4 ms·
This is a very simple argument. Given fixed inputs, produce a testable, repeatable output. It has nothing to do with peer reviews, political committees, cited
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
This is a very simple argument.
Given fixed inputs, produce a testable, repeatable output.
It has nothing to do with peer reviews, political committees, cited papers, consensus or any of that. Nice try, but no banana.
So predict the worldwide temp in the year 2029. We'll wait around and see if that prediction holds true. As far as I know, nobody has yet been able to actually forecast climate and validate it. It's just all arm-waving and hysteria. That may pass as science for you, but it doesn't work for a lot of other people. Their position, which is mine, is that unless science is falsifiable, it's not science, no matter how much you gussy it up with anything else.
It doesn't even have to do on whether mankind is changing the climate -- that's a whole nother can of worms. Along with whether and how much we should do about it if we are. Or the role of science in politics (hint: both will have a corrupting influence on the other) Or the question of what the perfect climate should be, or how fast it should change. This is just about whether or not you talk about global warming with the confidence as you do gravity, integrals, or electromagnetism.
- robg 17y agoThe globe does seem to be warming. I agree that the ultimate cause may be impossible to nail down in the same way that testable scientific theories have been. Still, given the warming globe, and the strong possibility that man is somewhat to blame (see the correlation between industrialization and climate change), isn't the risk of doing nothing far greater than the risk of trying to do something? In the former, we end up with unpredictable changes to the planet. In the latter, we might still end up with those changes, but at least funding has been invested in trying to understand and ameliorate them. For me, then, it's not about deniers or supporters. It's about making determinations for behaviors today based on the best possible evidence. That doesn't mean the evidence adds up to Truth. It just means that we take it seriously enough to understand the problem space. If we're wrong, we've lost, maybe, one year of defense funding as the Arctic freezes more fully in 100 years. If we're right, then maybe we got a head start on the order of twenty or thirty years. My point is: Why wait? Scientists will adjust if they're wrong. And we'll adjust if they're right. Isn't it better to keep collecting data especially while we try to change human behavior?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI hear this one a lot -- why wait? Also the cousin: if there is such a huge possible downside, shouldn't we do something? I guess I'd have to say "no". There are so many problems I have with this -- even assuming we're changing the climate -- that it's difficult to know where to begin. First, is there some badness that is going to happen in the next 20 or 30 years? Or are we talking about 60+ years? Because if people seriously think they know anything about what the next century is going to look like, they're smoking crack. We could all end up as smoking radioactive rubble, in which case a couple degrees of warming would be the least of our risks. There is simply no way to compare various scenarios, likelihoods, and risk exposures to make an intelligent guess about things so far off in the future. It has nothing to do with "this won't effect me, so I don't care" -- although that's a perfectly natural point of view too. It's simply that freaking anything could happen in a hundred years. To sit around and worry about a few degrees temperature change leads me to believe a lot of people don't have anything better to do with their time. That's the thing: without hard numbers this is a religious discussion -- a discussion about how most people "feel" about what's happening. I just don't "feel" the danger is anywhere near the level of being worried or changing the way our economies work. To me that sounds like crazy talk based on fear-mongering. It reminds me of every other religious movement I've seen -- mankind has sinned, we will pay the price, we must change our ways, punishment may come anyway, etc. I'm sorry. Given the archaeological climate data, the current state of the models, and the distant future impact, it just doesn't seem very rational to me to be that concerned about it. That doesn't mean I'm not open to compromise. Heck -- build a few thousand nuclear reactors over the next 20 years. It'll make the air cleaner, reduce our dependence on fossil fuels, and make the greenhouse gas people happy. There's lots of room for working together, even with different worldviews.
- robg 17y agoThere are numbers. They may be too correlational for your liking, but there is significant data. I think you have to be careful here. Saying the data are inconclusive, because controlled tests are difficult if not impossible, is one thing. But dismissing the data embraces the same fanaticism that you seem uncomfortable with. Science demands skeptics but deniers get thrown out of the tent. The difference might seem like a religious dispute but it really comes down to productive criticism versus unproductive needling. The emotion probably comes from seeing something that seemed permanent, like permafrost and Arctic ice, melting away. Humans don't tend to like instability. And instability on a global scale is a relatively new phenomenon. Sunspots might be the next worry but what could we possibly do about that? It's an interesting point on the cycle of religious movements (and it reminds me of deathbed confessions - what do you have to lose?). But what's an alternative explanation for rising temperatures? That's science. There's an existing and prevailing hypothesis that attempts to explain that data. You need another hypothesis that explains the data just as well. It could be that the Earth is simply repeating normal warming trends. The problem is, that's not a testable hypothesis. There is no experiment that could reject that hypothesis. By contrast, if man is playing some role, then if we change our behaviors we should see a change in temperatures. If we see some reduction in global temperatures coincident with climate change interventions, that's another data point in favor of the hypothesis that man has some role to play. To me, that's another clear reason to pump research dollars into the problem. And sure, nuclear plants should be a part of the solution. My point on not waiting is what can be gained by running interventions. Sure, it might be a wasted effort, but either way you gain knowledge you didn't have previously from simple observation. I really don't know what the alternative is. The planet appears to be changing. We're unsure of the cause - some more so than others. What's the problem with trying to figure out things through the scientific method? Wasted resources? Unnecessary hysteria? So what? Research and development is like insurance. You may not need it, but if you do, you'll be happy you put in the effort years ahead of time.
- timr 17y agoThat is, indeed, a simplistic argument. Unfortunately, it has absolutely nothing to do with anything I've said here. I have not -- and would not -- suggest that science is a matter of consensus. The IPCC is relevant only in that it acts as an excellent, public summary of the scientific knowledge on global warming. It's a review article, not a popularity contest. Your comment is only interesting in that you have, once again, used a favorite rhetorical tool of the pseudo-scientific debater: a faulty redefinition of "science". By your standards, a scientific experiment must: "Given fixed inputs, produce a testable, repeatable output." which is supposed to imply that global warming can't be science, since we can't predict the weather next Wednesday, let alone a random Wednesday in 2030. Unfortunately, while this line of faulty reasoning is superficially appealing to those untrained in scientific thinking, this definition excludes 99.9% of all scientific research done today. We can't evolve a complex organism in the lab -- yet we know that it happens in nature. We can't grow a human in a dish -- yet we've been able to do a huge amount of research into human embryonic development. We can't do repeatable experiments with nearly any human genetic disease -- yet here we are, making measurable scientific progress year over year in nearly every field that touches human genetic medicine. A scientific theory needs to produce a testable hypothesis, nothing more. The experiment doesn't have to be practical on any particular time-frame. And since you've (rather conveniently) provided a experiment for any theory related to global warming, you've refuted your own straw-man attack. Global warming theory is quite obviously within the domain of "science". It is patently absurd to suggest otherwise.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThe IPCC is relevant only in that it acts as an excellent, public summary of the scientific knowledge on global warming. It's a review article, not a popularity contest. It's not a review article, it's a political statement put out by a political organization in order to effect political change. Read some of the dissenting opinions. which is supposed to imply that global warming can't be science, since we can't predict the weather next Wednesday, let alone a random Wednesday in 2030. Sometimes I think you're just talking to yourself, timr. Nobody is talking about the weather. Pick any inputs, predict any outputs. Take projected levels of greenhouses gases in the atmosphere (what are those, anyway?) and predict average global temperature. Take solar input and predict cloud cover. You choose. For us to have any sort of reasonable discussion about this "science" of yours, you actually have to make some testable hypothesis. Without that we have bupkis go on. You're the person saying something bad is going to happen. Logically you have to have some idea of what output amounts to "bad". It's your problem, not mine. Have the conversation that we're having, not some other conversation you wish we were having. We have no idea how gravity works, yet we are able to model it quite accurately. Why? Let's take a look at your examples to see what we can learn there: life evolving, embryonic development, etc. These examples are complex systems that we can only make Bayesian links between. Why would we do that? Because we're still in the process of abduction in a lot of these areas. Nothing wrong with that. With gravity we've moved to induction. But it means that the science in those fields has not advanced to the same point as physics, for instance. Various fields of science are harder or softer than others. Because you choose to conflate all of this for purposes of argumentation, let me give you an easy discrimination rule: the amount of data observed makes correlation more reliable even if hypotheses are flimsy. To give a real-world example, if I go to my doctor with cancer, he prescribes some medications. Now even though he may have no idea of how cancer works or be able to predict how it will progress in me, I can have confidence his treatment will be "mostly" good. Why? Because he has a million other cancer cases to statistically draw on. He may have not idea why the treatment he is using works (he may have not deduced any rules), but he knows from the patterns of a large set of data that, given a certain treatment, most patients get better. (He has abductively progressed) Compare to those millions of patients (or millions of embryos or millions of cells to use your example) to the global warming guys who have one earth and about a hundred years of data. That's like me going to a witch doctor for brain surgery. Ain't happening. The problem we have is that the softer the science and the sparser the data, the more easily Kuhn's observation of scientific paradigms plays itself out in research. In other words, groupthink takes over. It's very difficult to get anybody to believe that scientific consensus means anything when talking about integrals, but if you're talking about something like psychology consensus is really all you have. That's because without an inductive model we're stuck looking at data and attempting to find patterns. Biology sits nicely between hard and soft sciences. So it's a good example. The basic chemistry we have down. Some of the other stuff we're just guessing. So while I think it's very interesting that current scientific thinking is that some sort of string theory explains the universe, I'll feel a lot better when we have a theory that can't be bent into saying whatever you'd like it to say. While I think evolution is a profitable and reasonable generally good thing for folks to believe, I don't think it's the answer to every open biological question there is. It's simply the best we have to address the big questions. And while I'm certain the absorption spectra of various greenhouse gases are well known and reliable, I'm completely unwilling to take that simple piece of data and extrapolate it using various forms of cellular automata into predictions of world-wide catastrophe. Yes, scientists are doing all of these things, and I'm sure it would hurt their feelings to hear that they're just blowing smoke up each other's posteriors, but that's all it amounts to. Guesswork. Relying on the paradigm because that's all we have. It's a great starting place. Now just complete the circle of the scientific method to get something useful out of it.