7 ms·
When Debtors Decide to Default
- shizcakes 17y agoThis article is severely lacking in a discussion of consequences. Publishing an article like this, given the average intelligence level of Americans these days, is irresponsible. I have debts to repay (student loans!), and the idea of "just not paying" is very charming, but there are real consequences for these actions. It's not something to be done lightly or 'because I want to'.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- transburgh 17y agoThe are trying to drive you nuts till they get their money. Really, if you get 6-7 calls a day you just want it to stop.
- mclin 17y agoThey should just get a phone where you can set unknown numbers to have a silent ring tone.
- noelchurchill 17y agoGet a Google Voice number.
- jsares 17y agoThe difference with Student Loans is you can't just avoid paying them. With most debt you can discharge it through a bankruptcy but since 1998 you can no longer discharge student loans unless it would be an "undue hardship". After you default they will simply attach your wages for up to 25% of you after tax salary.
- pmichaud 17y agoPeople don't do it lightly, they do it because they are desperate and realistically the only consequence they really face is a crappy credit score. They are okay with that... many already have tanked credit before they start this.
- rdtsc 17y agoOnce millions of people have bad credit scores and bankruptcies in their credit histories, the social stigma of a bad creditor gets diluted. That becomes a self-reinforcing process. The more individuals default, the less defaulting looks bad. I believe that it was social and moral norms rather than clear cut financial analyses that stopped people from defaulting. It seems those moral norms have changed. People have simply lost faith in the system. They don't care about being nice little creditors, wrought by guilt if they overspent or made bad financial decisions, when the government is handing out hundreds of billions to to-big-to-fail banks. Then as if mocking everyone, banks go ahead and hand out tens of millions as bonuses to their CEOs. I cannot see anyone watching this circus feeling too guilty about screwing up and then not paying back $10000. Everyone, wants a bailout.
- johnrob 17y agoThe big winners are the businesses that sold products to these consumers. The losers are the banks and consumers themselves.
- jsdalton 17y agoI think the biggest losers are actually "the rest of us": i.e. those of us who neither borrowed more than we could afford to pay back nor lent to those whom we knew could not afford to pay us back. There aren't many bailouts or special government programs (at least that I'm aware of) for people who acted responsibly in the midst of what was obviously foolishness.
- stuffthatmatter 17y agoI am so glad I barely pay any taxes anymore (income and spending)
- jrockway 17y agoIndeed. I feel very screwed over by all of this. Making the wrong decisions got people lots of free money. Making the right decisions got me nothing, except interest on my savings account is now so low that it barely makes up inflation. (It was nearly 5% before all this!) All these people that don't pay off their credit cards ensure that those who do get higher interest rates and fewer services. Thanks a lot, guys...
- mainguy 17y agoThat doesn't make sense. The banks make money off people who carry a balance.
- jrockway 17y agoThey don't make much money off people that rack up $25,000 of debt and then refuse to pay, or people that borrow $500,000 for a house that's worth $150,000 who then leave and stop paying the mortgage. People that pay the minimum payment on their credit card every month are great -- if everyone did that, there would be no credit crisis. I would be getting my 5% on savings, and would probably be able to own a house.
- krschultz 17y agoThe reason why Bank of America (or any lender) jacks the interest rate up on people failing to pay is quite obvious - people will pay off the most expensive debt first and then work there way down to the low interest rate stuff. By positioning themselves as the highest interest rate, that lender gets paid first. But that makes the debtor more likely to simply default because the interest is killing any hope they had of escaping. Add in multiple lenders all trying to play the same game and it is no wonder so many are simply unable to get out of debt. It would be nice if lenders really stopped giving loans and credit cards to these people in the future, but I think plenty of people will default and in 5 years be back on new credit cards and new mortgages that some will end up defaulting on again.
- lurkinggrue 17y agoOr they go though it once and opt out of the system after that and live on cash. I know many people now that refuse to have a credit card as they became far too expensive in the long run.
- elecengin 17y ago"With all the bailouts the government is giving everyone, no one has any personal accountability about their own debts." So true. The sanctity of an obligation, as the article discusses, was destroyed when the government ruled one side of the obligation less sacrosanct than the other. Is that an excuse for lenders to run away from their problems? Absolutely not. It is no more valid than the child's argument "he/she did it first!"
- donw 17y agoNot quite -- the money for the bailouts comes directly out of the taxpayers' pockets, in the form of taxes. So debtors, who are nominally also taxpayers, are effectively having to pay these companies twice. Once, because of their own poor decisions, and again, because of the lending companies' poor decisions. In this case, I think that not paying is more a form of civil disobedience, Thomas Payne style, than anything else.
- stuffthatmatter 17y agoI didn't feel like working so that my neighbor can walk away from their mortgage and my relatives can walk away from their credit card debt. So I don't anymore.
- ubernostrum 17y agoI didn't come here to see mindless talking points parroted back at me. If you want to actually talk about the complexities of debt and the problems on all sides of the issue, by all means do so. If you want to shout slogans, please go somewhere else.
- stuffthatmatter 17y agoIt's really not that complicated. People are walking away from debt obligations. - mortgages (12% of all mortgage, 50% subprime, 50% options) - credit cards (13% default) - personal bankruptcies (up 28% in second quarter) federal/states/local governments are walking away from debt obligation - pension reduction - massive printing of dollar, $250B treasury selling this week Companies are walking away from debt obligation - commercial mortgages delinquency up 586% this half - pension discharged by bankruptcy Guess who's paying for this. That's right; the taxpayers. So. Are you the sucker that's gonna keep on paying taxes? All these you can google yourself (too many links to list here) I didn't come here to list all the bad things, since I doubt you even comprehend 1% of the atrocities. Therefore, I kept it simple for you.
- snorkel 17y ago25% interest rate should not even legal in the first place. Do banks offer consumers 25% on savings interest? Not even close.
- philwelch 17y agoAt that point, the credit becomes a risky investment--a significant percentage of people paying 25% interest will never repay their debts. If there isn't any return on the ones that do, then these people will just get outright blacklisted from credit. (Maybe that's a good thing.) If you bought junk bonds backed by high-interest consumer debt, you'd get a high interest rate too. Unless you got nothing. But you're probably a safer investor than Bank of America. It's also a bargaining tactic for when these people finally wisen up and renegotiate their debts through a consolidation agency.
- joshfinnie 17y agoI agree, there should be a set limit that people can charge. It can be fixed to the fed's rate, but no more than 10%. There is no reason I should be making 0.0025% on my savings but being charges 19.5% on my credit.
- chollida1 17y ago> There is no reason I should be making 0.0025% on my savings but being charges 19.5% on my credit. Technically there is a good reason. You make so little interest on your savings because you are lending money to the bank, which means due to the banks credit rating and CIDC insurance that you are very unlikely to loose your money. When the bank loans money to you via your credit card, they are taking a much much larger gamble. If you go bankrupt there is no CDIC insurance to protect them and give them their money back. Hence the higher interest rate. How big should the spread be? That's an entirely different question:) The
- jrockway 17y agoNobody is forcing you to pay 19.5% interest. My rate is lower than that, but I never carry a balance, making my rate 0 (but with all the conveniences of a credit card). If I overspend, which sometimes happens, then I pay for it out of savings. That money is doing anything for me (1.5% interest, or whatever), so I might as well pay off the credit card with it.
- RobGR 17y agoI hope that society developes a different view of debt and consumer debt in particular through all this. One thing to note, is that either the paying off or writing off of debt is deflationary -- something that was an asset on someone's books, either simply vanishes, or else is replaced by money that was extracted from the economy.
- tophat02 17y agoWhy not lend only to people who have already shown that they can handle money? In other words, why not mandate large annual fees for credit cards and VERY high down payment requirements for mortgages? And yes, in fact, I AM suggesting that we only loan money to people who already have some.
- nradov 17y agoDuring the Great Depression there was significant public sympathy for bank robbers as the banks were seen as having taken advantage of common people. I hope we're not headed for a similar breakdown in social order. Intentionally defaulting on a debt is one thing, but sticking a gun in a teller's face is something else altogether.