6 ms·
The sky is not falling: [External Blues: Google Has Brought Big Changes To SD Cards In KitKat, And Even Samsung Is Implementing Them]: http://www.androidpolice
by bryanlarsen 13y ago
The sky is not falling: [External Blues: Google Has Brought Big Changes To SD Cards In KitKat, And Even Samsung Is Implementing Them]: http://www.androidpolice.com/2014/02/17/external-blues-google-has-brought-big-changes-to-sd-cards-in-kitkat-and-even-samsung-may-be-implementing-them/ http://www.androidpolice.com/2014/02/17/external-blues-googl...
Summary:
All apps (even ones without external storage permissions) can now read and write from a designated private folder on external storage.
There's a new sharing framework called the Storage Access Framework that can be used to request access to other folders, which treats external storage in a manner similar to cloud storage.
It might be a harsh transition, but not completely surprising since it's been quite a while since Nexus devices have had external storage slots, and it's been quite obvious for a while that Google has been discouraging external storage.
The hopeful takeaway is that Google will be relaxing this discouragement now that they've figured out a strategy for external storage moving forward.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gcb0 13y ago1. launch all flagship phones without sd slot to force use of gdrive 2. everyone buys other companies (budget?) phones because they have more features (eg sd card slot) 3. break that in software (because they can) so that feature is not "missing" on the flagships anymore. 4. instead of just removing, make the functionality be yet another entry point to gdrive by making the sd write api be analogous to the cloud write one. google only fear to not fuck up like that was something like cyanogenmod, but, well...
- samstave 13y agoAt this point in my life; I am ready to challenge any design team of any mobile device which decides to leave out expandable [micro]SD storage to a bout of the fisticuffs. There is absolutely NO reason any mobile device should lack this. [This is ESPECIALLY aimed at Mr. Smug; Ive]
- sitkack 13y agoHow else would they up sell to the 64GB model? What if a device I bought 3 years ago could be still relevant by just upgrading an inexpensive flash card? Not only is so restrictive as to be insulting, it harms the environment by forcing devices to die a premature death, I know my iPad 1 would be a whole lot more useful with a 64GB SDHC card in it. I was super stoked to buy a Google Nexus tablet, after finding out there was no SD card slot, I forever declined that purchase.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI have a Galaxy Nexus that is barely supported by Google now, and its just a little over 2 years old. Going to recycle it and buy a Nexus 5. I'm just a bit too old (31) to care anymore. No SD card? Whatevs. I'll use Dropbox/Evernote/Amazon's MP3 Player with wifi to get whatever I need onto the phone.
- gcb0 13y agosadly, you are probably the norm nowadays. a shame.
- gcb0 13y agoHear hear. I'm still using a nexus One. ONE. now, had i been using stock image on that device... first it would be full of crapware that i couldn't uninstal. and since the available space is something like 250mb for apps, i wouldn't even be able to install 2 apps. now, i've spent $500 on it. why should i already replace it if it does exactly what I need? just so i can have NFC? ha! no SD? ha! even less, non replaceable, battery life? ha! (i use an extended SEIDIO battery). no trackball with extremely visible and customizable full color alert led? ha! the only thing it misses is a better screen some time. but i like the size, so i won't be switching to a fullHD phone with a phablet screen size. to fix it. Also the OLED screen is awesome to read at night. Ironically because of software, by features REMOVED on android after 2.3. on 2.3 on my custom roms i can have smart inverted colors in the browser. I don't have to choose between white on black pages with inverted images or bright pages with correct color images. i can have both! Also i can enable night mode render effects. Good lucky doing any of that on your shinny nexus 5.
- magicalist 13y agoOn the contrary, the Storage Access Framework is an awesome development and how Google should integrate more of its play services: by having a provider agnostic API that fits their service as well as any other. Anyone can be a SAF file provider by implementing the interface, and it's as easy as Intents to switch between them. It's silly to have "external" storage with special behavior at this point. Storage should act like storage, and apps should access that data consistently, without users having to remember which storage they're using for any particular purpose. https://developer.android.com/guide/topics/providers/document-provider.html https://developer.android.com/guide/topics/providers/documen...
- x0054 13y agoHowever, this new infrastructure precludes file management apps.
- bdonlan 13y agoI don't see why you couldn't have a file management app that uses the new storage access framework to access external storage in the same way as online or internal storage - shouldn't it just be a matter of switching to the new API?
- radley 13y agoThere's no write in the new API. Only read: "The SAF makes it simple for users to browse and open documents, images, and other files across all of their their preferred document storage providers."
- tadfisher 13y agoThat's not true, you can ask any DocumentsProvider to delete or edit a file resource given a valid URI. Whether or not the DocumentsProvider that owns the resource will acknowledge your request is up to the DocumentsProvider.
- tadfisher 13y ago
- radley 13y agoThis may make sense for sensitive data, but it's a massive attack on independent media players. Can't write, edit, or move files. No downloads. No music sync. No file renaming. No editing of mp3 metadata. Only walled gardens allowed on the new Android "open" platform.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoFile managers may be out, but photo apps might be OK: they just need to somehow request full access to /DCIM through this new API (which I have not looked at). music & video players may be more awkward but possibly doable.
- wslh 13y agoSo moving from Android to iOS will be less painful in the near future. I think traversing the whole filesystem and adding a big SD Card are key features in Android devices. If Apple launches a device with a bigger display they will eat part of the Android ecosystem.
- stock_toaster 13y agoor if/when amazon releases a phone based on their android fork..
- wslh 13y agoAt the end I would prefer to run a full desktop operating system with a mobile UI in the device.
- matt_heimer 13y agoSure they can, just not the MP3s that belong to another application. Each application can put its own private data on the external storage. Most of the people here don't get how scary external storage was with Android. Every time you install an app with the android.permission.WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE permission you have to worry about what it will do to every other applications data. Some apps (like file managers) need this but letting every app that wants to write data to external storage have the ability to trash every other apps data is just crazy. The private app directories on external storage is a MUCH better approach. And if you want to install apps that can trash other apps then I'm okay with needing root for that.
- JohnTHaller 13y agoAnd how you know this is a bullshit play to mess with SD cards specifically is right here: >With WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE, they also have: > - Read and write for any public folder on the primary (built-in) storage > - Read (not write) for any public folder on the secondary (SD card) storage If this were really about security, why does the built-in storage let you write everywhere but the sd card not? It's not about security. It's about forcing you into the cloud. And there are a ton of reasons not to (privacy, financial aka bandwidth, lack of access on subways and similar, etc). With every release, Android is less and less of an operating system that I recommend to friends and family. Openness and expandability were some of the key selling points and they're both going bye bye.