4 ms·
This false dichotomy is seriously getting annoying. If 60 hours is sustainable for you, do it. If only 30 hours is sustainable for you, do that instead. Two di
by joe_the_user 13y ago
This false dichotomy is seriously getting annoying. If 60 hours is sustainable for you, do it. If only 30 hours is sustainable for you, do that instead.
Two different things are frustrating about this simple homily.
* It's very easy to fool yourself into thinking you can handle things you can't, especially with peer pressure, job pressure and so-forth involved. By the time your health is ruined, your marriage is ruined and etc, it's too late to just say "uh, that didn't work for me". IE, for every "unique physiology", there twenty self-deceivers. I mean, what are the odds? Next, tell me you have "unique physiology" that gets healthier on Cheetos and Ramen (not impossible so it must be true, right).
* The poor result of a permanent 60-hour week aren't just felt by those who make the mistake of following it but by their families and their co-workers.
Sure, freedom. I mean, this article obviously isn't about physically blocking someone from working 60 hours at their workplace but rather encouraging the person to think again whether those 60 hours really make sense.
- stretchwithme 13y agoIts even easier to fool yourself into thinking you can't handle things that actually can handle. At least when you take on something that's too much, there are signs of failing or your wellbeing declining.
- joe_the_user 13y agoIts even easier to fool yourself into thinking you can't handle things that actually can handle. I don't know if that's true or not. It's probably too vague to be even true or false. But it also seems like a dangerous sort of symmetry to invoke because the consequences of going beyond your capacities tend to be a lot worse than the consequences of not quite reaching them. I recall you as fitness person from other discussion - what's worse, not stretching as much as your tendons allow or stretching more than your tendons allow? In the case of work, as noted by the people here mentioning studies, most people can push themselves for short periods. But that pushing is definitely going involving learning to ignore tiredness and such. But you take that skill and use it ignore your constant tiredness, you can get to a really bad place after a while. In other words, I disagree with any contention that a person's body provides a magic signal that distinguishes between "hard but you can handle it" and "too much for you, you must stop or suffer bad consequences". The degree to which people do harm themselves today shows this.
- stretchwithme 13y agoI guess if there are negative consequences and you aren't able to detect them and respond appropriately, then you'd not attempt anything. Its too dangerous for you.
- joe_the_user 13y agoI'm saying that someone is going to attempt something that pushes them to significant physical limits, they need to have good controls. Feeling like you can do something should be supplement by some understanding. When I teach stretching and movement, I advice my student to only go to the edge of their "comfort zone" at any one point and I only teach certain stretches. It's known that most people's limberness can be gradually increased so that's relatively safe. It's pretty well known (see studies on this page) that most people can't "learn" to go without sleep and I wouldn't advice them to try to do so (the point of the article). And I can believe a few people who in the right place at the right time and brutally push themselves can get rich, rich, rich. That doesn't take away from the point of most people who work with extended years of sleep deprivation screwing themselves up (and this can include a fair fraction of the first group). Sure, push yourself to greatness. I like to push the quality of my activity, not the quantity anyway.
- RodericDay 13y agonot to mention the tragedy of the commons interns who work for free prevent people from asking for wages for their work, to name one example.