn't include baseless fantasizing. To think "I get an interview from 1/3 of the applications I send out, and I might be hired for 1/5 of the positions I apply for, so if I make sure I am applying, I will likely find a job" is reasonably positive thinking, but it's more constructive than thinking "Ah, I'm awesome, there's a job I want, and I'm certain they will hire me because I'm thinking positively. I won't bother applying elsewhere, I'm special, they'll need to take me" and then falling into a depression when you don't even get invited for an interview. On the other hand, both of those situations are better than sitting at home and thinking "I'm never going to get a job anyways, I might as well not apply". To me positive thinking is about looking at all of the angles, not being afraid to see where things go differently, but still have a positive outlook. "If I do this, there's a 25% chance it will fail. If it fails, I will lose my money, if it succeeds I will make 200 times what I invested. I have enough set aside to try this 10 times. It's worth doing it, and I wont ruin myself if it doesn't work out." It's that sort of thinking that shows that failure isn't bad, it's just a possibility. Recognizing that and planning to make the best of both the bad situation and the good situation is positive thinking. Thinking "I'm going to start this business, I'm going to throw everything I have at it, but I'm going to pay myself a fair salary and save. When I succeed, I will be rich. When I fail, I'll be in a comfortable position to start again. Life is good." is positive. Thinking "I'm going to start this business and throw everything I have into it, and if it starts to look bad, I'm going to throw even more into it until I'm a hollow shell of a man who can't live with the idea that I could fail" is ignorant. Wishful thinking, but there's a difference between thinking positively and being ignorant of the circumstances.
- tokipin 13y ago
- nickthemagicman 13y agoMac: Yeah. The Secret is a self-help book that Dee read and explained to us. It’s about how you can get whatever you want without having to work for it. Dennis: Yeah, man, all you have to do is envision all the shit in the world that you want, cut pictures of it out and paste it on a board. Then you get it, you get the stuff!
- jasey 13y agoShameless plug. We developed a smartphone app at http://positivethinking.net http://positivethinking.net to solve this problem. I don't doubt ideology like The Secret does more harm than good, that's why our tagline is YOUR SUCCESS STARTS WITH A POSITIVE MINDSET. Because being optimistic and hopeful is only a small part to being successful, it's only the start, actually practicing and working towards your goals is the other 90-95%. The way we try to help is by motivating and inspiring you consistently to reach your goals. For example if you want to be successful at business we will send you insightful quotes from the likes of Richard Branson and Steve jobs daily. If you want to be fit and healthy we have things like "success trains, failure complains" and "to cold, to busy, to tired. NO EXCUSES, TRAIN EVERYDAY". Being reminded daily of these things has helped changed my thoughts. Ps, I'm not sure if calling my app "positive thinking" was a great idea because it often gets lumped with the lazy wish-and-the-universe-will-provide ideology but it was purely a SEO move. I would love peoples thoughts on all of this!
- anythingis 13y agoThe secret defiantly does more harm than good...Ive meet crazies the believe they can cure their sickness with their thoughts
- elwell 13y agoPossibly relevant Bible verse: "Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours." Mark 11:24 Ancillary to that: "When you ask, you do not receive, because you ask with wrong motives, that you may spend what you get on your pleasures." James 4:3
- zackmorris 13y agoAm I the only one who becomes demoralized by positive thinking, precisely because if it worked it would mean that I have some metaphysical effect on reality? That can be a scary notion, when you really stop and think about it, that we have the power to reshape the world around us just by thinking about it. Having been down in some dark pits of despair, I can honestly say that "The Secret" had a profound effect on my life. I don't mean in a subtle way. It was more black and white: one day I was depressed, poor, and lonely, and then I saw The Secret and started acting more on instinct, the way humans might have thousands of years ago before they were institutionalized. My theory about how it works is the same as when you look at geese flying in the sky in January and it’s 10 degrees outside, and wonder how in the heck they are not starving or freezing to death. “The secret” is that they are simply acting in harmony with the reality that brought them into existence, not fighting it every step of the way or dwelling on how things “should be”. Modern concepts like scarcity, power, success, money, etc are insidious forms of mind control because they frame reality in a way that traps people. Children don’t normally suffer from maladies related to these things, because they are oblivious to them. Now how come adults dwell on them so much? I think it’s because they are so busy working hard to earn a living or provide for their children that they put subsistence at the top of their priorities. But life’s a game, we’re all going to croak at some point anyway. The truth is that whichever culture you are in, at whatever level of affluence, has a strong incentive to keep you right where you’re at. You could stop trying, go on autopilot and spend your time daydreaming, and.. nothing happens. You just continue on your present course. You start noticing how outside forces step in and solve problems that you used to be micromanaging. You start to notice coincidences and miracles, or even the emotional fabric that holds society together, the way that people rely on each other. And your subconscious comes to the forefront and brings opportunities to your attention that you couldn’t see before, so you can act on them and create tangible changes in your life. To me, that’s the most powerful lesson from The Secret. To let go, realize it’s all just details, and experience the act of living without constantly trying to validate it. Then the natural laws come back into play and thriving is a likely outcome. Anyway, that’s the tip of the iceberg, if anyone is feeling a little off lately, or having a sense that its “me against the world” or “me against god” or “everything is hanging by a thread”, basically anything along those lines, I highly recommend looking into group meditation. I started with something called The Reconnection, or Reconnective Healing, because a good friend of mine is into it. It’s just a tool among many to quiet the mind and let the subconscious come forward. I still think it’s kind of eerie when I think about something and the universe changes to reflect my interests, but I don’t necessarily think it’s supernatural. It could have something to do with the way we store memories or some physical process like that. I’m not really sure, I just know that the effect is real because as soon as I started trying it, there were too many unexplained coincidences to happen by chance. I think it’s loosely related to how faiths become prevalent. It’s not due to the specifics of any religion, but the notion that belief in itself creates outcomes. It’s sad and ironic that so often, capable people write it off because science has no explanation for it (yet). But would knowing the mathematics behind it, say like psychology or economics, help us incorporate it more readily? I’m not so sure. If you took any kid and told him or her that the universe is governed by strict laws, there is no deeper meaning to any of it, or even free will, then depression is a likely outcome. I know it happened to me, and I wore my depression like some kind of badge of honor, like I had it all figured out, when I really didn’t. I still feel depressed from time to time like anyone else, but I actually use that as a signal now that I’m holding on too tightly, and take some time for myself to stare at the stars, or go into the wilderness, or do something that’s not governed by man-made laws, and then MIRACULOUSLY, I feel better.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- NerdfaceKillah 13y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WbS9jZOlQjc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WbS9jZOlQjc Just saying.