6 ms·
Scientific literacy is no shield against anti-evolutionists or global warming deniers, for example, who are often scientists themselves, who couch their argumen
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Scientific literacy is no shield against anti-evolutionists or global warming deniers, for example, who are often scientists themselves, who couch their arguments in sophisticated scientific language, and who regularly cite articles in the peer-reviewed scientific literature. Having the knowledge equivalent of a PhD is more along the lines of what’s necessary to refute them, and even then, the task requires considerable research and intellectual labor, far more than most people have the time for.
As a "global warming denier", now I'm being lumped into the anti-evolutionist camp. What's next? Sticking us in with the flat-earthers and the folks who believe men didn't walk on the moon? Perhaps we can be included with the holocaust deniers. That's a fun group.
Science is about adbuction (inferring patterns from data), deduction (inferring rules from patterns), and induction (inferring new data from rules). You hypothesize and test to validate, and it's always provisional.
That means that science doesn't play the role of the oracle of ultimate truth. As the article points out, for scientists to take on this role is counter-productive.
Taking a cheap shot at the critics of current global warming theory is just so much political genuflecting. The article could have done without it.
- rimantas 17y agoThat bothers me too. I would not call myself AGW denier, more like agnostic with some inclination to believe, but this attitude that if you don't believe in god that makes you believe that the Earth is flat is just stupid. The whole GW issue to me looks most alike to faith from them all.
- timr 17y ago"As a "global warming denier", now I'm being lumped into the anti-evolutionist camp. What's next? Sticking us in with the flat-earthers and the folks who believe men didn't walk on the moon....Taking a cheap shot at the critics of current global warming theory is just so much political genuflecting." Misuse of the word "theory" to imply debate where none exists puts you squarely in the same rhetorical camp as anti-evolutionists. It's not a cheap shot to group pseudo-scientific criticisms based on the common logical fallacies used to advance their respective agendas.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoHypothesize and validate. It's as simple as that. If that puts me in some rhetorical camp of yours (or anybody else's) then I'm happy to be there.
- timr 17y agoShow me the part of your comment where you advance and validate a hypothesis.
- ars 17y agoYou didn't understand him. Just "having no debate" is NOT a good way or determining "this is science". Until a hypothesis has been tested, it's not science. Global warming has not been tested. It's not even a theory, it's a conjecture, or a hypothesis. Science is not done by majority vote, I don't care that more scientists that not believe in it. By that criterion phlogiston and luminiferous aether were both science. Until you test it, it's just an idea.
- timr 17y agoI understood him perfectly. There have been multiple, public IPCC reports, summarizing thousands of peer-reviewed, scientific journal articles documenting global warming in fields as diverse as oceanography, geology, biology, ecology and chemistry over the last 30 years. Meanwhile, neither of you have provided evidence for your own opinions, yet you have the gall to characterize an entire field of scientific research as completely false. This exchange is a case study of why global warming critics are rhetorically identical to anti-evolutionists and flat-earth believers: it's trivially easy to throw stones from the fringe of a scientific debate, then hide behind the fallacy that that you're the unsung outsider, defending science from the bad logic of the mainstream. It's a remarkably convenient position, since it allows you to criticize everything, but provide evidence for nothing.
- varjag 17y ago